Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[Halbrowne61]

Joffa wasn’t just rated by us.
He was well ranked competition wide.

Right, that’s why we gave him a really good contract and he came out and showed that this year.
As I’ve said before, last year he was an above average player in a terrible team. And this year his shortcomings were exposed.
He’s on the way down, not up, exactly like Frizzel IMO.
But each to their own.

 

[earl]

Whilst I agree he hasn't been up to his barnstorming attacking best - I largely think having the standard of quality of half in Moses and Brown at Parra feeding him the right ball at the right time is a contributing factor to this.

I think we however, aren't acknowledging the work and effort area's he puts in defence. . IP is constantly chasing kicks, making multiple tackle effort plays and is always the first at attempting to charge down a kick, considering he comes from an edge, it's these 1% and heart that we have lacked for many years. Never saw Garner or Tuilagi making those plays.

I agree. He hasn't been bad. I just want more from him.

 

[WesternSuburbsBoy]

Whilst I agree he hasn't been up to his barnstorming attacking best - I largely think having the standard of quality of half in Moses and Brown at Parra feeding him the right ball at the right time is a contributing factor to this.

I think we however, aren't acknowledging the work and effort area's he puts in defence. . IP is constantly chasing kicks, making multiple tackle effort plays and is always the first at attempting to charge down a kick, considering he comes from an edge, it's these 1% and heart that we have lacked for many years. Never saw Garner or Tuilagi making those plays.

Yep shows the difference of class between the two halves. Even Bryce Cartwright has improved massively playing outside of Moses which is saying something lol. I feel Brooks has never been able to use his 2nd rower properly his whole career... he looks outside everytime but always just hits his 2nd rower with a short ball while they're basically flat footed. Very predictable.

 

[Lukic]

The problem with Papali'i is coaching and Brooks.

The lines he's running don't make sense, especially with Brooks' game. He should be coming against the grain a lot more given how he's almost impossible to stop with arm tackles and the fact that Brooks speed across field will have defenders sliding and off-balance whenever someone cuts back.

Brooks is also poor at drawing and passing in a structured attack and at putting outside men in holes. He doesn't isolate defenders well and also telegraphs the pass too early. It's very apparent from just about the minute he touches the ball whether he's running or passing. Too diagonal when he runs - needs to be straighter to square up the defender and engage them, or if going across field, have the outside men running those against the grain lines.

He lacks the deceptiveness and sleight of hand that you see in guys like Walker and Hynes who routinely create linebreaks or linebreak assists for their outside men. Hynes in particular is a master at squaring up the defender and dropping those short balls to his outside runner, while Walker despite being tiny constantly breaks the line by keeping defenders guessing mixing up his acceleration, footwork and playing them with his eyes.

 

[BlackWhiteGold]

The 3 positions we need to look at currently in order of most important to least are Half > Lock > Centre.

It is possible Star continues his good form and I think Tupou will naturally progress to a centre over time. We also have Naden who could be good if he improves on his discipline & Feledy is joining the squad next year and has some wraps on him. I would expect AD to return as a centre as Bula has fullback locked up and we look better with Wakeham in the halves. That is if he does return and if not then we have pretty good centre money free at the end of next year.

Matamua could be ready for lock soon, but he might not be. Plenty of players with a lot of talk behind them recently have stunk it up for us. The ones that have been really good have been the ones with a lot less talk (e.g. Bula, Pole). The ones with big wraps (Simpkin, Tuki, Hoffman, Madden, Talua, Blore) haven't kicked on at all.

Our junior halves are a few years away and we can not wait. Wakeham is great for a backup half but we are a 4th-6th place team with someone like Hunt. I do not know if someone like L. Fainu gets us to top 8 if paired with Brooks next year.

I agree with Half but I would have Impact Prop (instead of Lock) and agree on Centre/Wing in 3rd.

I feel that Fonua Pole will transition to our predominant Impact Prop but we need another in our Top 30 (possibly could be an upgrade for Aitasi James).

If Talau is moving on as rumoured, we have T'oa, Naden and then Reilly & Feledy as our centre options. Yes Tupou could transition to centre with Nofa & Staines on the wing but Tupou atm has more value for us developing as a damaging winger.

IMO Feledy is going to be a gun explosive centre but I would rather him spend an entire season in Cup in '24 with a focus on him getting physically stronger, increasing leg drive & working on his speed with a Roger Fabri type. He would be found out defensively against men atm. Has a real Kotoni Staggs feel about him without being as fast over longer distances.

