Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

Ethan Strange is better than both Galvin and Latu at this stage. Shame he is not here instead.

Its hard to judge Latu given he has been injured and has not played 5/8. They both have potential, Galvin appears slow and as his body fills out more and more muscle goes on the frame I'm not so sure he will remain in the halves.
 
Tom Shines said:
Yeah they just love Bateman at present …

So much that the CEO has just taken an urgent mid week flight to the UK to try to unload him..,

Sounds like a guy very much in their plans
Click to expand...

See Above.....

In no world - Are they (Or anyone else with a Brain) replacing 'Either' Current International Edge Forward,
With your reserve Grade Middle Forward....

I'm sorry, They're just not.
 
batboy said:
Right now, It's Sullivan for me....
If Doueihi sticks around (In another position) then Latu is next for mine...
He'd be decent back up, But decent back up (In the halves) shouldn't cost more than 300k

Could also squeeze a couple more years out of Sezer on a lower contract for back up next year..
Click to expand...
I think Sezer is the decent backup, not Doueihi

The one thing we have seen is that Sezer, has done a job of a halfback. Sure a poorer job then other halfbacks, but we actually see him act as a halfback.

Having him around means Luai and others can actually benefit from experience. I also think a crusier ride may suit Sezer.
 
batboy said:
See Above.....

In no world - Are they (Or anyone else with a Brain) replacing 'Either' Current International Edge Forward,
With your reserve Grade Middle Forward....

I'm sorry, They're just no
Click to expand...

All I said he is in their Top 17…when Ice gets moved on …looking at the current squad

Good chance Bateman has played his last game for the WT …certainly wouldn’t surprise me if Sione plays more games than him the rest of this season …
 
batboy said:
the reality is, Fully fit - There's no spot for him here for the next few years.
Click to expand...
There are spots though. Both 5/8 if Galvin goes to lock. Or lock if Galvin stays at 5/8. Both perfect positions for them once healthy. A great situation to be. But you want to throw the cot when he hasn't even had the chance to play healthy in a position he has played in.

Hating just to hate on a 19 year old.
 
batboy said:
See Above.....

In no world - Are they (Or anyone else with a Brain) replacing 'Either' Current International Edge Forward,
With your reserve Grade Middle Forward....

I'm sorry, They're just not.
Click to expand...
The
"Current International Edge Forward"
Click to expand...
Is playing like a sub on a reserve grade side. He has no reason to be in the team. Sione in his limited impact has a larger impact on the game then Bateman has all year barring two games where he was good in patches
 
Nonotmeagain said:
Do we know that ? The CEO hasn't said so ? And if Bateman doesn't want to go back yet ??
Click to expand...

You mean the CEO hasn’t come out and publicly named the players he is shopping around?

let’s wait and see what happens … the whole situation of him taking this trip is at best very unusual …
 
Furious1 said:
Ethan Strange is better than both Galvin and Latu at this stage. Shame he is not here instead.

Its hard to judge Latu given he has been injured and has not played 5/8. They both have potential, Galvin appears slow and as his body fills out more and more muscle goes on the frame I'm not so sure he will remain in the halves.
Click to expand...
I think in a few years Galvin might become a backrower, unfortunately he just doesn’t have the speed that is needed to be a half full time. Unless he’s willing to try and get his speed up I reckon by 2027 at the latest he’ll be a backrower. Galvin is still our best 6 for now but I think if Latu can remain injury free he’ll be our half with Luai by 2026-27.
 
crazycat said:
That's a fair amount of money off contract.

We have to punt Ice, but it is a crap look for us when a talented player comes here and goes backwards.

that's over 1.5m we can play with. We should be able to hire some strong forwards and muscle as we need to replace Ice.

IMHO, this is not the time to punt Bateman. Sure if we could upgrade him, but I don't think there is anyone on the market we could upgrade him too.

If we loose too many in the front row. Good forwards won't come here to be a punching bag.
Click to expand...
All forwards are punching bags, they do it because they want to make space for the backs.
That is where we let them down!
 
