Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[Robbie's Love Child]

I for one would gladly send Galvin to the Panthers to get To'o. We have Fainu who can easily slot in alongside Luai, Galvin is a talent but he isn't an instant winner like To'o and will probably become a second rower or lock in the future. He may end up leaving anyhow so why not go hard for To'o.

 

[weststigers]

I for one would gladly send Galvin to the Panthers to get To'o. We have Fainu who can easily slot in alongside Luai, Galvin is a talent but he isn't an instant winner like To'o and will probably become a second rower or lock in the future. He may end up leaving anyhow so why not go hard for To'o.

This is the question.

Suppose a deal is on the table to make a swap, but the club stands firm to keep Galvin and lose To'o, but we lose both. Are we going to lose Galvin anyway? It kind of looks that way to me.

 

[bptiger 0]

Article states depth......

Not bad, to be honest.
Well done.

There all kids again that won’t play 1st grade , some are 21 and have struggled, we are not learning

 

[liltiger]

Just hope we are locking down Pole

 

[bptiger 0]

I for one would gladly send Galvin to the Panthers to get To'o. We have Fainu who can easily slot in alongside Luai, Galvin is a talent but he isn't an instant winner like To'o and will probably become a second rower or lock in the future. He may end up leaving anyhow so why not go hard for To'o.

So u would swap a GUN 5/8 for a winger , are u mad . What the club needs to do is to get a pack that can give this great backline a chance , if we do sign some quality forwards and make a run for the semi’s next year maybe that will convince Galvin to stay , but u don’t throw away a playmaker for a winger

 

[pawsandclaws1]

There all kids again that won’t play 1st grade , some are 21 and have struggled, we are not learning

Rahme is known to the club being a Tigers' junior and served a good apprenticeship for a prop.

 

[pawsandclaws1]

This is the question.

Suppose a deal is on the table to make a swap, but the club stands firm to keep Galvin and lose To'o, but we lose both. Are we going to lose Galvin anyway? It kind of looks that way to me.

If there is a swap and this goes ahead, it will be a player Cleary believes will fit seamlessly into the Panthers' system.

 

[851]

I heard the Brian To'o rumour again today I think it has legs

I heard To'o , May and Toby Rudolph to the Tigers I love my Local

That would be sweet, To'o and Skelton on the wings, Turuva and May at centre

 

[batboy]

Article states depth......

Not bad, to be honest.
Well done.

Our 'depth' Players are taking up most of the top 30....

We need first graders - Not projects.

 

[Tiger Stripes]

I for one would gladly send Galvin to the Panthers to get To'o. We have Fainu who can easily slot in alongside Luai, Galvin is a talent but he isn't an instant winner like To'o and will probably become a second rower or lock in the future. He may end up leaving anyhow so why not go hard for To'o.

Toó an instant winner. You jest!

 

[Tiger_Yoshi]

Just hope we are locking down Pole

And Sione Fainu

 

[426Tlgerland]

There all kids again that won’t play 1st grade , some are 21 and have struggled, we are not learning

Yep kids , this just not good enough , and depth it says , that’s fine what about the main game the NRL team , we are last and non of the 7 will help us. Move up the ladder in 2025 , more lip service with no strength

 

[rugbygoated]

I heard the Brian To'o rumour again today I think it has legs

I heard To'o , May and Toby Rudolph to the Tigers I love my Local

Toby can assist the locals on Norton Street in putting up the rainbow flags

 

[426Tlgerland]

I hope everyone is happy now the signings are named

Not really happy at all
7 lower graders
what about Pole , Galvin , Sione ,
land where is Stefs replacement and the extra prop and back rower we need now

 

[FrodoTBaggin]

Our 'depth' Players are taking up most of the top 30....

We need first graders - Not projects.

Not a single player signed today for depth will be taking a top 30 role.

 

[Kelce68]

Yeah I guess that's my point. Plenty of backs making debuts, but very few forwards. Miller being the only one from memory. Maybe Kit L?

Seems like the forwards are well behind and we have a while to wait before we see them in NRL consistently.

I think, as a broad rule, forwards can tend to take a bit longer to mature to NRL, just given the requirements of their positions.

As an example, if you look at the best teenagers of recent times, Galvin, Talagi, Strange, even back to the likes of Sua'ali'i and Walsh, they're all backs (generally).

But, in our side, we've already got Pole (22), Samuela (20) and Sione (22), so our generation now is up and going, it's the next crop that is 2/3 years away (min) from getting a decent taste.

Probably for the best though.

 

[Tom Shines]

Not really happy at all
7 lower graders
what about Pole , Galvin , Sione ,
land where is Stefs replacement and the extra prop and back rower we need now

Whenever I complain someone tells me to be patient and the signings will come in the off season

 

[pawsandclaws1]

Not really happy at all
7 lower graders
what about Pole , Galvin , Sione ,
land where is Stefs replacement and the extra prop and back rower we need now

Look at Rahme, a three year apprenticeship at Souths and the Knights, a Balmain junior perhaps on the cusp of the NRL. If you look at his write ups hardworking features. I think he is a smart signing and is not taking a top 30 spot.

 

[batboy]

Not a single player signed today for depth will be taking a top 30 role.

Maybe read what I wrote then comment?
Look at the Quality of our Top 30 Roster....

- Most of those players would be considered Depth and not NRL quality, Some of them not even depth....
3rd grade at best most of them.

Now we've signed a heap of players to sit behind them....
How's that work exactly?

What are we announcing RMC Players?
(Have a look at where a lot of our recent 25-30 players are playing now.... in RM cup)
- That's how we roll

 

[batboy]

Whenever I complain someone tells me to be patient and the signings will come in the off season

Merry Christmas....