Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[TheEnz]

He only lasted 4 months into a 2 year contract, why would that be a good signing for us?

Could be they have themselves in a bit of a bind with roster spots and salary cap. I prefer not helping them out so a hard pass from me.

 

[Canadian Club]

Dolphins are making a big play for Cobbo, which would explain their urgency to get Tupou's 550k off the books only 6 months into the deal.

Would poke around some of their forwards. Knowles, Plath, Gilbert, Flegler (maybe) still need to come back into this squad. With Lemuelu, Molo, Saifiti, Stone, Keeley, Nicholls, Finefuiaki, Stone and Su'a surely one or two may become available.

 

[tigahhh]

He only lasted 4 months into a 2 year contract, why would that be a good signing for us?

for depth? not every person we sign need to be superstars

 

[tigahhh]

Dolphins are making a big play for Cobbo, which would explain their urgency to get Tupou's 550k off the books only 6 months into the deal.

Would poke around some of their forwards. Knowles, Plath, Gilbert, Flegler (maybe) still need to come back into this squad. With Lemuelu, Molo, Saifiti, Stone, Keeley, Nicholls, Finefuiaki, Stone and Su'a surely one or two may become available.

might need tupou now bostock did his ACL

 

[Canadian Club]

This is a grey area for the forum to understand but if the club didn't have a backup cover plan for this scenario well that would be disappointing,

Can't suggest any players myself but there would be some smokeys getting a run at training you would hope, or they are looking at an external.

Edit some handy suggestions above if they can lift to 1st grade standard.

The club should be doing everything to keep TDS. However if he leaves, Sandon Smith would be a good pick up to play 14. Covers hooker and dummy half. Although I doubt he would be open to coming here to play 14 when he will probably get offers from other clubs as a starting half or 9.

 

[Canadian Club]

might need tupou now bostock did his ACL

Not if they can get Cobbo before June 30. Broncos could use the cap space and front load some contracts for next year with Cobbos money off the books for the rest of the season.

 

[Tucker]

for depth? not every person we sign need to be superstars

Why are they letting him go so early? He hasnt had the chance to prove himself.
Seems a red flag to me.

 

[hsvjones]

The club should be doing everything to keep TDS. However if he leaves, Sandon Smith would be a good pick up to play 14. Covers hooker and dummy half. Although I doubt he would be open to coming here to play 14 when he will probably get offers from other clubs as a starting half or 9.

I would take Smith if we could get him. Covers a few positions and would be a perfect 14

 

[Vicious]

I would take Smith if we could get him. Covers a few positions and would be a perfect 14

Sandon Smith has now proven himself to be a good quality NRL starting halve, there is next to no chance he would be satisfied coming to a club such as Wests Tigers to be a number 14.

 

[tigahhh]

Why are they letting him go so early? He hasnt had the chance to prove himself.
Seems a red flag to me.

fair enough

 

[Vicious]

Dolphins are making a big play for Cobbo, which would explain their urgency to get Tupou's 550k off the books only 6 months into the deal.

Would poke around some of their forwards. Knowles, Plath, Gilbert, Flegler (maybe) still need to come back into this squad. With Lemuelu, Molo, Saifiti, Stone, Keeley, Nicholls, Finefuiaki, Stone and Su'a surely one or two may become available.

There would have to be a chance of them allowing Jake Averillo to depart early if they land Selwyn Cobbo.
Averillo would add plenty of speed to our line up and I’m sure I recall he’s a decent goal kicker.
I’d much prefer Cobbo if we had a coach who could get the best out of him, I’m far from convinced Benji has it in him to motivate someone such as Cobbo.

 

[Betterdays22]

There would have to be a chance of them allowing Jake Averillo to depart early if they land Selwyn Cobbo.
Averillo would add plenty of speed to our line up and I’m sure I recall he’s a decent goal kicker.
I’d much prefer Cobbo if we had a coach who could get the best out of him, I’m far from convinced Benji has it in him to motivate someone such as Cobbo.

I like it but taking the person Cobbo replaces at the Dolphins instead of having a red hot crack at Cobbo himself is very Tigers.

 

[Oldman]

That's BS. Not sure why this crap keeps coming out.
Jac was a talented teenager, Taylor wanted him to demonstrate both his attack and defence against men before getting a shot in first grade, which he did a few weeks later....
Nearly all players we've signed have been on 2 year deals, why did we only give him a one year deal in the first place, that's the big question

Don’t forget the Sharks let him go because they didn’t think his defence was up to NRL standard.
So called experts where proven wrong by bellyache again.

 

[Odessa]

Don’t forget the Sharks let him go because they didn’t think his defence was up to NRL standard.
So called experts where proven wrong by bellyache again.

What about Hynes he's having trouble with his teammates at the Shark's we need a good number 14

 

[AmericanHistoryX]

How's this thread going? Helping anyone?

 

[hodgo]

Nope - The Club really needs to win Football games.
Speed and Experience helps that happen.

Turuva and Skelton don't hold a Candle to Addo Carr - On either
Even Combined...

cant agree no matter how certain you are. Addo carr is handy but no more or no less handy then skelton or turuva. For the last 5 years we have been absolutely horrendous at yardage from our back 5. That is what we badly needed and that is what we went our and got. Addo car does not make our team better IMO. He is average at best doing the hard yards. Skleton and turva have been huge in that frame.

Out of curiosity what makes him better. Ill give you speed but what else

 

[AmericanHistoryX]

You can't help us either. Agree or not.

 

[Dennisspicer1]

What about Hynes he's having trouble with his teammates at the Shark's we need a good number 14

Not worth a pinch of shit.

 

[AmericanHistoryX]

Nor the conversation

 

[Vicious]

Nor the conversation

Don’t you like my input AHX ?