 

[851]

The problem with Papali'i is coaching and Brooks.

The lines he's running don't make sense, especially with Brooks' game. He should be coming against the grain a lot more given how he's almost impossible to stop with arm tackles and the fact that Brooks speed across field will have defenders sliding and off-balance whenever someone cuts back.

Brooks is also poor at drawing and passing in a structured attack and at putting outside men in holes. He doesn't isolate defenders well and also telegraphs the pass too early. It's very apparent from just about the minute he touches the ball whether he's running or passing. Too diagonal when he runs - needs to be straighter to square up the defender and engage them, or if going across field, have the outside men running those against the grain lines.

He lacks the deceptiveness and sleight of hand that you see in guys like Walker and Hynes who routinely create linebreaks or linebreak assists for their outside men. Hynes in particular is a master at squaring up the defender and dropping those short balls to his outside runner, while Walker despite being tiny constantly breaks the line by keeping defenders guessing mixing up his acceleration, footwork and playing them with his eyes.

Spot on, Brooks whole career has been littered with him giving short hospital passes at 100 miles per hour to his secondrower, he has never, and never will it seems been able to put his backrowers through a hole. Poor old Rowdy got smashed from pillar to post trying to catch Brooks passes, the like of Hynes and Walker as you mentioned are masters at it, and look at all the tries this creates for their outside men

 

[WestsEffTheRest]

The problem with Papali'i is coaching and Brooks.

The lines he's running don't make sense, especially with Brooks' game. He should be coming against the grain a lot more given how he's almost impossible to stop with arm tackles and the fact that Brooks speed across field will have defenders sliding and off-balance whenever someone cuts back.

Brooks is also poor at drawing and passing in a structured attack and at putting outside men in holes. He doesn't isolate defenders well and also telegraphs the pass too early. It's very apparent from just about the minute he touches the ball whether he's running or passing. Too diagonal when he runs - needs to be straighter to square up the defender and engage them, or if going across field, have the outside men running those against the grain lines.

He lacks the deceptiveness and sleight of hand that you see in guys like Walker and Hynes who routinely create linebreaks or linebreak assists for their outside men. Hynes in particular is a master at squaring up the defender and dropping those short balls to his outside runner, while Walker despite being tiny constantly breaks the line by keeping defenders guessing mixing up his acceleration, footwork and playing them with his eyes.

Summed it up perfectly mate. Ice is a talented kid, he will come good.

 

[tony soprano]

The problem with Papali'i is coaching and Brooks.

The lines he's running don't make sense, especially with Brooks' game. He should be coming against the grain a lot more given how he's almost impossible to stop with arm tackles and the fact that Brooks speed across field will have defenders sliding and off-balance whenever someone cuts back.

Brooks is also poor at drawing and passing in a structured attack and at putting outside men in holes. He doesn't isolate defenders well and also telegraphs the pass too early. It's very apparent from just about the minute he touches the ball whether he's running or passing. Too diagonal when he runs - needs to be straighter to square up the defender and engage them, or if going across field, have the outside men running those against the grain lines.

He lacks the deceptiveness and sleight of hand that you see in guys like Walker and Hynes who routinely create linebreaks or linebreak assists for their outside men. Hynes in particular is a master at squaring up the defender and dropping those short balls to his outside runner, while Walker despite being tiny constantly breaks the line by keeping defenders guessing mixing up his acceleration, footwork and playing them with his eyes.

I guess he suited Arthur's crash and bash. I've observed Arthur doesn't have much regard for player safety but Papali’i seems to have the body to manage it.

Sheens plays with more finesse and less crash and bash of his players which are player like papali seems to struggle with. Maybe similar to Blair?

 

[tony soprano]

Brent Read said Laurie won't get a contract next year and could go before the cut off this year.

 

[Halbrowne61]

Brent Read said Laurie won't get a contract next year and could go before the cut off this year.

Yep, unfortunately the best he can hope for is Reggie’s full back. The 5/8 experience never worked ( if it was even really contemplated).
Someone will pick him up as a utility back.

 

[Tigers_Wests]

Brent Read said Laurie won't get a contract next year and could go before the cut off this year.

No real surprise there about next year. Would imagine he only gets release in 2023 if Staines returns early enough to be fullback cover.

 

[supercoach]

Cant see Staines hanging around to be back up full back and back up winger. He should get an offer elsewhere. Although I would love to have him stay

 

[batboy]

Joffa wasn’t just rated by us.
He was well ranked competition wide.

