Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

Tim Sheens said:
My evaluation in watching Bula in each of those many minutes have been confirmed by your stats. Him being great in some areas, yet lacking in assisting others, and missing the early highlight defensive efforts that had us all excited.

I expect that Luai will help him more in getting through the line, as Jahream can find a hole, and if Galvin can somewhat limit his sideways running that takes away the space out wide, they too will be a much more lethal combination. Hopefully others will be following him and taking the pass to score.
Click to expand...
Galvin won't run sideways as much if we get a forward pack that consistently punches over the advantage line & puts defence on the back foot.
 
balmain boy said:
For now, it's a pretty big blow. Our outside back stocks in the juniors are paper thin. Nav was great aerially, and as he fills out he will become a lot more powerful with the ball. Not super fast, but as fast as nearly all our current NRL backs.

Staines, Naden, Lobb and Toa are all bog average, Staines the pick of the three. All could easily be axed.
With Skelton joining that's one decent winger at the club next year. Ngutlik is only just coming back from injury, has potential.
The likes of Faatape and Casey offer nothing. Saukuru has potential but has been injured this year and is a centre more than winger.
Laulilii has talent but is just very small, questions on his defence and high ball skills, and ability to just compete in the nrl level.
The Taotua boys have been in and out of Flegg. No wingers of note in Ball or Matts.

The only possibilities that would make this make sense:
1. Makasini and Large are on Dev contracts next year so we needed to free up the spot, it's fair to rate both higher than Nav.
2. Manly are trading us someone quality like Hopoate or Koula in exchange
3. We've signed another young star winger from elsewhere who we rate better than Nav.

If none of the above conditions come true then this is a massive stuff up from the club yet again. We must always have too much talent that we can't fit in, cherry pick and can't keep them all, but if we offload first and then hope to secure better that's just amateur. We really should be getting a trade from Manly regardless, can't just give them another Paseka for free.
Click to expand...

Agree with your assessment of our limited depth in the outside backs but the suggestion that Manly would offer us Hopoate or Koula in exchange for Willett made me laugh.
 
balmain boy said:
For now, it's a pretty big blow. Our outside back stocks in the juniors are paper thin. Nav was great aerially, and as he fills out he will become a lot more powerful with the ball. Not super fast, but as fast as nearly all our current NRL backs.

Staines, Naden, Lobb and Toa are all bog average, Staines the pick of the three. All could easily be axed.
With Skelton joining that's one decent winger at the club next year. Ngutlik is only just coming back from injury, has potential.
The likes of Faatape and Casey offer nothing. Saukuru has potential but has been injured this year and is a centre more than winger.
Laulilii has talent but is just very small, questions on his defence and high ball skills, and ability to just compete in the nrl level.
The Taotua boys have been in and out of Flegg. No wingers of note in Ball or Matts.

The only possibilities that would make this make sense:
1. Makasini and Large are on Dev contracts next year so we needed to free up the spot, it's fair to rate both higher than Nav.
2. Manly are trading us someone quality like Hopoate or Koula in exchange
3. We've signed another young star winger from elsewhere who we rate better than Nav.

If none of the above conditions come true then this is a massive stuff up from the club yet again. We must always have too much talent that we can't fit in, cherry pick and can't keep them all, but if we offload first and then hope to secure better that's just amateur. We really should be getting a trade from Manly regardless, can't just give them another Paseka for free.
Click to expand...
Well said!
I hope a manly player comes in return. But we can't expect much because Willett is a Flegg player.
Only possible options:
Clayton Faulalo - Would be awesome. Seen great things in cup so far.
Jaxson Paulo - Not mad on this. Kind of another Staines. Just a really mid player but will do his job
Raymond Vaega - Hope not. We just bought Skelton. We don't need 3 backs who all look for the all or nothing tackle
Lehi Hopoate - I feel this would be a great signing. He too is signed until 2026 but that doesn't seem to stop anyone.

A lot of movement at the moment. Im trying to stay positive thinking Richo is cooking something up. Only time will tell. Only have 1 more day for the new signings and retentions to be announced . . . as per the Skelton announcement.
 
balmain boy said:
For now, it's a pretty big blow. Our outside back stocks in the juniors are paper thin. Nav was great aerially, and as he fills out he will become a lot more powerful with the ball. Not super fast, but as fast as nearly all our current NRL backs.

Staines, Naden, Lobb and Toa are all bog average, Staines the pick of the three. All could easily be axed.
With Skelton joining that's one decent winger at the club next year. Ngutlik is only just coming back from injury, has potential.
The likes of Faatape and Casey offer nothing. Saukuru has potential but has been injured this year and is a centre more than winger.
Laulilii has talent but is just very small, questions on his defence and high ball skills, and ability to just compete in the nrl level.
The Taotua boys have been in and out of Flegg. No wingers of note in Ball or Matts.

The only possibilities that would make this make sense:
1. Makasini and Large are on Dev contracts next year so we needed to free up the spot, it's fair to rate both higher than Nav.
2. Manly are trading us someone quality like Hopoate or Koula in exchange
3. We've signed another young star winger from elsewhere who we rate better than Nav.

If none of the above conditions come true then this is a massive stuff up from the club yet again. We must always have too much talent that we can't fit in, cherry pick and can't keep them all, but if we offload first and then hope to secure better that's just amateur. We really should be getting a trade from Manly regardless, can't just give them another Paseka for free.
Click to expand...
I'd give them a Paseka for free... He stinks
 
jrtiger said:
it’s quite possible, but the question is whether they’re leaving school at the end of this year.
Click to expand...

Yeah, final year of school, I'm hopeful they could do
a Sua'ali'ii at Kings and get exemptions. They're not
regular students that play sport they're exceptional
athletes that will both play football professionally.
Up to the parents and club but no age requirements
for development contracts, odd Craig & Willetts gone
 
jrtiger said:
Nav’s a wonderfully talented footballer but he was externally recruited by Sheens and McDonnell and as a result this was always a chance of happening, especially now considering Skelton has just pushed him further down the depth chart.

with Craig reportedly heading to Penrith and Willett now gone, something tells me Richardson is tinkering with development contracts.
Click to expand...
Willet must have been given permission to look elsewhere. And Richo new Skelton was coming, and didn't see much value in Willet and what he probably wanted. We will be fine without you. By By.
Willet couldn't do all that negotiating in less than a week after hearing Skelton was coming so the pecking order was not the reason.

Agree Richo is working on a plan, and I like the way he goes about it.
Putting a tick for players he wants to keep: And players that can shop elsewhere for a better deal.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Staff online

Members online

Total: 928 (members: 23, guests: 905)
Back
Top