Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

tony soprano said:
The coaching staff were abysmal this year. We had a better squad than the previous year and still came last. You cannot roll into a preseason the way they did. They were under prepared and poorly coached that's on the coaching staff.
Click to expand...
Exactly! Some key players were missing preseason through injury, but they had the last 12 games to get something sorted. Get a team together instead of going on holidays and leaving Noddy to take a hospital pass.
 
Tiger_Yoshi said:
I love Twaly, but this decision, on the back of the clubs decision to release him only 1 month back shows to me the club has no strategic thinking behind its recruiting. They make things up as they go along. I thought Fulton was supposed to be a recruitment guru....dumb, dumb dumb...
Click to expand...
Mate it’s Groundhog Day here.

The coach decides he needs an upgrade, the club can’t sign a dead fish, so the coach doesn’t get his upgrade.

Then they sack the coach.
 
batboy said:
The Melbourne release isn't in the same postcode as the Dogs issues....
I've claimed here repeatedly, If Addo-Carr stayed in Sydney - He wouldn't be the player he is
(Stating the obvious when it comes to Bellamys coaching)
But Sydney itself I've always felt - Is the worst place for him....

It seemed like every time he came back he was in some sort of mischief....
He'd also have a lot of hangers on in Sydney... Not always a good thing.
Click to expand...
Spoke openly about it on Denans podcast a long time ago.

Trouble at Souths- cut.
Then Sharks he really got a chance to play, then us.... then he became a weapon at Melbourne.

Hasn't been the same since leaving.
He's now trying to be an influencer, pushing his clothing line, portraying himself a certain way online.
 
Kelce68 said:
I have absolutely no issue with the Bateman signing and would place my house on the fact that he will be better next year with a far better off season.
Click to expand...
Even if he is, what about the two years after that? He'll start the 2025 season at age 31, as a sub-100kg back row forward with nearly 300 games in his body. Expecting him to be good in 2025-26 is extreme wishful thinking. I'll give you an optimistic case: let's say he's good next year, ok in 2025 and one step from retirement in 2026. For a marquee player's salary over four years we'll have got one good, one ok and two poor seasons. That's bad business whichever way you slice it. My concern when we signed him was that his first season, given the type of player he is, his track record and his age, was almost certain to be his best.
 
batboy said:
Back to be closer to his daughter....

They also made him stay for an extra year after they'd organised for him to leave....
They're NOT doing that if he's a shit human - No matter how you spin it.

Surely you of all people would remember Lee's 'Heads of Agreement'
Click to expand...
Current information leads me to believe there was a bit more to it.
 
batboy said:
Can you provide any details on it?
As it stands - If the numbers thrown around for next year are close to accurate, He's getting paid too much.
I'd guess the extension is at a lesser rate - Spread over more years....
If anyone has any brains, That's what it is....

For the upteenth time, I have no real problem with Twal,
Only of the opinion shared here he's one of the best players in the game
(If not the world - Or any other big place)

And that he's in every teams Starting 13....
I just don't think he is... Even this year, All and sundry are banging on about how he'd improved....
I'd like to see his highlights reel.

He's in the 17 of a Stronger side for sure....
But we've got far too many holes for us to rely on a player of his level as heavily as we do.
Said as much - Many times....
But there it is again for you curiosity...

ps: I'm guessing you have no details to share on the new contract?
Click to expand...
Reports are that his deal is going from $525k to $400k with the new contract.
 
batboy said:
Can you provide any details on it?
As it stands - If the numbers thrown around for next year are close to accurate, He's getting paid too much.
I'd guess the extension is at a lesser rate - Spread over more years....
If anyone has any brains, That's what it is....

For the upteenth time, I have no real problem with Twal,
Only of the opinion shared here he's one of the best players in the game
(If not the world - Or any other big place)

And that he's in every teams Starting 13....
I just don't think he is... Even this year, All and sundry are banging on about how he'd improved....
I'd like to see his highlights reel.

He's in the 17 of a Stronger side for sure....
But we've got far too many holes for us to rely on a player of his level as heavily as we do.
Said as much - Many times....
But there it is again for you curiosity...

ps: I'm guessing you have no details to share on the new contract?
Click to expand...

I’ve made like 30: comments about Twal over the past 24 hours if you want to check Them out
 
guywolf said:
Wests Tigers fan favourite Alex Twal is set to remain with the club until at least the end of the 2027 season after adding an additional three years to his current deal.

www.nrl.com

2025 NRL Signings Tracker: Rabbitohs extend gun fullback; Feagai joins Titans

Livewire fullback Jye Gray has signed a three-year extension with the South Sydney Rabbitohs while the Gold Coast Titans have secured the services of Max Feagai for the next two seasons.
www.nrl.com www.nrl.com
Click to expand...
No doubt he's gone down the Chris Lawrence clubman route here, taken security and passion over dollars. I'd say his contract will have been renegotiated for 2024 and future years so he's on~400k a year over the next 4 years.

He saw what he could get from other clubs and decided it's better to stay for less money than to leave for slightly more
 
Tiger_Yoshi said:
I love Twaly, but this decision, on the back of the clubs decision to release him only 1 month back shows to me the club has no strategic thinking behind its recruiting. They make things up as they go along. I thought Fulton was supposed to be a recruitment guru....dumb, dumb dumb...
Click to expand...
It's actually different in this instance.

We said to him he's free to explore his options so he can gauge what his market value was. If he got a monster off he was free to take it. His market value came back at 400k. In the end he decided he'd rather stay here and earn that here than leave for that same amount. So we've got a solid, reliable but unspectacular forward locked in for a few years. When teh youngsters are struglling over time it's good to have reliable players in the squad.

The club placed a value on his head, allowed him to test it himself, only for him to come back saying he'll take that lesser amount we offered. That's a win for the club.
 
For those saying the Twal situation is a sign of lack of direction etc, i disagree.

I think the club realised his contract value was out of balance. They gave him the opportunity to find a better deal elsewhere & when he couldn't, the Tigers got him re-signed on $100k less per year- a better representation of his value.

One of those occasions where letting him test his market value was actually.....letting him test his market value.

With the release of one my favourites in Joffa, not overspending on Brooks, re-signing young players like Bula & To'a, extending great players like Api, and buying in young starlet players like Fainu x 2...I think we actually see a club that realises their contract values were skewed and are trying to rebalance that side of the ledger.

For mine- that shows.....direction.
 
balmain boy said:
It's actually different in this instance.

We said to him he's free to explore his options so he can gauge what his market value was. If he got a monster off he was free to take it. His market value came back at 400k. In the end he decided he'd rather stay here and earn that here than leave for that same amount. So we've got a solid, reliable but unspectacular forward locked in for a few years. When teh youngsters are struglling over time it's good to have reliable players in the squad.

The club placed a value on his head, allowed him to test it himself, only for him to come back saying he'll take that lesser amount we offered. That's a win for the club.
Click to expand...
Same thing occurred with Keon at South's.
Except he chose to test his value and wasn't asked to.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Staff online

Members online

Total: 807 (members: 27, guests: 780)
Back
Top