That would explain why the Broncos paid him to play for us when he came down…
(Forgot he’s a qlder)

Ranked by clubs who bought themselves into a corner and were hoping to get a bargain when we put him back in ressies… and that’s about it.

 

[Halbrowne61]

Cant see Staines hanging around to be back up full back and back up winger. He should get an offer elsewhere. Although I would love to have him stay

So the cost of Bula is going to be ( possibly) no f/b back up. More opportunities for local juniors I guess.

 

[teddy23]

Brooks is our $1.1 million dollar halfback/leader. Reality is the club should’ve never offered him that money, let alone that position. The pressure and responsibility of being our halfback and making that sum of money doesn’t suit Brooks play or persona.

Unfortunately Papali’i hasn’t been able to be as effective attacking wise, his last two years at Parra he scored 17 tries. So far with us halfway through the year he only has 1 try.

Brooks biggest weakness imo is utilising his edge forwards, probably the most predictable play in football is his short no look pass to the edge which Papali’i has been accustom to so far this year.

Bateman is the type of who goes looking for the football and likes to cut in the inside and create for himself. So he can still be able to impact the game due to his playstyle regardless on his halfback. Whereas Papali’i needs direction and allows his work rate and strength to do the rest.

Defensively Papali’i has been unreal, so his work ethic and effort hasn’t dropped at all. It’s just his ability to be injected from an attacking perspective by his halfback.

This isn’t a bash Brooks post… I think he can be one of the best 6’s in the league and personally don’t know why the club keep persisting with him at 7.

Brooks strengths is his running game and has really improved his kicking game so far this year imo, but having a genuine 7 next to him to steer the team around and inject our edge rowers more and giving Brooks the sole role of just running the football, creating overlapping plays and taking some kicks will take him even to another level. The emergence of Bula and the experience of Api is helping create a lot of space for Brooks to take the line on as the spaces opening up are becoming larger. Adding that genuine 7 will even further that more.

Wakeham has been impressive but currently we’re playing like a 10-12th ranked team and we keep improving however I don’t think we’ll ever reach the heights of being a top 8 team with them as our halves combination. He’s definitely earned the right to be our backup half however.

I genuinely believe we’re one position away from being a top 8 team…. to me it’s clear that Ben Hunt is the answer each day goes past more statements are coming out about him wanting out. May as well try get in front of the line.

 

[Vicious]

So the cost of Bula is going to be ( possibly) no f/b back up. More opportunities for local juniors I guess.

A fit and healthy Charlie Staines surely starts somewhere in our backline.
He is by far the fastest player on our roster and before injury showed he’s willing to play with the intensity and toughness required to be a quality NRL player.
Start him as a winger or centre, just don’t let him go elsewhere.

 

[Tucker]

Right, that’s why we gave him a really good contract and he came out and showed that this year.
As I’ve said before, last year he was an above average player in a terrible team. And this year his shortcomings were exposed.
He’s on the way down, not up, exactly like Frizzel IMO.
But each to their own.

That is beside the point you were arguing.
It wasn’t some Mickey Mouse award Frizell won last year and neither was Joffa’s.

 

[Halbrowne61]

A fit and healthy Charlie Staines surely starts somewhere in our backline.
He is by far the fastest player on our roster and before injury showed he’s willing to play with the intensity and toughness required to be a quality NRL player.
Start him as a winger or centre, just don’t let him go elsewhere.

Agree V, I was hoping we could keep him.

 

[Vicious]

That is beside the point you were arguing.
It wasn’t some Mickey Mouse award Frizell won last year and neither was Joffa’s.

We already have Klemmer who works hard, Twal who works hard, Papali’i who works hard, Bateman who works hard, we need a few fast, athletic, tackle busting, line breaking forwards to complement the hard workers.
Frizell is just an other ageing and slowing hard worker, he won’t help us climb the ladder.
Same with some people suggesting Sezer as our halfback, we are trying to win the NRL, not the National over 30’s competition.

 

[Tucker]

We already have Klemmer who works hard, Twal who works hard, Papali’i who works hard, Bateman who works hard, we need a few fast, athletic, tackle busting, line breaking forwards to complement the hard workers.
Frizell is just an other ageing and slowing hard worker, he won’t help us climb the ladder.
Same with some people suggesting Sezer as our halfback, we are trying to win the NRL, not the National over 30’s competition.

I’m not pushing the Frizell barrow too much, but the guy is still Origin material and was the Blues best player last Wednesday.
I’d much prefer a young Tapine or Luki type if they are around.