Tallyn Da Silva #270

[NT_Tiger]

Lol
Spare me the passive observer routine, it’s a convenient stance when you’d rather avoid accountability for having an actual opinion. Hiding behind the idea that Marshall “must live and die by his decisions” doesn’t make you wise or objective, it just means you’ve chosen to stay on the sidelines while pretending it’s some sort of virtue. If you think deferring everything to his judgment is the pinnacle of insight, then perhaps it’s not my perspective that needs adjusting.

Thanks again for sharing your unique wisdom. And speaking of high horses, you must ride a giraffe.

 

[TigerNeddyK]

I hate to put too much pressure on young players. I recall when Da Silva debuted there were comparisons being made to a teenaged Robbie Farah.

Well I’ve recently copped the tip from a very keen judge that Jared Haywood could well be the next Grant Fyvie.

Exciting times ahead at the back of the ruck for
Wests Tigers fans 👍

Who?

 

[Tucker]

You conveniently overlook the fact that he was NEVER going to stay .. and you know it .. he asked for a release before he debuted , several last year and only ever said “ I intend to serve out my contract”.. you can theorise over why he wanted to leave but I absolutely reckon it’s because he wanted to be at a powerhouse club ..

Yes I knew it, and the club knew it.
When it became apparent that he was starting to agitate, Richo called a sitdown with the family/manager and at the end of that the kid was talking very positively about the next 2 years.
The club had bought itself some time to turn his opinion around.
From there on out things just seemed to happen. Offer made early which brought the decision to reject out early which put the tenure of the current contract into doubt and eventually made it untenable and caused an early release.
So no Im not conveniently overlooking it. It all ties in to my opinion that situational events could have been handled better. We had secured the services of both Galvin and Tallyn until the end of 26. We may not have secured them past that point but we should have managed them better than losing one in May and the other July in 2025.

 

[Tucker]

Thanks again for sharing your unique wisdom. And speaking of high horses, you must ride a giraffe.

Dont get all pissy. You started this.

 

[WestsEffTheRest]

When Tucker took a week hiatus (I assume he was banned) I noticed this forum was a lot less hostile & you could actually engage in conversation. Now that he's back tensions are high again & the abuse has come back. Mods maybe make it permanent next time?

 

[NT_Tiger]

Dont get all pissy. You started this.

All pissy? I'm marvelling at your self awareness. You're a legend.

 

[Lestronge]

...and thats my point...gossipy women making up stories due to a few youtubes and fabricating things with no evidence

So am i.... you've misinterpreted me

Oh ok sorry mate

 

[Tucker]

All pissy? I'm marvelling at your self awareness. You're a legend.

Well I didnt attack you, I am barely aware you exist.

 

[Odessa]

When Tucker took a week hiatus (I assume he was banned) I noticed this forum was a lot less hostile & you could actually engage in conversation. Now that he's back tensions are high again & the abuse has come back. Mods maybe make it permanent next time?

Mate I like Tucker the forum wouldn't be the same

He's Robin to Batman
Garlic sauce to a lamb kebab
Bangers to mash

He's spicy and has an opinion you need different points of view you don't have to agree but how do you expand your mind without hearing other points of view

 

[innsaneink]

Dont get all pissy. You started this.

Naah... you started it.
Dont lie.
NT gave his opinion and you came back with yiur standard "you havent been paying attention lol"

So cut the crap

 

[WestsEffTheRest]

Mate I like Tucker the forum wouldn't be the same

He's Robin to Batman
Garlic sauce to a lamb kebab
Bangers to mash

He's spicy and has an opinion you need different points of view you don't have to agree but how do you expand your mind without hearing other points of view

Plenty of people can handle a different POV but people shouldn't have to deal with the abuse & narcissism that he brings when they think different.

 

[Demps]

"Goodbye Tallyn"

"We need you to start, but it's probably your last game."

This is ridiculous.
Extend the kid !
[And Api as well]

 

[Tucker]

Naah... you started it.
Dont lie.
NT gave his opinion and you came back with yiur standard "you havent been paying attention lol"

So cut the crap

"You havent been paying attention" isnt a personal attack.

 

[GNR4LIFE]

Like I'm keeping receipts for an internet Quamby.
this place has a search function, You're obviously a genius - You can sort it, Surely?
I know what I've read, More importantly - Got a giggle at.
Mentioned here a couple times by different posters - Without even really looking.

There have been dozens of posts of people worrying about upsetting the Fainu’s and thus the club needing to make decisions around their delicate feelings.

 

[Tucker]

Plenty of people can handle a different POV but people shouldn't have to deal with the abuse & narcissism that he brings when they think different.

You never say anything to me personally.
You never engage in any form of conversation about any football related topic with me.
You never put forward an opinion other than to snipe from the sidelines like a coward.
If you hate me so much put me on ignore...otherwise just shutup.

 

[WestsEffTheRest]

You never say anything to me personally.
You never engage in any form of conversation about any football related topic with me.
You never put forward an opinion other than to snipe from the sidelines like a coward.
If you hate me so much put me on ignore...otherwise just shutup.

Case in point.

 

[Tucker]

"Goodbye Tallyn"

"We need you to start, but it's probably your last game."

This is ridiculous.
Extend the kid !
[And Api as well]

Lol the mixed messages...
He must be sitting around the changeroom looking at the rest of them not having a clue what to say.

 

[tigahhh]

There have been dozens of posts of people worrying about upsetting the Fainu’s and thus the club needing to make decisions around their delicate feelings.

What is your problem with the fainu’s? You constantly villainise them on here.

I’m convinced half of you lot aren’t even WT fans just haters

 

[Demps]

Lol the mixed messages...
He must be sitting around the changeroom looking at the rest of them not having a clue what to say.

Kid deserves better.
But, I get it...

It's a shame really.
Wish him the best.

 

[tigahhh]

Kid deserves better.
But, I get it...

It's a shame really.
Wish him the best.

He’ll be missed for sure