TEAM LIST Round 20 vs. Rabbitohs

Team List
Mighty_Tiger said:
Olam hasn’t provided value for money & his knees are busted, be lucky to get a season of games out of him during his 3 seasons here.
Because of that we must have a NRL quality backup which we don’t.

Luai is awesome pickup, but will offer little unless we have other roster quality inbounds coming. If you think he will be the difference between 4 wins and 12 your kidding. Turuva pro/cons you could argue is a like for like for Tupou (Tupou has more development upside).

We like usual get 3 pickups but then let go 5+ others rather than make a squad stronger. Then every year complain about our roster.

We strengthen the halves & backs and weaken the forwards. We focus on starters and neglect depth.

We let go of our better players rather than our weaker ones. Our retention profile sucks & our squad has major flaws in it.

No team outside of us in the last 5 years has lets go of 5+ NRL level players in 12mths (Tupou, Papa, Blore, Stefano, Laurie) to teams above them that start/figure frequently for top 8 sides.
Click to expand...
Hard to argue with Olam, but he’s been a key part in a few of our wins. I’m still hopeful.

Luai will need other pieces to be a success no doubt, and I’m prepared to wait and see what our team looks like in 2025 before calling for heads.

I’m certainly not crying over Tupou, Laurie or plasticine man. And Stef is still with us as far as I know.

I’ve bashed the club from pillar to post in the past so I wont tell others not to, but I think people are getting a little hysterical given it’s only July and this year was never going to go any different.
 
BAGNF05 said:
Hard to argue with Olam, but he’s been a key part in a few of our wins. I’m still hopeful.

Luai will need other pieces to be a success no doubt, and I’m prepared to wait and see what our team looks like in 2025 before calling for heads.

I’m certainly not crying over Tupou, Laurie or plasticine man. And Stef is still with us as far as I know.

I’ve bashed the club from pillar to post in the past so I wont tell others not to, but I think people are getting a little hysterical given it’s only July and this year was never going to go any different.
Click to expand...
plasticine man?
 
BAGNF05 said:
Hard to argue with Olam, but he’s been a key part in a few of our wins. I’m still hopeful.

Luai will need other pieces to be a success no doubt, and I’m prepared to wait and see what our team looks like in 2025 before calling for heads.

I’m certainly not crying over Tupou, Laurie or plasticine man. And Stef is still with us as far as I know.

I’ve bashed the club from pillar to post in the past so I wont tell others not to, but I think people are getting a little hysterical given it’s only July and this year was never going to go any different.
Click to expand...
Genuinely think Talau has been our biggest loss
 
BAGNF05 said:
Hard to argue with Olam, but he’s been a key part in a few of our wins. I’m still hopeful.

Luai will need other pieces to be a success no doubt, and I’m prepared to wait and see what our team looks like in 2025 before calling for heads.

I’m certainly not crying over Tupou, Laurie or plasticine man. And Stef is still with us as far as I know.

I’ve bashed the club from pillar to post in the past so I wont tell others not to, but I think people are getting a little hysterical given it’s only July and this year was never going to go any different.
Click to expand...

You’re missing the point. Regardless how we rate them, they’re NRL players. They’re playing (most start) with top 6 sides from last and this year. We let them go, we couldn’t keep them fit, we couldn’t get them to perform, but they’re good enough to start for the best teams. We let them go with ease and replaced them with rookies/reggies at best.

We didn’t make our squad stronger in letting them go. Instead we extended Toa, Naden and others whilst brought in a bunch of experiments from union/qld cup.

You started the argument about the is/was regarding squad quality. The reality is just because Luai is coming doesn’t make our squad stronger as such our squad is not was weak.
 
BAGNF05 said:
Plasticine is a putty-like modelling material made from calcium salts, petroleum jelly and aliphatic acids. Otherwise referred to as Shaun Blore’s bones.
Click to expand...
Thanks for the breakdown of of plasticine but that wasn’t the problem, funny though. 😁
I couldn’t remember who we were calling plasticine man. 👍🏻
 
Selecting / blooding players over others that underperform for me is positive. If he didn’t do this, we would be criticising it. This season is gone and at least Benji is trying something, experimenting and testing combinations.
Fair to have a go at Benji for game plan or structure, but he puts himself on the line with these selections. It’s ballsy. Sends a message too.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 1,120 (members: 34, guests: 1,086)
Back
Top