2024 Grand Final

from 2:40. Its very clear he never gets it down and you can actually see the shot that the still that is all over socials. His arm is under the ball the whole time.
Then why did Channel 9 feel the need (or pressure) to make the announcement after the game was over? And why did they say that the bunker had clearer vision than that shown to the public, coitus ergo sum, why didn't they show that footage at the time?
 
The replay in the clip above was shown on the night after the try but Joey was so busy ranting that it got down that everyone ignored it.

There WAS a replay that looked like he got it down, and that is the one that Joey and every sheep started bleating on about. When I saw that replay I thought he scored but straight away after they showed the replay in that clip and it clearly shows he never gets it down.

In the clip that it looks like he gets it down, he still has his arm under it but his arm looks white (maybe paint?). There is no conspiracy. They showed that replay on the live coverage everyone was too excited to see it.
Exactly.

I thought the worse bunker decision was the non-overturned strip that lead to the Harry Grant try.

There was enough evidence there to show it was a loose carry.
 
from 2:40. Its very clear he never gets it down and you can actually see the shot that the still that is all over socials. His arm is under the ball the whole time.


In the first section of this article there's this gem (my bold emphasis):

"The NRL swiftly responded after the game by releasing secret vision — only available to the officials in the bunker — that showed the ball was held up by Penrith defenders."

Seriously, telling the media AFTER the game is considered swift and not telling the public at the time is OK??

Then, about half-way down the page is the headline "Hidden footage of controversial call" and the following explanation:

"But it turns out the Bunker was looking at a different replay angle that showed the ball didn’t touch the ground. The footage has been shown to media at the ground but is yet to be released publicly.

NCA Newswire’s Martin Gabor tweeted: “Fair play to the NRL. We’ve been shown a high resolution replay and there is no point when the ball touches the ground. Jack Howarth did NOT score. I thought it was definitely a try at the time.”

So all I am saying is that if there was conclusive evidence at the time then why wasn't it broadcast at the time?
 
Cleary is a fantastic player albeit incredibly unlikeable.

4 in a row, despite the bunker nonsense is something special.

Maybe Penriths decline will begin next year but Cleary Jnr has been a powerhouse for many years.
Penrith 2025 season will depend on how Blaize Talagi goes at 6 ....
 

In the first section of this article there's this gem (my bold emphasis):

"The NRL swiftly responded after the game by releasing secret vision — only available to the officials in the bunker — that showed the ball was held up by Penrith defenders."

Seriously, telling the media AFTER the game is considered swift and not telling the public at the time is OK??

Then, about half-way down the page is the headline "Hidden footage of controversial call" and the following explanation:

"But it turns out the Bunker was looking at a different replay angle that showed the ball didn’t touch the ground. The footage has been shown to media at the ground but is yet to be released publicly.

NCA Newswire’s Martin Gabor tweeted: “Fair play to the NRL. We’ve been shown a high resolution replay and there is no point when the ball touches the ground. Jack Howarth did NOT score. I thought it was definitely a try at the time.”

So all I am saying is that if there was conclusive evidence at the time then why wasn't it broadcast at the time?
How else do you show the public other than by showing the media? It's always been known that the bunker has footage that isn't shown on the broadcast. It's not up to the NRL to dictate what camera angle 9 telecasts.
 
It was.....the replay I posted that conclusively shows his arm is always under it, was actually shown live, you can hear the channel9 commentator Billy Slater saying "thats his own arm under it".

It cant be clearer, the video I posted that PROVES his arm was under it the whole time WAS broadcast at the time. Its just that people are so easily led that everyone jumped on the bandwagon.
Mate you keep missing the point. The bunker relied on video footage that was not shown publically and still has not yet been released.
 
How else do you show the public other than by showing the media? It's always been known that the bunker has footage that isn't shown on the broadcast. It's not up to the NRL to dictate what camera angle 9 telecasts.
That is the point. Why didn't they show the conclusive footage?
 
He’s not at all my thing musically, but The Kid Laroi is probably the most famous/recognised Aussie artist around at the moment, including in the USA. Not bad for a guy from Redfern.

(Cue boomers “well I’ve never heard of him!!!!?!”)

The pre-game entertainment has NEVER been good. It’s tradition at this point.
I thought they stuffed up the sound mix, with the music drowning out the vocals. I’m actually not sure if he is good or not lol…
 
He’s not at all my thing musically, but The Kid Laroi is probably the most famous/recognised Aussie artist around at the moment, including in the USA. Not bad for a guy from Redfern.

(Cue boomers “well I’ve never heard of him!!!!?!”)

The pre-game entertainment has NEVER been good. It’s tradition at this point.
I agree, my kids (who are a lot more up with the current trends than me) were surprised the NRL got someone so good!!
 
I haven’t either. But I do have to ask why he was playing covers if he’s that big of a deal

He's Massive....
Had a couple songs on his last (Debut maybe?) Album that were global - Collabs with Miley Cyrus and Beiber....
They're cracking songs.
Not my thing either, But he's been about for sure....

I though the INXS thing was a good choice.... The way they cast his set - It fit perfectly with his stuff.
To be fair,
His music isn't football music - But he's a local kid from a Footy area who has roots in the game and a global star....
Was a good mix for what they were doing.

Not the choice I'd have made - But certainly didn't offend me....
I'm in it for the game - and the game was a cracker.
 
I thought they stuffed up the sound mix, with the music drowning out the vocals. I’m actually not sure if he is good or not lol…
Studio Rat....
Openly admits to using Auto Tune and effects as he want's his shows to be as good as they can be.
Seems popular enough - But those couple songs he had both had fantastic Radio Hooks....
How he is where he is...
 
Back
Top