Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

I’m dubious signing Fogarty to one year , but could probably live with it …

2028 as well though is too much of a stretch …hopefully he might want to try the SL by then if he is indeed coming ,..

it would probably see a fogarty 7 Douhie 6 pairing
where that leaves latu and Andrews...

So it seems to leave them out the back door ?

No one has been a bigger supporter here of Latu than me, but he has not demonstrated any consistency given his injury history, so I don’t think you can plan he will be there in 2027 ..you are just crossing your fingers …. It’s a shame because he does seem to have somthing I would like to see more of ..

Andrews hasn’t tuned 20 yet , and I doubt Benji is gunna play him much in 2027....I’m hoping he can remain patient …
 
Last edited:
I’m dubious signing Fogarty to one year , but could probably live with it …

2028 as well though is too much of a stretch …hopefully he might want to try the SL by then if he is indeed coming ,..



So it seems to leave them out the back door ?

No one has been a bigger supporter here of Latu than me, but he has not demonstrated any consistency given his injury history, so I don’t think you can plan he will be there in 2027 ..you are just crossing your fingers …. It’s a shame because he does seem to have somthing I would like to see more of ..

Andrews hasn’t tuned 20 yet , and I doubt Benji is gunna play him much in 2027....I’m hoping he can remain patient …
agree with latu, we cant pin our hopes on him re his injury history it would be a big risk
 
Fogarty is the type of signing that fans will applaud now but will blow up at the club about mid July next year when he's not performing and one of our young halves requests to leave due to lack of opportunities.

Happens all the time with our fans and club.
 
Madden going the other way to Manly might be tolerable. At least if Madden goes it stops Latu or Andrews getting offside

It just makes no sense to let a 26 year old Madden go who is on no money to sign a 34 year old on good money that does the same job. Both are poor defenders, both have no running game, both organise well and both kick well. Madden steps up with the game on the line while Fogarty crumbles with the game on the line. When you take into account future improvement and salary cap management, you take Madden over Fogarty every time.

Im ok if Fogarty comes so we can have like for like at 6 and 7 in NRL and reserve grade, but to replace Madden with a player costing us 500k more who is on the decline and offers no more than what Madden does is crazy.
 
We're all crossing our fingers that this is the case. I'm sure every Tigers supporter wants to make the eight next year. But it's not a long term solution, and it could potentially block our juniors and potentially force some to leave.
All those you mentioned arent here for long, and it will give those juniors that you rhink will be blocked - time to develop.
Constantly we hear our juniors are rushed before theyre ready...alternately if theyre not.promoted instantly theyre blocked.
This sounds like Mick Crawley at work already
 
It just makes no sense to let a 26 year old Madden go who is on no money to sign a 34 year old on good money that does the same job. Both are poor defenders, both have no running game, both organise well and both kick well. Madden steps up with the game on the line while Fogarty crumbles with the game on the line. When you take into account future improvement and salary cap management, you take Madden over Fogarty every time.

Im ok if Fogarty comes so we can have like for like at 6 and 7 in NRL and reserve grade, but to replace Madden with a player costing us 500k more who is on the decline and offers no more than what Madden does is crazy.
Our priority is to build depth, at low cost, not fitter it away. Madden is an integral component of the team.
 
Back
Top