Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

The kid is a goer but his frame is very undercut.
He isn’t in the hopgood mould and would need alot of effort to get his frame right for NRL level.
Well we don't currently have any room for a project player in our top 30. We already have 7-8 which is way more than any other club. He currently in Panthers top 30, but for us he'd ideally be a development player, but we're unlikely to get a player to denote their status and join us.
The solution to having the smallest club in the comp isn't too sign small forwards, I was hoping he'd be at least be 188, 105kgs.
 
Last edited:
I think Faataape is getting criticized for not being a stand out 1st grade player. I believe the people sticking up for him are suggesting there is something to work with there.

If Faataape is your #3/4 centre option & not relied on weekly- you can see potential enough to develop. Same with Naden. As a starter- no value. But to fill in when there are injuries etc- he's a viable short term solution.

It's really all about what is expected from the player.
You’ve just described most of our squad
 
There's a world of difference between "you'll never play first grade for this club again - get out now or rot in the reserves" and "realistically, you're likely to be our fourth or fifth choice half next season so if an offer comes along that gives you a better opportunity you should seriously consider it".
Yep agreed. What do you think the message Sullivan has got? To me it looks like he has totally been frozen out, to not even be named on the extended bench and choosing to go with Api at 7.
 
Ciraldo came second last in his first season. By the logic above, the Bulldogs should have punted him. All I'm saying is give him a fair shot...the roster is mid way through a rebuild.

Maguire had 3 years...or was it 4? He was a premiership winning coach in both ESL and NRL. Took NZ to great heights. Won a series from behind with the Blues...By all metrics, he should have turned us around, but he didn't. A credentialled coach makes a difference everywhere they go. We got worse under him. Why is that?

If replacing coaches was the answer, we would have solved the problem by now. I think the issues are more than skin deep and we have genuinely started addressing them starting with the CEO and the board.

Add to that Luai and Turuva and shelling underperforming players to make cap room for players that will make a difference. Slowly but surely things are moving.

If you expect results immediately, then your expectations may be unrealistic. I was always prepared to see 2024 and perhaps 2025 as tough years.

Brad Arthur is not our saviour. Flanno, Hasler or Bennett were the right calls for us, but we didn't take those opportunities, so now we need to work with what we've got. On the plus side, we are starting to score some points which is nice. Perhaps things are shifting in the right direction.
A more than worthy retort, excellent strong points!
 
Yep agreed. What do you think the message Sullivan has got? To me it looks like he has totally been frozen out, to not even be named on the extended bench and choosing to go with Api at 7.
Seems the writings on the wall for him I'd dare say hes one of the guys Richo had a chat with after round seven. I'm torn on him cause Benji just helped get his signature across the line last year, now he wants him out. I feel bad for the guy. In saying that though we don't need him after this year. Once Luai gets here it'll be him and Galvin / Fainu.
 
Yep agreed. What do you think the message Sullivan has got? To me it looks like he has totally been frozen out, to not even be named on the extended bench and choosing to go with Api at 7.
I wouldn't have a clue. There doesn't seem to be any suggestion that he's been problematic so either he's quite mature and realistic, or the club has managed things very diplomatically (or both). It sucks for him because when he signed he presumably thought he had a good shot of being a starting half, but the combination of the Tigers then signing a bunch more halves and the emergence of Galvin put paid to that before he had a chance. And, to be fair, he's been pretty awful when he has played. He didn't get much opportunity but he didn't exactly seize what he got with both hands.
 
Ciraldo came second last in his first season. By the logic above, the Bulldogs should have punted him. All I'm saying is give him a fair shot...the roster is mid way through a rebuild.

Maguire had 3 years...or was it 4? He was a premiership winning coach in both ESL and NRL. Took NZ to great heights. Won a series from behind with the Blues...By all metrics, he should have turned us around, but he didn't. A credentialled coach makes a difference everywhere they go. We got worse under him. Why is that?

If replacing coaches was the answer, we would have solved the problem by now. I think the issues are more than skin deep and we have genuinely started addressing them starting with the CEO and the board.

Add to that Luai and Turuva and shelling underperforming players to make cap room for players that will make a difference. Slowly but surely things are moving.

If you expect results immediately, then your expectations may be unrealistic. I was always prepared to see 2024 and perhaps 2025 as tough years.

Brad Arthur is not our saviour. Flanno, Hasler or Bennett were the right calls for us, but we didn't take those opportunities, so now we need to work with what we've got. On the plus side, we are starting to score some points which is nice. Perhaps things are shifting in the right direction.

A more than worthy retort, excellent strong points!
Benji was coaching last year

2 wooden spoons in a row

Stef left to be better developed

How many players want to leave the bulldogs for better development? Hmmm

No comparison ciraldo and benji

Problem is it doesn’t matter - proof will be next year when we lose galvin and the wheels come off.

Agree no one better atm but that first mean Benji can be compared to ciraldo
 
  • Like
Reactions: TSP
Benji was coaching last year

2 wooden spoons in a row

Stef left to be better developed

How many players want to leave the bulldogs for better development? Hmmm

No comparison ciraldo and benji

Problem is it doesn’t matter - proof will be next year when we lose galvin and the wheels come off.

Agree no one better atm but that first mean Benji can be compared to ciraldo
Benji was under sheens last year. It doesn't count as he couldn't do what he wanted. It's like saying CEO's PA is responsible for the companies earnings.
 
Benji was under sheens last year. It doesn't count as he couldn't do what he wanted. It's like saying CEO's PA is responsible for the companies earnings.
Lol.

Those close to the club know benji was doing the coaching.

But sure.

This is the same rhetoric when people said sheens was a bad idea and everyone frothed on the 2005 reunion.

Let’s see next year.

My opinion is Benji will be gone by round 10
 
Back
Top