Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

balmain boy said:
It still amazes me that some people are talking about Galvin playing forwards anytime soon even he's a super skinny Seyfarth body frame, and even now Seyfarth still struggles with the physicality of the league.

Also pretty laughable to think Doueihi might get any gametime this season. He'll pay 7-8 NSW cup games at most before being released at the end of the season. He is not part of the clubs future.
Click to expand...
Galvin should play 5/8 or centre as he serves his apprenticeship. Clubs were chasing him as a 5/8 not a forward. He could play centre as many great 5/8s over the years have done including Laurie Daley, Brett Kenny, Brad Fittler, Ben Ikin, Trent Barrett.
 
WesternSuburbsBoy said:
851 said:
I saw a story today, Olam is quoted as saying “THE TIGERS HAVE A LOT OF FAITH IN ME BECAUSE I WASN'T 100 PER CENT HEALTHY WHEN THEY TALKED TO ME. I WANT TO REPAY THEM AND GET BETTER SO I CAN GO OUT THERE AND COMPETE.”
Click to expand...

Judging from the article released the other day &
Click to expand...
Olam apparently being subsidised by the Storm is a good deal for WTs.

As for Blore, Pole is a higher priority. Any increase in Blore's contract may have been at the expense of Pole. In the end he wanted to be at the Storm. Good luck to him.
 
jrtiger said:
I see the vision with Galvin but the kid does his best work on the edges. I have seen him demoralise the fourth and third man time and time and time again and rarely does he ever take the wrong option.

to put him in the middle takes away his best asset, forces him to make double the tackles and blocks Laulili’i’s path. I like your thinking but ultimately I think the left edge is his spot. whether it’s at 6 or 12 is up to our coaching staff.
Click to expand...
Or centre
 
Camel2281 said:
Or centre
Click to expand...
yeah, centre could work too. he's more Wade Graham than he is Brad Fittler personally. he could do a job at 13 or in the centres but 5/8 and back-row is where he should be. his ability to pick apart opposition defences is world class, probably why he's in contention for a first grade debut despite not being capped at Flegg level.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 851
balmain boy said:
It still amazes me that some people are talking about Galvin playing forwards anytime soon even he's a super skinny Seyfarth body frame, and even now Seyfarth still struggles with the physicality of the league.

Also pretty laughable to think Doueihi might get any gametime this season. He'll pay 7-8 NSW cup games at most before being released at the end of the season. He is not part of the clubs future.
Click to expand...

Agree on Galvin just don’t see him in the forwards anytime soon.

AD it’s up to him to actually own a spot that isn’t in the halves. It’s clear we have moved on from him in the halves. To be fair he looks like he has rehabbed very well wouldn’t surprise me if he hits the footy field before mid year. He can add value for the right price to the squad especially if he had improved his defence efforts/decisions.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 851
WestsTigers4VR said:
Does anybody have access to the interview between Brent Read and Benji Marshall? And how can I watch it without having to pay the td?
Click to expand...
It's not a video, just an article.

It was posted in Page 78 of this thread previously:

Benji Marshall #70

I’d like you to explain the difference between the Warriors in 22 to the Warriors in 23 if coaching had nothing to do with that change. The one main difference I will accept as a contributing factor was the health of Tohu Harris. However come 23 preseason with a couple of old heads replacing...
weststigersforum.com
 
851 said:
I saw a story today, Olam is quoted as saying “THE TIGERS HAVE A LOT OF FAITH IN ME BECAUSE I WASN'T 100 PER CENT HEALTHY WHEN THEY TALKED TO ME. I WANT TO REPAY THEM AND GET BETTER SO I CAN GO OUT THERE AND COMPETE.”
Click to expand...
Hope we've done our due on Olam's injuries... I have more faith now that I would have last year but it is a worrying comment to me.
 
Vicious said:
Although it helps, size is not a determining factor on whether or not someone can play or not, have a look at Reuben Cotter as an example.
As discussed in the past, being short, unfit and slowish is certainly an issue., the same as being big, unfit and lazy is an issue.
If you have inside information that Doueihi won’t get any NRL game time then fair enough, my view is if he got back to somewhere near his best he would certainly be an asset.
Moving forward the 2025 and beyond, he would highly unlikely command the same money he’s been earning over the past few seasons.
Click to expand...
Size does make a difference, when it comes to kids. Especially tall players. They'll get smashed. He has to get his body right for the rigours of the forwards, that's normal, and it just takes some time. For the next few years at least he'll be in the backs.

Doueihi is unlikely to be fit enough to even get on a field before July. And then given it's his third ACL it will take him a long time to get the confidence, strength and agility back in his knee. If he ever does get it back. Even before the injury he was hanging by a thread, no clear position, a poor attitude, terrible in defence.

I doubt any club would even consider him for 2025 on a minimum wage deal. Possibly a club like Dragons who may be desperate, but a train and trial somewhere is most probable. He'll have to prove his fitness, form, and what position he falls into. Dose he have the work rate to play in the back row? Probably about his only option left
 
Last edited:
jrtiger said:
both have a little to work on (Alaimalo with acclimatising to league, Faataape defensively), but if we can give them a couple of months in Cup to work those things out, I think they could unseat our first graders very quickly.
Click to expand...
Doesn't Alaimalo already come from QLD cup where he's been mainstay and players player? He's either ready to go in NRL or he isn't. I'm keen to see him thrown Toas spot asap
 
  • Like
Reactions: 851
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 1,349 (members: 1, guests: 1,348)
Back
Top