Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

More the 85kg which is small for an nrl winger
He obviously needs an NRL off season or two. Needs just a skinny 20 year old currently.
It's the X factor that he has that we so desperately need. The skill to be able to pull something out of nothing, that gets you a contract. Put him in a professional system and he'll bulk up a bit more. Remember he basically just played at ball last year.
At present he's easily the best wing prospect outside of first grade at the club
 
Top 17 - most of the top 17 wernt even at the club 2 years ago

Bula - Loves Benji
Skelton - wasn't here
Toa
May - wasn't here
Turuva - wasn't here
Laui - wasn't here
Latu - Loves Benji
Twal - Benji made him Captain 2 weeks ago
Fainu - Loves Benji
Seyfarth
May - wasn't here
Api - loves Benji
Pole - Resigned since they left

Sukkar - Junior back then
Sam - Loves Benji
Doeuhi
Bird - wasn't here

Really not many options in the top 17
The whole story is being misreported and is clearly leaked by Moses. If they were all just 'spotted' there then how are any supposed contents of their conversation known? C'mon. All of a sudden Douhei's manager is Moses and 2 stories come out about Benji in 3 weeks. No coincidence.
 
Top 17 - most of the top 17 wernt even at the club 2 years ago

Bula - Loves Benji
Skelton - wasn't here
Toa
May - wasn't here
Turuva - wasn't here
Laui - wasn't here
Latu - Loves Benji
Twal - Benji made him Captain 2 weeks ago
Fainu - Loves Benji
Seyfarth
May - wasn't here
Api - loves Benji
Pole - Resigned since they left

Sukkar - Junior back then
Sam - Loves Benji
Doeuhi
Bird - wasn't here

Really not many options in the top 17
Curious where the evidence is that the Fainu's love Benji. Not saying they don't, just haven't seen anything suggesting they do.
 
idk why this forum is always so quick to point out the PI’s in the team …. like it means anything
Only reason being is the talk of a clique in the group between Benji and the players. I don't buy it but I could understand how not being in the majority culturally could make someone feel like an outsider a bit. I think there's nothing to it. In saying that if players did feel like outsiders and decided to air their dirty laundry to Lee and Justin, imo those players know where the door is and are free to use it.
 
So what your saying is that Balmain panicked and kicked possession away despite being given six again 🤣🤣🤣

And they blame Wests for being losers 🤷‍♂️
a bird in the hand is worth 2 in the bush ! if the tigers survived on their own , they almost certainly would have ended up at Gosford , considering that was the original singo plan, only for the timelibes to not match up re. blue tongue stadium. even norths really, should have stayed, for they met nearly all criteria , and were totally screwed in the last season because when they committed to gosford , building was delayed so badly, it messed their backpocket significantly .
Its posts like yours that reveal who you really are , and are the reason many on here have no time for anyone advocating what you do
 
He obviously needs an NRL off season or two. Needs just a skinny 20 year old currently.
It's the X factor that he has that we so desperately need. The skill to be able to pull something out of nothing, that gets you a contract. Put him in a professional system and he'll bulk up a bit more. Remember he basically just played at ball last year.
At present he's easily the best wing prospect outside of first grade at the club
Don’t disagree with you for one second.

Looking at Makasini’s performances in NSW cup though it seems quite a possibility he is ready for NRL next season. Do wonder if May goes left wing, Makasini left centre. Skelton goes NSW Cup on left wing. Do we go Tavana right wing in cup or Staines?
 
Doesn't Pepper Money sponsor Benji

Yeah maybe ….I love it when one person here says something ( about a sponsor paying Benji’s salary) and then people start running with it like it’s fact .. I would be very surprised if the club is not paying Benji’s salary…. Perhaps he has a sponsor arrangement elsewhere though.. I doubtthis would be “hidden” as originally claimed 👍
 
We only have one development spot left and there are 3 players I would want on development for next year who I feel are the highest risk of being poached by another club if we don't.

1. Logan Deininger. Has probably been our pathways standout success story so far this year having been scouted out of Far North QLD in the off season and playing SG Ball for Balmain before taking over as the full time Flegg fullback. Yesterday he single handledly won us the game with a huge defensive play followed up by scoring a try nobody in our roster could have scored. He is an elite talent at a premium position and should get upgraded if we don't want to lose him.

2. Josese Lanyon. Josese played most of the Flegg season at 9 but has moved to 13 since Haywood got promoted to Flegg and has probably been consistently our best player since. That Havili type of utility player is something we desperately lack. At a club who needs a quality option at 13 with utility value he is one I expect to go on to play NRL so we should be developing him with priority. Josese is also an external recruit that is in his first year with us. His younger brother James had a fantastic Harold Matthews season and appears to be a premium outside back.

3. Tino Tavana. Tino has been in our pathways now for years and has been a standout on many occasions. He is a freakish match winner who can play fullback, wing and centre well plus kick goals. Everyone knows about him.

Other Flegg grade players I would hope we can keep on second tier contracts are Iverson Matai, Max Liles, Marc Tannous, Mitchell and Max Taotua and Elijah Mataale. I would like to keep Feledy around if we could do so without him being on top 30 but it seems unlikely. All of these players have potential to become quality NRL players in time.

In terms of NSW cup level players the unsigned ones who have NRL depth upside are Solomona Faataape, Brent Naden, Jaxson Rahme, Alex Lobb, Isaac Tuitupou, Luke Jack, Elie El-Zackhem and Kurt Falls. I would hope we could retain as many of them as possible on NSW cup contracts as they would offer useful depth post round 11.

I would say despite the results going our way as often as we would like you can tell that the pathways program has taken a leap this year. Both SG Ball sides just missed the 8, Flegg and NSW cup started poorly but once they found their best rosters are competing with the best sides. And now we are beginning to see the "good problem" of genuinely good young players not being able to progress due to not being better than others. When we lose good players from our pathways not because they want to go to greener pastures but because we simply don't have the room, that's when it's working. I am afraid we will see quite a lot more of this!
 

Latest posts

Back
Top