Cricket Season Thread

I'm just disappointed that Smith didn't put his foot down and say don't do it. Clearly from Bancroft's statement Smith didn't like the idea "Captain Steve Smith came into the conversation and, as I remember it, made it clear that he wanted no part in it before distancing himself"
So he couldn’t nix it as captain? You think Steve Waugh would have distanced himself from something he didn’t like? The guy is a total coward. It’s been evident since the initial press conference in SA, who when asked what happened, turned to Bancroft, a rookie and said “Wanna explain yourself?”. He has the backbone of a paramecium and isn’t fit to captain a pub team.
 
Warner's idea.

From Bancroft's statement today: "David Warner raised the possibility of using sandpaper to roughen one side of the ball"

Not sure who told Bancroft to do it but you'd think from the context of the conversation and the problems raised within that conversation with Warner doing the sand papering, that the obvious person who asked Bancroft to do it was Warner.

From Bancroft's statement today: "I was asked whether I could carry out the task"

I'm just disappointed that Smith didn't put his foot down and say don't do it. Clearly from Bancroft's statement Smith didn't like the idea "Captain Steve Smith came into the conversation and, as I remember it, made it clear that he wanted no part in it before distancing himself"

Not good enough Steve. You should have put your foot down.
Like many others we could have accepted the ICC short bans and moved on.

If CA wanted to impose further, makes sense the main architect, captain and player doing it were the ones.

What does Warner want?
 
What does Warner want?

Davey isn't the sharpest tool in the shed. Remember, this guy drove drunk and attempted to swap driver seats when confronted with a RBT. Don't know, wouldn't attempt to try to think like him.

So he couldn’t nix it as captain? You think Steve Waugh would have distanced himself from something he didn’t like? The guy is a total coward. It’s been evident since the initial press conference in SA, who when asked what happened, turned to Bancroft, a rookie and said “Wanna explain yourself?”. He has the backbone of a paramecium and isn’t fit to captain a pub team.

I couldn't imagine a dressing room of Ian Chappell, Alan Border, Mark Taylor, Ricky Ponting or Steve Waugh allowing such shenanigans to happen.

For all the criticism of Greg Chappell for the under arm bowling, it was allowed under the rules of the game, though clearly against the Spirit of the game. He wouldn't have allowed such shenanigans to happen.

As an old try hard wannabe fast bowler for 30 odd years - having just come from the physio fixing my aching old back - I was guilty of ball tampering every single game. I massaged gallons of sweat into those balls, as did every other wannabe fast bowler. And yes, we talked about bottle caps down the pub after a dozen or so sherberts, but we never would actually go through with it. To use sandpaper never crossed our minds.

They say cricket is a funny game. There is a saying "it is just not cricket". Using sandpaper to doctor the ball clearly falls into that category.
 
Yeah he had nothing left to lose. As if he didn't know that he would be called out for saying something eight years after the fact when his career was over and it was no longer financially disadvantageous to him to say something.

He didn't stick up for his mate, he let him take the wrap while he and his other complicit teammates who said nothing all those years got to have a career and at worst copped muted jibes about how they may have known. If he had have stuck up for his mate he would have said something at the time, no matter what the cost was to him, or his teammates. There is absolutely nothing brave about what he has done.
He knew he would be called out but still said it.

He didn't stick up for his mate, felt guilty about it and said it later. Yes he should have done it then, on within these 8 years but still to go against the team and say it now is commendable, you can't say the same for the other 15 people who knew as well.

The repercussions are less but not absent.

I still call Bancroft brave for what he did today, same as Sayers and Warner.

This was a crappy situation. Everyone was tampering the ball at the time and probably moreso in the 90s without cameras.

To me the issue was never tampering or suggestions to tamper. The issue was always CA throwing 3 people under the bus. When your employer throws them under the bus and you're scared of your own job, you're not going to speak out.

Let's see it from CAs point of view too, the PM at the time said something about being embarrassed and based on the high moral grounds they'd taken at the time, they painted themselves in a corner.

I don't understand the personal attacks on Warner, Jhawaja or even Patty. We don't need villains.
 
Davey isn't the sharpest tool in the shed. Remember, this guy drove drunk and attempted to swap driver seats when confronted with a RBT. Don't know, wouldn't attempt to try to think like him.



I couldn't imagine a dressing room of Ian Chappell, Alan Border, Mark Taylor, Ricky Ponting or Steve Waugh allowing such shenanigans to happen.

For all the criticism of Greg Chappell for the under arm bowling, it was allowed under the rules of the game, though clearly against the Spirit of the game. He wouldn't have allowed such shenanigans to happen.

As an old try hard wannabe fast bowler for 30 odd years - having just come from the physio fixing my aching old back - I was guilty of ball tampering every single game. I massaged gallons of sweat into those balls, as did every other wannabe fast bowler. And yes, we talked about bottle caps down the pub after a dozen or so sherberts, but we never would actually go through with it. To use sandpaper never crossed our minds.

They say cricket is a funny game. There is a saying "it is just not cricket". Using sandpaper to doctor the ball clearly falls into that category.
I know we like to romanticise the past, but do you really think ball tampering was just restricted that specific generation of players in 2018?
 
Another interesting layer to the 2018 saga coming out in the SMH today, turns out the team's media manager, Kate Hutchison, actually resigned in the week before Newlands because she'd had enough of the squad's out of control behaviour on that tour, and she ended up speaking out against the sandpaper plan too.

It really backs up the idea that the whole environment around that tour had completely gone off the rails well before Cape Town blew up.
 
I know we like to romanticise the past, but do you really think ball tampering was just restricted that specific generation of players in 2018?

Ball tampering has been happening since the game was invented. I don't think that has ever been in dispute.

I am guilty as charged. I am not going to speak for every cricket player in the world, but I suspect that a sizeable majority are also guilty as charged.

I played at a reasonable level and for near on 35 years. In all my time, I can hold my hand over my heart and say not once did I engage in ball tampering using anything other than sweat and my fingernail. I didn't have to take those things onto the field because they were already there as a part of my body.

That sort of ball tampering is accepted and expected.

Sandpaper isn't part of the human anatomy the last time I looked.

Was sandpaper used to tamper with a cricket ball in a test, first class or ODI match prior to 2018? I can not say with any degree of certainty that no cricketeer used such tactics. Perhaps they did. Perhaps they were just better at getting away with it. I don't know. I have no way of knowing.

Dopey Davey and Bancroft were caught.

So draw your own conclusion. They were either dreadfully unlucky because "it has been going on for years" or they were just plain dumb arse cheaters that were caught in the act. Perhaps this is proof that past players were just that bit smarter not to get caught. Take your pick.
 

THE PREAMBLE – THE SPIRIT OF CRICKET​

Cricket owes much of its appeal and enjoyment to the fact that it should be played not only according to the Laws, but also within the Spirit of Cricket.

The major responsibility for ensuring fair play rests with the captains, but extends to all players, match officials and, especially in junior cricket, teachers, coaches and parents.

Respect is central to the Spirit of Cricket.
  • Respect your captain, teammates, opponents and the authority of the umpires.
  • Play hard and play fair.
  • Accept the umpire’s decision.
  • Create a positive atmosphere by your own conduct, and encourage others to do likewise.
  • Show self-discipline, even when things go against you.
  • Congratulate the opposition on their successes, and enjoy those of your own team.
  • Thank the officials and your opposition at the end of the match, whatever the result.
Cricket is an exciting game that encourages leadership, friendship and teamwork, which brings together people from different nationalities, cultures and religions, especially when played within the Spirit of Cricket.
 
Back
Top