Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[AmericanHistoryX]

He's been poor but it's actually a good thing to happen now rather than later. What I've learnt. He's not a good right winger (better on left), he can play fullback well and he's having a bit of second year syndrome

Best 2nd year syndrome I've ever seen.

 

[tiger05premier]

Critta is in a team of great players. We don't have that. Our only great players are Api, and a bunch of rookies

Critta is an amazing leader whether you like it or not

 

[rugbygoated]

Best 2nd year syndrome I've ever seen.

Thanks AHX

 

[hank37w]

How many toes has he got left now?

Still got enough to get by.

 

[old_man_tiger]

Taylan May is likely to be going to gaol.

Good signing they'll get him cheap

 

[rugbygoated]

No he isn't. Have a look at the Digs forward pack. They have 1 big name player, the rest are middle of the road classed players. Preston will surpass that, but the rest are just honest toilers having a go.

The fullback and halfback couldn't get a start at other clubs. The Bulldogs team is far from being filled with great players.

Preston is a great great player. Curran is bloody amazing. Mann is a good work ethic player. Salmon comes from a great system and is comfortable with the others. Max King very underrated forward. Bailey Hayward is very good, like that max plath from the dolphins. Kikau is a great individual player when he is unlocked. Their forwards are doing better than us. Sexton is also a great buy

 

[AmericanHistoryX]

Good signing they'll get him cheap

Someone has to replace Hayne.

 

[rugbygoated]

Taylan May is likely to be going to gaol.

Egomaniac shouldn't be anywhere near our team. Not that we have many options. But the club's standards have to be something. Can't keep on lowering them out of desperation

 

[AmericanHistoryX]

Preston is a great great player. Curran is bloody amazing. Mann is a good work ethic player. Salmon comes from a great system and is comfortable with the others. Max King very underrated forward. Bailey Hayward is very good, like that max plath from the dolphins. Kikau is a great individual player when he is unlocked. Their forwards are doing better than us. Sexton is also a great buy

Lets not get started on their backs.

 

[rugbygoated]

Critta is an amazing leader whether you like it or not

He is, but it is definitely helped by being in a great side with great acquistions over the off season. Connor Tracey has gone mental in 2024, without critta on the weekend had 3 tries and 3 try assists against the broncos. One of the many utilities they bought which people laughed at. If you put critta in our team with our coach in benji as opposed to ciraldo we're not in the top 8, it's as simple as that. And that's my point

 

[Vicious]

No he isn't. Have a look at the Digs forward pack. They have 1 big name player, the rest are middle of the road classed players. Preston will surpass that, but the rest are just honest toilers having a go.

The fullback and halfback couldn't get a start at other clubs. The Bulldogs team is far from being filled with great players.

I wish we had a few honest toilers such as Tracey, Kiraz, Xerri, Mann, Preston and Curran.

 

[rugbygoated]

Lets not get started on their backs.

Addo-Carr will struggle to get back in. Kiraz class. Blake wilson outstanding. Xerri. Critta. So good

 

[tigermate]

Look at what happened to brooks when he wasn't able to play what he saw.

You can know your role and still play what you see.

Poor analysis imo.

Have you ever watched brooks “play what you see”

It’s basically Brooksy running to the line and then running around like a headless cook and panicking and then trying to throw a short ball to the second rower who drops it or gets smashed

Brooks can only run

 

[Vicious]

Best 2nd year syndrome I've ever seen.

I don’t think it has anything to do with that, he’s either playing injured or he’s a dud.

 

[AmericanHistoryX]

I wish we had a few honest toilers such as Tracey, Kiraz, Xerri, Mann, Preston and Curran.

We do. Just can't get the best out of them

 

[king_sirro]

Preston is a great great player. Curran is bloody amazing. Mann is a good work ethic player. Salmon comes from a great system and is comfortable with the others. Max King very underrated forward. Bailey Hayward is very good, like that max plath from the dolphins. Kikau is a great individual player when he is unlocked. Their forwards are doing better than us. Sexton is also a great buy

Yes agree with all that, but at the start of the year would you have said that? They are working together with an amazing attitude combined with the most bias refereeing I have ever seen every week.

 

[AmericanHistoryX]

I don’t think it has anything to do with that, he’s either playing injured or he’s a dud.

I don’t think it has anything to do with that, he’s either playing injured or he’s a dud.

Or playing out of position without notice.. like yesterday

 

[rugbygoated]

should be looking good for 15th.

Your optimism is inspiring

 

[king_sirro]

I wish we had a few honest toilers such as Tracey, Kiraz, Xerri, Mann, Preston and Curran.

So do i

 

[rugbygoated]

Yes agree with all that, but at the start of the year would you have said that? They are working together with an amazing attitude combined with the most bias refereeing I have ever seen every week.

Yeah the refs were on their side on the weekend. But the defence they've had all year has been because of the players they bought. Curran, Critta, Salmon, Tracey, Taaffe, Sexton, Xerri, Wilson