Again, such an emphasized return? Relax ya old fart. Finally completed my engineering degree though, doubt that suggests limited intelligence, a bit baseless don't you think. Something must of got you into a bit of a mood today fella, don't worry I'm sure brooksy will give you a performance on the weekend to cheer ya
Luke Brooks #167
- Thread starter rihannafan1
- Start date
earl
Well-known member
It's pretty funny right.
The Brooks debate continues on the WTF.
Those against, rightly using the argument that the definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and over again and expecting a different outcome, blaming the coach and club for his continued selection all while saying the same thing over and over again expecting a different outcome.
Those in favour, rightly so highlighting his achievement’s and skills all while supporting a team that has achieved nothing in the last 10 years culminating in a wooden spoon.
Man it’s like watching a fight at woolies over toilet paper. I don’t know if I want to laugh or cry.
Those against, rightly using the argument that the definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and over again and expecting a different outcome, blaming the coach and club for his continued selection all while saying the same thing over and over again expecting a different outcome.
Those in favour, rightly so highlighting his achievement’s and skills all while supporting a team that has achieved nothing in the last 10 years culminating in a wooden spoon.
Man it’s like watching a fight at woolies over toilet paper. I don’t know if I want to laugh or cry.
earl
Well-known member
It's sad that so many fans want to blame one player for every loss and we have a lot of them. The stats recently posted basically confirmed that narrative is completely wrong. We win a lot more games with Brooks in the team compared to Brooks out of the team. We don't win a lot of games though.
Still he has some shockers at times and the club has rightly been playing him as a running half. You could call that a 6. I wish they'd just give him the 6 jumper and if he isn't good enough for that position punt him at the end of this season.
bythebeardofzeus
Well-known member
Also Twal dropped the ball over the line & then ran an obstruction which lead to another try disallowed. We really could’ve & should’ve won comfortably.
Earl I know what you have been saying about Luke and he will be better as the weeks progress,I have no argument with that,however we must draw the line on comparing Madden's games to Luke's ,Jock was an honest ressie player who did his best...he was on far smaller money and wasn't hyped up as much as Luke...I liked Jock because he tried his best with limited ability compared to Luke...
earl
Well-known member
I agree. Brooks is on a ridiculous salary. If he was on half what he is now the situation changes. He hasn't performed much better than any of our halves. I thought Hastings was our best half last season then Brooks. Madden wasn't far off. Doueihi has some great moments but too many errors in him.
crazycat
Well-known member
The one thing that keeps sticking out for me with Brooks.
WT vs Newcastle.
I reckon there is no one on the forum that wouldn't have wanted us to keep Hastings at 7, and let Brooks go to Newcastle (or where ever).
Swap Brooks for Hastings that round 2 game and I see us winning. Hands down winning.
Anyone else not see an improved Tigers with Hastings at 7 vs Brooks at 7?
Less money
Better options and a true halfback.
WT vs Newcastle.
I reckon there is no one on the forum that wouldn't have wanted us to keep Hastings at 7, and let Brooks go to Newcastle (or where ever).
Swap Brooks for Hastings that round 2 game and I see us winning. Hands down winning.
Anyone else not see an improved Tigers with Hastings at 7 vs Brooks at 7?
Less money
Better options and a true halfback.
Yeah....
They made their decision though.
Another year of Brooks.
Brooks is off contract after this season...
You'd think he'd play better, being contract season and all... haven't seen it in the first two games.
I'd like us to go another direction and not re-new Brooks, but this club constantly surprises with stupid decisions.
Who was your 3,2,1 last week?
I didn't participate.
Missed the first 10 mins or so because I was watching Tsyzu fight... then from what I saw, I'd struggle to pick 1 - let alone 3.
😂😂😂
Safer - Than having to give Brooks 3?
Brooks ain't it chief.
Heads and Shoulders above the others last week boss....
And that's a real problem.
Last week was close to the worst game of rugby league I've ever seen.
No idea why or how it took that direction.
Low expectations for Sunday but I hope it clicks soon.
Pascoes_barber
Well-known member
Best player in one of the worst performances in the club’s history. What an accolade.
WesternSuburbsBoy
Well-known member
hey did you also know he won the dally m halfback of the year in 2018?
It's called simply the best.
pawsandclaws1
Well-known member
Wrong.
