Unless the 2024 Roster changes before March 2024 Wests Tigers cannot make the finals!

D

DUCK

Well-known member
I will answer my own Statement. "Good one Scoop"! The club is so short of talent for our Rookie Coach to work with next year, and any expectations beyond a wooden spoon threepeat is unrealistic. The quality is not Top 4 standard for NSW CUP. Winning more than 4 games as per years 2022 & 2023 may very well be unrealistic. As a supporter I see no light at the end of the tunnel. The forum posters are sincere but have no answers and the key club administrators are in denial. One giant hole has been dug and the fans are the ones trapped and struggling for air.
 
Our goose is already cooked. We could not have had a better recruitment drive than we had leading into this season. It’s going to take a lot more than a good centre. And chances are, if we land one, he’ll underperform, as most players that come here do.
 
DUCK said:
I will answer my own Statement. "Good one Scoop"! The club is so short of talent for our Rookie Coach to work with next year, and any expectations beyond a wooden spoon threepeat is unrealistic. The quality is not Top 4 standard for NSW CUP. Winning more than 4 games as per years 2022 & 2023 may very well be unrealistic. As a supporter I see no light at the end of the tunnel. The forum posters are sincere but have no answers and the key club administrators are in denial. One giant hole has been dug and the fans are the ones trapped and struggling for air.
Click to expand...
The club has already stated they don’t plan on ‘winning’ until (atleast) 2025.
 
  • Wow
Reactions: BZN
Demps said:
Recruitment is key

We got the gun 9 and hopefully our halves options work out for us in 2024...

But we need a whole new backline almost

If Stef and Ice want to go, let's make that happen too.
Click to expand...
So you want to let 2 solid 1st graders go and replace them with who….please don’t tell me that our Juniors are the way to go.
So unless they have players knocking down the doors to sign with the wooden spooners no no no no no.
 
Fallen Angel said:
Our goose is already cooked. We could not have had a better recruitment drive than we had leading into this season. It’s going to take a lot more than a good centre. And chances are, if we land one, he’ll underperform, as most players that come here do.
Click to expand...
Except we focused solely on the forwards and relied on what we already had in the backline, most notably a halfback who hadn’t proven himself in over 10 years of footy!
Halves now changed and hopefully some better additions to the centres and we may actually get somewhere next season. Don’t know about anyone else but I long for the glory days of finishing 9th 😂
 
craigtob said:
So you want to let 2 solid 1st graders go and replace them with who….please don’t tell me that our Juniors are the way to go.
So unless they have players knocking down the doors to sign with the wooden spooners no no no no no.
Click to expand...
They haven't said they will leave... however the articles keep coming out.

We ain't going to be top 4 next year so are we delaying the inevitable?

I'd like us to sign Josh Curran as a 13 and Huuamole Olakautau to replace Ice.

Blore can replace Stef and Samuela onto the bench.

Why not!
 
Flippedy said:
Except we focused solely on the forwards and relied on what we already had in the backline, most notably a halfback who hadn’t proven himself in over 10 years of footy!
Halves now changed and hopefully some better additions to the centres and we may actually get somewhere next season. Don’t know about anyone else but I long for the glory days of finishing 9th 😂
Click to expand...
So it’s the backline now. Running out of excuses.
 
craigtob said:
So you want to let 2 solid 1st graders go and replace them with who….please don’t tell me that our Juniors are the way to go.
So unless they have players knocking down the doors to sign with the wooden spooners no no no no no.
Click to expand...
Exactly retaining is just as important as recruiting. You don't let two good ones go to replace them - or just end up in the same position or worse.
You add to those two to give them someone to play beside that strengthens the side and gives some hope of being competitive.
 
Telltails said:
Exactly retaining is just as important as recruiting. You don't let two good ones go to replace them - or just end up in the same position or worse.
You add to those two to give them someone to play beside that strengthens the side and gives some hope of being competitive.
Click to expand...
You don't let them go...
Unless they legitimately have clauses in their contracts for them to walk out.

Which is a possibility.
 
batboy said:
You mean the same forwards that got a towelling last night from Ethan Bullemor, Jake Turbo and Keppie?
been getting a towelling most of the year.... Those ones?
Click to expand...
We were missing Bateman & Utoikamanu last night.

Pole is one of the best young forwards in the game - still eligible for fleg.

I think we need a genuine 13... and yes, the pack will be fine.. as it's been most of the year as the problem hasn't been getting down the field but Red zone attack, getting repeat sets and scoring points.
 
Demps said:
We were missing Bateman & Utoikamanu last night.

Pole is one of the best young forwards in the game - still eligible for fleg.

I think we need a genuine 13... and yes, the pack will be fine.. as it's been most of the year as the problem hasn't been getting down the field but Red zone attack, getting repeat sets and scoring points.
Click to expand...
Saw Samuela in KOC today - I realise that the Fainus have a lot of brothers but I reckon he was separated at birth from Stefano! They will be the new bookends in years to come. Hell, they'll be the entire Encyclopaedia of Bookends!
 
batboy said:
We were also playing a team for spots outside the 8!!
- Missing quite a few of their top forwards as well...

Pole is the only middle we have worth feeding for mine....
Click to expand...
Twal has taken it up another level this year.

We need a genuine lock.
I'd be trying as hard as we can to sign Curran.

The kid Kitt looked very promising in that woeful performance.
Anyway, I'm hoping the spine is much improved next year - really unlocking the forwards but we definitely need some better backs.
 
Demps said:
Recruitment is key

We got the gun 9 and hopefully our halves options work out for us in 2024...

But we need a whole new backline almost

If Stef and Ice want to go, let's make that happen too.
Click to expand...
Stef is part of the reason we haven't played finals footy. When is the last time he has put on a big hit to change momentum when the game needs it? Every club needs an enforcer. The door is there Stef. Surely you want to be part of a successful redbuild. Parra are no longer in their premiership window so you're not winning a premiership there.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BZN
upthetigers said:
Stef is part of the reason we haven't played finals footy. When is the last time he has put on a big hit to change momentum when the game needs it? Every club needs an enforcer. The door is there Stef. Surely you want to be part of a successful redbuild. Parra are no longer in their premiership window so you're not winning a premiership there.
Click to expand...
It's on them to help the team improve.

So they should put the work in.
Ice was trash last night and I've seen Stef fire up like 3 times. He's soft.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 734 (members: 27, guests: 707)
Back
Top