Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[Odessa]

No he hasn’t ..,

Something has gone wrong … you would have to say in hindsight he has been promoted too early .., a lesson for the next time

I think this year he should have played cup and first grade a few games up then a few games down to get him use to the demand of first grade and don't burn him out or break him

 

[weststigers]

I think this year he should have played cup and first grade a few games up then a few games down to get him use to the demand of first grade and don't burn him out or break him

We need to remember he's 18 still. Let him develop a bit. I don't think we see the best of him until 21 or 22.

 

[wstigers11]

I think this year he should have played cup and first grade a few games up then a few games down to get him use to the demand of first grade and don't burn him out or break him

Yep + early injuries with Star & May so he had to cover centres before his time and it’s knocked his confidence.

 

[bigsiro]

Do you really think he has? I like him, I think he’s a good player and we are always better when he’s in the team. But he’s 24 or 25. He’s not a dynamic runner (lacks acceleration, is lithe, and therefore not powerful). I kind of think he is what he is. He’ll always be an 8 to 10 ranked fullback out of 17 to 18 teams.

Agreed.
I was ambivalent about re-signing him.
No doubt, if we did not re-sign him, his many fans here would have gone berserk and would now be saying his poor form is due to not being re-signed. Well, it’s not that.

He is proving, again, that he just isn’t that good.

He doesn’t break the line. He doesn’t offer a creative option. Shown up by Fuller and Kini in successive weeks.

Hope someone else comes in. Bula can be back up. If this year has shown anything, it’s that we lack depth.

 

[Tom Shines]

Yep + early injuries with Star & May so he had to cover centres before his time and it’s knocked his confidence.

The opposition every week early in the season went after him… ( legally) ..,

The step up from the lower grade to NRL is a massive one and should be strongly considered when promoting an 18 yr old

 

[hank37w]

He's annoying ay

Much like Clarkey

Finish the following sentence:

Isaac is a . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

 

[crazycat]

Averillo and Blore would definitely improve us, but still not good enough to get us into the top 8, we need a couple more good quality players to add depth.

Why do people keep saying "add depth".

Our problem is always the quality of 1-17. not 18-30.

We need to trade depth for quality and that's what I think Benji has been doing with punting Jack Bird (400k) for Pat Herbert (150k/min). We have to keep doing this till we get a first grade 1-17.

Then you can start upgrading guys like Starford (who is finally regaining form admittedly), or look at our forwards and add beef there.


We need our first grade to be of a higher quality, if we can improve our reserve grade sure. The focus of our cap and spending should be getting a good first grade side.

 

[user118245]

What the Australian squad going against America!

A nation of 400 Million people who usually dominate most olympic sports. The only reason why they did not do well at Soccer is they did not care about soccer. Now they are starting to care...

Against:

27 Million Australians, A nation that can get to the top 5 Olympic spots. Yet also doesn't have Soccer as our national sport...

...

Damn it just hit me.
I just don't care about soccer at all.
Meh Next comment about Luke Brooks hooking up with Gavlin please.

There are more people who play registered soccer in America than there is people who play across all ages and game levels (rec/youth/competitive etc) in Australia

 

[innsaneink]

I think Bula is a bit of a victim of our teams overall lack of speed...hes easily handled when half chances arrive because the defence hasnt had to work too hard.
Hes been disappointing lately lowest run meters of all fullbacks so far this round
Our.lack of speed compared to probably the fastest team in the comp was extremely evident yesterday.

We really need to recruit some fast outside backs and a big kicker

 

[tonza]

Maka needs a year in cup, apart from the Penrith trial I don’t think he’s dominated a game all season

He appears to have had his confidence smashed out of him. Hopefully he can come good, but it might have to be in cup.

 

[Bellend]

Maka should have been left in Flegg this year with the odd game in Koe cup.

 

[hugh1954]

Why do people keep saying "add depth".

Our problem is always the quality of 1-17. not 18-30.

We need to trade depth for quality and that's what I think Benji has been doing with punting Jack Bird (400k) for Pat Herbert (150k/min). We have to keep doing this till we get a first grade 1-17.

Then you can start upgrading guys like Starford (who is finally regaining form admittedly), or look at our forwards and add beef there.


We need our first grade to be of a higher quality, if we can improve our reserve grade sure. The focus of our cap and spending should be getting a good first grade side.

We need a danger player like Weekes, genuine speed, where is our Larry Corowa today ?. I cannot think of one player who could provde that in our team

 

[pawsandclaws1]

I would have targeted Tyrell Sloan for our wing. He's a different commodity to the normal winger but needs a coach who can bring out the best in him. Also yesterday, it was two impressive young footballers who hit the go button when they sensed a weakness and try scoring opportunity. Haywood went into overdrive at dummy half to get the ball to Andrews who sent that outrageously good pass to our left winger for the try. Also Attard backing up the middle to take the pass from Haywood was a classic fullback play. There's lots to be excited about but they need time.

 

[TheEnz]

Yep + early injuries with Star & May so he had to cover centres before his time and it’s knocked his confidence.

You can tell both he and taylan are not using their fend as much, for maka its a confidence thing and probably shoulder injury related and for taylan its shoulder injury and risk of recurrence.

 

[Buttface]

He’s too light

Tall and light.
His Mrs carried him over the threshold
He needs to work this FB role out, I don’t see any other spot for him.