Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

tigerman 0 said:
This is probably the most negative thing ive ever read on here and that’s a big statement.
Benji was an absolutely incredible player. Won 2005 when he was very young and should’ve won another comp or two (2011/2012).
Won the Golden Boot and for years was simply unplayable.
Had a million injuries and of course slowed up as he got older.
If a peak Benji clone came on the market there would be 17 clubs falling over themselves to get him.
You either have a short memory or are delusional. I know you’re negative but this is something else
Click to expand...
He is out greatest ever player. And he was also a perennial underachiever. Both statements can be true.

We don't have many greats. Possibly 2-3. He only player finals 3 times for us, that's an underachiever.
 
Let me put it in perspective. If you think that description is grossly off the mark, let’s talk about Sheens. He has been bashed from pillar to post for years, and especially the last year. Rightly so. But look at everything he has done for the club, yet that doesn’t give him a free pass from recent results. With Benji, he was a force of nature from 2005 to 2011. After he came back from rugby, he was maybe a third of the player he was. Thats taking nothing away from what he did at the beginning of his career, but facts are facts. How much of his highlight reel is post 2014? I’m sure everyone has felt the same about him at least once after watching him kick out on the full or pass into the third row. He regressed incredibly. He was a perennial underachiever for not being able to sustain his talent from his early age.
 

The Wests Tigers’ re-signing of Alex Twal and Alex Seyfarth has prompted discussions of another player swap deal, involving out-of-favour Melbourne centre Justin Olam.

Wests Tigers and Melbourne Storm are in talks about a potential player swap which would see premiership winner Justin Olam joining the Tigers next season.

The Tigers and Melbourne have held discussions about Olam signing with the Tigers and the Storm securing forward Shawn Blore in a rare player swap. The Storm have chased Blore already this year and were close to securing him a few months ago when he was given permission to leave the Tigers.

A late minute change of heart prompted the Tigers to hold onto Blore but a few things have changed significantly in their forward stocks since then. Originally they played to have at least one of Alex Twal or Alex Seyfarth leave the club now with Twal secured on a long-term deal and Seyfarth also re-signing for two years, the Tigers now believe they could let Blore go — for the right player.

The Storm’s renewed interest in Blore has prompted the discussions surrounding Olam.

Blore only has 12 months left on his contract while Olam has a deal until the end of 2026.

Olam had an unhappy season at the Storm where the 29-year-old was axed to Queensland Cup for the first time since 2019.

Blore would give the Storm pack starch after their big men were criticised at times this year.

Olam had been linked to the Super League after being sounded out by new Warrington coach Sam Burgess, but that is unlikely.

The Tigers and Storm have shown their hand previous with a historic player swap in 2020 when Harry Grant and Paul Momirovski traded clubs.

Melbourne also tried something similar ahead of 2022 when it considered giving up Brandon Smith for one year before he joined the Roosters in exchange for Stefano Utoikamanu. That was swiftly rejected by the Tigers.

If Olam does leave, the Storm will consider shifting Nick Meaney to centre provided Ryan Papenhuyzen can return to full fitness. They also have youngster Sualauvi Fa’alogo ready to play regular first grade. The Storm are yet to add a player for next season despite Tariq Sims (Catalans), Jayden Nikorima (Catalans), George Jennings (released), Jordan Grant (released) and Tom Eisenhuth (released) leaving. The Tigers have been fair more active with Latu Fainu (Sea Eagles), Samuela Fainu (Sea Eagles), Jayden Sullivan (Dragons) and Aidan Sezer (Leeds Rhinos) among the new recruits.
 
WesternSuburbsBoy said:
Would be peak WT’s to re-sign a plodder like Seyfarth & let go of a promising young forward in Blore more or less for a washed Ola
Click to expand...
Two sides to the coin though...

Blore is promising but he's also injured a lot.
Doesn't help the team by sitting at home, watching the game in his Penrith shorts.

We need centres.
I don't mind Blore - but this is business.

Olam is good, probably past his best.
But it's an area we need strengthening and I'm sure he has something left to offer us.
 
Demps said:
Two sides to the coin though...

Blore is promising but he's also injured a lot.
Doesn't help the team by sitting at home, watching the game in his Penrith shorts.

We need centres.
I don't mind Blore - but this is business.

Olam is good, probably past his best.
But it's an area we need strengthening and I'm sure he has something left to offer us.
Click to expand...
Bro the guy is washed… Bellamy hooked him for the backend of the season & the finals series & he’s been dropped for PNG as well
 
WesternSuburbsBoy said:
Bro the guy is washed… Bellamy hooked him for the backend of the season & the finals series & he’s been dropped for PNG as well
Click to expand...
See what happens...
Not sure the info is concrete.

I'd like the Tigers to make a smart move here and say yeah you can have Blore but you have to take Nofo too.

Like we did to the sharks in the past.

And in return, we aim higher than Olam.
They've got some good players in their squad.
 
Demps said:
See what happens...
Not sure the info is concrete.

I'd like the Tigers to make a smart move here and say yeah you can have Blore but you have to take Nofo too.

Like we did to the sharks in the past.

And in return, we aim higher than Olam.
They've got some good players in their squad.
Click to expand...
Then you are asking for them to clear up another roster spot. More to it than just saying “here, take him too”.
 
Beggars can't be choosers and based on what I saw this year if it was a choice between Olam or Suli - Suli wins hands down. Don't know if it's head or injury with Olam but his drop in form was difficult to digest
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 414 (members: 3, guests: 411)
Forever online: Tigergran, Geo
Back
Top