Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

king_sirro said:
Sukkar gets a chance to start for me next week. In his two appearances he has defended strongly and landed on his front every carry. I have no idea if he is a genuine first grader now or in the future, but in his two appearances he has come on in terrible circumstances and looked better than other forwards. So I say give him a crack and see what happens. Pole will likely be out, so Seyfarth moves to the bench as a middle.
Click to expand...
I wouldn't have Seyfarth in the team next week bring Kit in to have a go.
 
Tiger in boots 🐅 said:
Your shit mate! put your glasses on. Sukkar played better then our starting FG players. At least he had a go. With 40 Nil half time, what’s he ment to do wear an S cape. The playing team has a lot to answer for but the important thing is they lift their heads up and come out firing next week…
Click to expand...
Seyfarth again made at least 4 errors today. All resulted in 6 more tackles. That’s an extra 24 tackles to make.( 1 resulted in a try) It’s unlikely that’s the number as 6 agains could have been on tackle 1,2 or 3, but it doesn’t change the fact that every week he puts the team under pressure by continued infringements. People comparing him and Sukkar have no idea. One is a seasoned first grader, the other an inexperienced kid. One makes a shit ton of errors and should know better, the other should make them because he doesn’t know better. Seyfarth ceiling has been hit. He’s a squad member that should be called on when required, not a starter every week.
 
Furious1 said:
Seyfarth again made at least 4 errors today. All resulted in 6 more tackles. That’s an extra 24 tackles to make.( 1 resulted in a try) It’s unlikely that’s the number as 6 agains could have been on tackle 1,2 or 3, but it doesn’t change the fact that every week he puts the team under pressure by continued infringements. People comparing him and Sukkar have no idea. One is a seasoned first grader, the other an inexperienced kid. One makes a shit ton of errors and should know better, the other should make them because he doesn’t know better. Seyfarth ceiling has been hit. He’s a squad member that should be called on when required, not a starter every week.
Click to expand...

Thank you, good to see there’s some more common sense on here.

But just be ready for the Seytard clan to come at you with empty platitudes like “he gives effort and heart” or “he’s a good clubman, Benji trusts him” because they can’t argue the actual facts.
 
Tom Shines said:
Fonua knee injury …. Lucky our depth will stand up and get it done
Click to expand...
We have busted our other prop by playing him for 80mins each week.
Our coach has no idea, most of our depth are Ron Massey Cup standard st best and we have a clear divide in our playing roster.
Season over, another wooden spoon on the way and another rebuild required.
 
Batmans Parents said:
Thank you, good to see there’s some more common sense on here.

But just be ready for the Seytard clan to come at you with empty platitudes like “he gives effort and heart” or “he’s a good clubman, Benji trusts him” because they can’t argue the actual facts.
Click to expand...
Didn’t you read here he’s improved this season…
He’s only been in top grade for 6 years - years 11-13 should really be something
 
Batmans Parents said:
Thank you, good to see there’s some more common sense on here.

But just be ready for the Seytard clan to come at you with empty platitudes like “he gives effort and heart” or “he’s a good clubman, Benji trusts him” because they can’t argue the actual facts.
Click to expand...
I’m ok with that mate. I’ve never faulted his effort, but it’s distinctly better than his ability and his discipline, which are just not good enough to be a starting backrower in the NRL.
 
batboy said:
Didn’t you read here he’s improved this season…
He’s only been in top grade for 6 years - years 11-13 should really be something
Click to expand...
I’ve been disappointed in Seyfarth this season I expected more and he deserves to be dropped,
In saying that he’s not on his own, Sam Fainu has also been poor and they are getting more friends by the week.
We could have had Shawn Blore playing for us instead of Seyfarth and we still would have got beat by 50.
 
Dennisspicer1 said:
NADEN, NOT WORTH A PINCH OF THE PROVERBIAL,

ANY OTHER BACK WOULD HAVE DIVED AND HIT THE BALL DEAD, RATHER THAN TRY TO BUMP RYAN P OFF THE BALL.
STUPID STUPID STUPID.

PLAYING LIKE THIS,
ANOTHER SPOON DEFINITELY LIKELY.
Click to expand...
not any other back. Douiehi's turn and chase was half hearted and not a back but Fainu made no effort at all.
 
batboy said:
Didn’t you read here he’s improved this season…
He’s only been in top grade for 6 years - years 11-13 should really be something
Click to expand...

Of course but his dumb fanboys consider Seyfarth going 10 minutes without giving up a dumb penalty or 6 again an improvement so the bars pretty low.

Maybe he’ll finally make more than 5m in a run by year 9.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 866 (members: 5, guests: 861)
Back
Top