Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[Dazed]

Well at the risk of talking out of my arse.......no, probably not. I'm definitely not sold on the coaching. One can only hope that take is wrong.

You're definitely not talking out your arse mate and your take is definitely not wrong.

 

[TurnStyle]

The players that don’t need to be there (Luai, Turuva) were, the players that should’ve been there weren’t

That says it all: the players are where they are because of where they choose to be...

Man I've got the munchies....

 

[liltiger]

- on LiSTNR

play.listnr.com

Buzz was at Tigers' training ground on the players day off and it's good to see 5 players were still there doing extras. The little changes make the big changes a reality

Guaranteed it was only the 5 new signings

 

[Rock Hopper Steve]

Guaranteed it was only the 5 new signings

It was the Buzzard he might have had a long lunch.

 

[TurnStyle]

LOL we didnt develop him much at all.
He impressed during the pre season and so was chucked in to starting 5/8th in the NRL team.
This resulted in yet another last place finish.
Benji should know better...we didnt develop him either. Had he come through a decent setup, the Marshal name would be spoken about as a future immortal, without fan bias attached.

What do you mean the tigers didn't develop Benji? Didn't they grab him from nz and put him in Keebra Park (where he was still a student when he debuted)?

Or do you mean the player he eventually became? Because honestly, I think he became a better player overall away from WT.

 

[liltiger]

It was the Buzzard he might have had a long lunch.

I hope not that means we only have like 2 committed players.

 

[liltiger]

What do you mean the tigers didn't develop Benji? Didn't they grab him from nz and put him in Keebra Park (where he was still a student when he debuted)?

Or do you mean the player he eventually became? Because honestly, I think he became a better player overall away from WT.

Depends how you define better. He matured and learned to run a team around the park better.
His flair and off the cuff play he was notorious for was all at the Tigers. Won the golden boot in 2010 I think it was as a Tiger.

 

[Rock Hopper Steve]

I hope not that means we only have like 2 committed players.

You implying old Buzz has focusing issues, how dare you.

 

[Tucker]

do you mean the player he eventually became? Because honestly, I think he became a better player overall away from WT.

Yes, as per my point.

 

[Tucker]

Depends how you define better. He matured and learned to run a team around the park better.
His flair and off the cuff play he was notorious for was all at the Tigers. Won the golden boot in 2010 I think it was as a Tiger.

That was all mostly natural instinct.
He was doing all the same stuff as an Oztag and touch player.

 

[bradexl]

I don't understand why anything other than continued improvement this season would be the expectation for Galvin.

Outside of opposition clubs then having a season to study a rookie, where is the evidence a second year syndrome is anything but outdated myth?

"Im not going to fanboy a 19 year old .hes a prodigy to be sure"

View attachment 20313

Agree. Galvin was an 18 year old kid playing week in week out in an underachieving and eventually wooden spoon team. Give the kid a break - He showed us enough to suggest he will develop nicely playing alongside Luai..

 

[Tucker]

Agree. Galvin was an 18 year old kid playing week in week out in an underachieving and eventually wooden spoon team. Give the kid a break - He showed us enough to suggest he will develop nicely playing alongside Luai..

Thats not a given and is likely the reason his family is pushing for a new start elsewhere.
As per the point we were discussing.
It doesnt matter a shit how good he currently is, its all about how good he can become and thats where the development debate is being held.

 

[TurnStyle]

Yes, as per my point.

Completely agree

 

[TurnStyle]

Depends how you define better. He matured and learned to run a team around the park better.
His flair and off the cuff play he was notorious for was all at the Tigers. Won the golden boot in 2010 I think it was as a Tiger.

I'm not being cynical, but I feel like there is this false prestige attached to the Golden boot; it's like people think it is awarded to the best player in the world that year.

It's not. It is awarded to the player adjudged to have been the best player in international games that year.

 

[GNR4LIFE]

Agree. Galvin was an 18 year old kid playing week in week out in an underachieving and eventually wooden spoon team. Give the kid a break - He showed us enough to suggest he will develop nicely playing alongside Luai..

People sense he’s leaving and want to devalue him to try and diminish his loss.

 

[hank37w]

The players that don’t need to be there (Luai, Turuva) were, the players that should’ve been there weren’t

But it's okay because the journos that we love so much were there.

 

[Rock Hopper Steve]

People sense he’s leaving and want to devalue him to try and diminish his loss.

I'm hoping Helmes is right about Galvan so we can move on from the angst.

 

[innsaneink]

Man if you don’t think there’s going to be a downturn in Galvins performances , then I don’t know what to tell you . I’m not saying it will be 6 weeks , a season , or like Tim smith or Mortimer junior a one year wonder … I’m not saying any of that , it’s just inevitable there will be a downturning performance , in which Galvin and the club will have to counter . I mean we saw it really , well the beginnings of it , at the end of last year .
Im not going to fanboy a 19 year old .hes a prodigy to be sure , and i hope he can lead us to glory , but there’s a reason nearly every player suffers from the dreaded “second year syndrome” . The best ones just only suffer from it for a few games , and move forward … the worst ones , well I just mentioned a couple .

Sounds like youre describing a few off weeks...every players can go thru this.
Its not 2nd year sydnrome

 

[innsaneink]

Yep. What round do you think they will cave in by?

Rd 4 or 5

 

[innsaneink]

People sense he’s leaving and want to devalue him to try and diminish his loss.

Aaahh I see