Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

426Tlgerland said:
Yep , I feel with the players who have joined us Benji may feel , centre and right back row will sort it self , meaning players like Seyfarth and Sukkura may have enough support now with a stronger pack to be able to play at the level required , Luai driving , Appi Skemming , Galvin skemming , Big Sam on the left with Luai and front row power we haven’t had for years may be enough , Seyfarth was improving every game last season , just centre for me and With - Staines , Turuva , Skelton , Naden , AD , Toa ,Olam I think we are ok ,
Click to expand...
And Makasini destined to lock up one spot for the next 10 years
 
426Tlgerland said:
Yep , I feel with the players who have joined us Benji may feel , centre and right back row will sort it self , meaning players like Seyfarth and Sukkura may have enough support now with a stronger pack to be able to play at the level required , Luai driving , Appi Skemming , Galvin skemming , Big Sam on the left with Luai and front row power we haven’t had for years may be enough , Seyfarth was improving every game last season , just centre for me and With - Staines , Turuva , Skelton , Naden , AD , Toa ,Olam I think we are ok ,
Click to expand...
And Makasini destined to lock up one spot for the next 10 years
rugbygoated said:
eems like AD has been put into the side simply because he can goal kick, with Api missing round 1. Not a first grader, and a terrible centre at that. Benji stuffing up already with a good team
Click to expand...
I’m sure Benji will be checking his performance out during the trials.
 
Modman said:
mate sounds like the right thing to do as Wests tigers fans but what would you do if you were offered a couple of extra thousand a year and quite possibly a chance of winning a grand final. Fingers crossed here too, but if he was my young bloke my priorty would be to earn as much money as you can while you can. Hes only an serious injury away from earning nothing. I think we will do what we have to to keep him. Imagine the headlines if we lose Galvin after we lost our other top juniors like teddy and moses
Click to expand...
I don’t think any rival club is paying him 1 million per season unless he goes to another level in 2025.
I would offer him a massive upgraded offer for the next 5 years, 600k for 2025, 700k for 2026, 800k for 2027, 900k for 2028 and 1 million for 2029 and throw in bonuses if we make the top 8, top 4 or if he plays SOO.
 
Tiger Stripes said:
If below 10th is a failure who gives Benji his marching orders?
If its Richo and annoints a new coach, Richo becomes the New Whipping Boy if the new coach is a failure. Disharmony. 🤪
Richo would not like that at all.
Having opened this scenario for comments to keep me entertained a bit longer before the first trial--------I think Benji will prevail. 😁
Click to expand...
Can't see us in the Top 12 to be honest
 
magpies forever said:
I wouldn't say so much stuffing up as exposing a glaring hole in recruitment / playing roster- something we have said with a few people here- goal kicking is very thin on.
Click to expand...
Think about all those close games we lost early on last year, if we had a good goal kicker it changes a lot. But then again, is AD's goalkicking worth putting him in if he lets in 2 tries a game?
 
rugbygoated said:
eems like AD has been put into the side simply because he can goal kick, with Api missing round 1. Not a first grader, and a terrible centre at that. Benji stuffing up already with a good team
Click to expand...
FMD, the trials are weeks away and you already have the skinny on Benji's selections for round 1. This is the first hard evidence anyone has posted that shows Benji can't coach! I'm interested in who Benji will be selecting on the two wings for round 1 so I can put it in a multi!
 
Last edited:
Odessa said:
Rommey will be first choice kicker
Click to expand...
Don't think so. He doesn't tend to stand up and take roles off others. He's more of a player who gets players at their best around him. At penrith it's been cleary, crichton, edwards then alamoti goalkicking. I suspect he will be leaving it to api or galvin to do the big plays
 
Jolls said:
FMD, the trials are weeks away and you already have the skinny on Benji's selections for round 1. This is the first hard evidence anyone has posted that shows Benji can't coach! I'm interested in who Banji will be selecting on the two wings for round 1 so I can put it in a multi!
Click to expand...
Benji is a shit coach and we will not live up to the ridiculous expectations put on us in this off season. Benji has been good for two things. Blooding youngsters, and the recruitment attraction to work with him. Neither of which have anything to do with his actual coaching of the team and game plans. Everything else has show he is clueless as a first grade coach. Even with his assistant coach selections, jobs for the old boys... never ends well. The teams with culture issues and poor on field performances are the teams with old boys getting too involved with their team in the media and close to the club. Gordon Tallis at the broncos. The Dragons another team. Then there is us with Benny Elias and Blocker at a stretch
 
Spartan117 said:
Benji was a key figure in recruitment for Jerome, May , Tito etc.

He deserves the 3rd year with the right staff around him.

I'm in for the medium to long term with Coach Benji
Click to expand...
Even if he can't coach? We won't make the 8 with him. It'll take to year 4 or 5 with him and by that time galvin would have left
 
rugbygoated said:
Benji is a shit coach and we will not live up to the ridiculous expectations put on us in this off season.
Click to expand...
I'm seriously interested in your take on his coaching ability. I have asked several times for evidence that he can't and heard crickets.

I'm not won over by him but there is hard evidence to suggest that he does have a clue but had a side that was been unable to excute for 80 minutes.

The change in focus for this pre-season demonstrates learning, the recruitment demonstrates knoweldge of what is required and the one or two games where we put it all together against the sharks and raiders demonstrates that the players were able to execute what was being asked. there are plenty of other snippets that show he has a clue.

On the can't coach front 100% he stuffed up the entire lead up and approach to spoon bowl - but I expect that won't happen again. Some of his rotations were poor as well; but what examples are there that demonstrated that what he is coaching is below par?

I'm sure that Benji had a say in Hodgo as an assistant - but he isn't inexperienced and has broad exposure to some good systems. Would he have been my pick? Probably not. But how can you state that it won't end well before a ball is kicked.

So if Benji is such a shit coach - what are the hard facts that lead you to that conclusion. Not interested in opinion.
 
Last edited:
rugbygoated said:
eems like AD has been put into the side simply because he can goal kick, with Api missing round 1. Not a first grader, and a terrible centre at that. Benji stuffing up already with a good team
Click to expand...
eems like you are not a tigers fan, seriously no one knows what Benji is gonna do with the team.
Stop being a hater. Benji is the greatest tigers player and will be our greatest coach
Up the tigers !!!
 
teddy23 said:
I’m not sure if it has been mentioned before but I’ve heard today to keep an eye on Harrison Hassett from Penrith.

Could be a good chance at ending up a 🐯
Click to expand...
Thanks for the heads up. Mav Geyer was my emerging pick out of that system for 2026. If I recall correctly Hassett is also still contracted to them for 2025 so if we can prize him out early that could be a good thing.

He has a bit of Liam Martin about him, running good lines and gritty in defence (although defence is an area he needs to improve). I think him and Mav Geyer are potential NRL quality. Hope we land him for 2025.
 
rugbygoated said:
Think about all those close games we lost early on last year, if we had a good goal kicker it changes a lot. But then again, is AD's goalkicking worth putting him in if he lets in 2 tries a game?
Click to expand...
I do not why is this an issue? OK, our first choice hooker is suspended.
The logical, non Sheensian rule is, replace the like with like!
So as TDS is our best hooker after Kuroisau, he gets no 9!
But, he is also one of our best goal kickers.
Simple!
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 235 (members: 11, guests: 224)
Back
Top