Tom Shines said:
You mean the CEO hasn’t come out and publicly named the players he is shopping around?

let’s wait and see what happens … the whole situation of him taking this trip is at best very unusual …
Click to expand...
Unusual when compared with our last CEO and Pascoe, yes.
But a hands on approach is like this is a breath of fresh air at the moment. Richo our best salesman?
Effort and future planning being played out I imagine [ and successfully, fingers crossed]
 
Tom Shines said:
He is 19 years old …and been here only for a few months … gotta give him a chance …there are guys in their early 20s who have been here for years that seem as far away from NRL standard as ever ..

i was also under the impression that he “develops “ into the $500k a year deal down the road..I thought he was on $250k this season ..

The hamstrings are a concern though … he has been hampered by that since he got here and that can be tough to shake… not a great injury to have at a young age …
Click to expand...
Fainu was earning about $300k at manly I’m surprised he would move to the wooden spooners for $50k less than what he was on. I can believe he isn’t on $500k yet & will be upgraded as the years progress but does anyone have a link or remember an article saying $250k?
 
Tiger Stripes said:
Unusual when compared with our last CEO and Pascoe, yes.
But a hands on approach is like this is a breath of fresh air at the moment. Richo our best salesman?
Effort and future planning being played out I imagine [ and successfully, fingers crossed]
Click to expand...

Something needs to change so I don’t hate it …

Although it does seem at cross purposes with other comments he has made about how 80 percent of the team is already present at the club ..and develop from within etc… this is a very slow way to turn around a club like ours and he has now been there long enough to assess all the younger talent already there …so perhaps he may have changed his mind about this ..

Look at the end of the day… I just want them to win more football games …it’s the only thing that matters ..everything else is just fluff … whatever it takes to make this happen I’m fine with …
 
Glenji95 said:
I think in a few years Galvin might become a backrower, unfortunately he just doesn’t have the speed that is needed to be a half full time. Unless he’s willing to try and get his speed up I reckon by 2027 at the latest he’ll be a backrower. Galvin is still our best 6 for now but I think if Latu can remain injury free he’ll be our half with Luai by 2026-27.
Click to expand...
Richo has said that Galvin reminds him of John Sutton. Debuted as teenagers in the backline for struggling/wooden spoon clubs. Sutton played 5/8 during his 2nd season and then was shifted to lock towards the end of his 3rd season. Similar body shapes, ball skills & speed from memory.

We'll give Latu all the time he needs.

2026 we'll be in a better spot to ascertain both their long-term positions.
 
InGalvinWeTrust said:
The

Is playing like a sub on a reserve grade side. He has no reason to be in the team. Sione in his limited impact has a larger impact on the game then Bateman has all year barring two games where he was good in patches
Click to expand...

Where's the data for that?

They play (Totally) different positions,
And you have 1 game for Sione to reference from.
 
Last edited:
Juice said:
Fainu was earning about $300k at manly I’m surprised he would move to the wooden spooners for $50k less than what he was on. I can believe he isn’t on $500k yet & will be upgraded as the years progress but does anyone have a link or remember an article saying $250k?
Click to expand...

Common sense will serve you no purpose here my friend....
 
InGalvinWeTrust said:
There are spots though. Both 5/8 if Galvin goes to lock. Or lock if Galvin stays at 5/8. Both perfect positions for them once healthy. A great situation to be. But you want to throw the cot when he hasn't even had the chance to play healthy in a position he has played in.

Hating just to hate on a 19 year old.
Click to expand...

One minute you're saying he's not performing because of been played out of position,
The next we're moving him (Out of position) to accommodate him.....
make up your mind?

I've seen enough of Latu to know the quality in him,
But there's a dogged determination, a will to compete and a voice in Galvin that I've not seen in Latu...
So my egg is in the Galvin basket...

Galvin and Luai are my halves moving forward, Both are contracted for a few years and I don't see a spot when fit (In the halves) for Latu.... I don't see him wanting to play back up for the next 4 years, and I don't see him not getting poached in that time.

Apologise if that's all too 'conclusive' for you...
I don't hate the kid at all, I can't wait to see him fire....
I just don't see a situation where they're both on our books (In their preferred position)
in the next 3 years.

You inventing one, Doesn't make it real for everyone else....
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 1,102 (members: 14, guests: 1,088)
Back
Top