Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

I get what you’re saying but I’m still not giving them that out.

Even with all the injuries, there were multiple opportunities to play Latu as a starting half and Benji opted for Jock Madden every single time. The depth issue is on Benji as he is responsible for recruitment and he wanted to let our backup hooker, TDS, walk early

Benji used Latu off the bench to cover his recruitment/retention mistakes and it was at the expense of Latu’s development as a half.

I said it last year and ill say ot again, Benji is the worst coach this club has ever seen.
 
A lot of emotion and speculation about the Latu situation which is understandable. I have been the same as Latu is one of my favourites and I have so much belief in his ability and where it can take us.

But I think we should wait until the club gives us an explanation to its recruitment strategy this season. An explanation which will probably only come once our recruitment for 2027 is done unfortunately.

1 We don't know Benji's reasons for allowing Latu to explore a loan for 2027.

2 Maybe Benji has identified the need for a game managing senior halfback to improve the team.

3 Maybe there was more to the Doeuihi blow-up last season than what has been revealed (cough Luai) & maybe AD is still held in high regard by his team mates. Not condoning how he went about it but maybe his relationship with Benji & team mates has not been affected.

4 Maybe the football dept has seen the need for more senior players who lead standards both on the field & training, hence the arrival of Frizell, Mann, Brailey and possibly JAC and Fogarty.

5 I think we have all identified a lack of speed out wide as a need for us so JAC ticks another box here & explains our early interest in Schiller and bringing back pathways player Mikey Nassar.

6 Maybe we are at 29 contracted players atm if Bunty Afoa & Tony Sukkar are amongst them. Maybe to get a few extra pieces that the football dept have identified (Fogs & JAC and maybe another), we have to let a player or 2 go. May explain Royce still be allowed to explore opportunity plus Latu, who knows who else has been given permission.

Look there a lot of maybes in there and for a reason, we don't know what the club are doing and the reasons for it. And we probably won't know for a while yet either. But no need for some of the comments about Benji & Shaun imo until we hear from them.
Comes back to a real communication breakdown between the club & it’s fans in everything they do
 
Comes back to a real communication breakdown between the club & it’s fans
Yeah I have harped about club comms for a while. It seems they keep everything in-house until official and don't comment on speculation or leaks from agents.

I get that the CEO & Coach can't comment on every rumour as it arises in the media but surely they can come out and either shut it down or provide some reasoning to us fans. I doubt it affects negotiations or their relationship with players if it's already happening in the background.

Some transparency would be a breath of fresh air.
 
Bula is good at catching high balls… and running at half speed… unless he gets in the clear and then runs fast (which happens once every four games)
He's a terrible fullback but nearly everyone on here was for signing him. The only way he gets rep honours is for the Cook Islands. They could cut Teddy's hands off and hobble him and he's still infinitely better
 
its nobody's money really mate and after katoa he's shown he's the next young gun half in line, he's going to have his ups and downs and is no where near the finished product but you don't get better not playing your position. you should hope all of our players stay injury free. He's due for some luck on that front
You don't live on luck - we'd all be millionaires. He 22 - probably soon to be 23 and still under an injury cloud every week. Hasn't manages more than 13 games a season. If he tears it up at another club so be it but $500k is well over his output
 

2027 NRL Halfback Rankings​

RankHalfbackClub
1Nathan ClearyPenrith Panthers
2Jahrome HughesMelbourne Storm
3Tom DeardenNorth Queensland Cowboys
4Sam WalkerSydney Roosters
5Isaiya KatoaDolphins
6Dylan BrownParramatta Eels
7Luke MetcalfNew Zealand Warriors
8Jonah PezetBrisbane Broncos
9Braydon TrindallCronulla Sharks
10Jayden CampbellGold Coast Titans
11Fletcher SharpeNewcastle Knights
12Ethan SandersCanberra Raiders
13Mitchell WoodsCanterbury Bulldogs
14Joey WalshManly Sea Eagles
15Kyle FlanaganSt George Illawarra Dragons
16Latu FainuWests Tigers
17Ashton WardSouth Sydney Rabbitohs
 
By what - injury ? Poor technique leading to suspensions ??

Here we go, this old chestnut. No one is saying he hasnt been responsible for some of his lack of development through injury. However everything else around that has been handled terribly by Benji. Besides lack of opportunity given to him when there seems a clear spot for him to start at 6 or 7, or play KOE cup there, let me ask you this....why in 3 years has his tackle technique not been fixed? This is and easy fix and this is supposed to be a professional organisation.

To say his development has been hindered by himself is laughable at best. If he was at Melbourne he is a star by now
 
I’m trying to think this craziness through logically…

Firstly, fact is we need an organising half who plays right side. We are literally bottom 4 without it. I get that the club has prioritised this over every other external recruitment priority.

Fogarty is a organising half who plays right side. He doesn’t make us a top 8 team, but probably moves us out of the bottom 4 where we sit today. He’s also available. For a first grade half he is likely very cheap.

Thus, the starting point is we need to work out a new plan that builds off Fogarty (right side controlling half with some ball playing ability but very limited running threat).

Let’s then try to logically build the backline from this new starting point.

Jake Averillo arrives as a right sided player, one would think as a centre. Even if the 5/8 chat was real, he would still be right side 5/8 and thus isn’t likely to be the first player you put into a backline that starts with Fogarty. That said, feels like a perfect centre partner for someone like Fogarty.

So, now I’m scratching my head, where could we possibly find a left sided running ball player?

That player will be inside literally our best back Taylan May. Logically, the player then needs to have a tool kit that makes the most of the players on their outside.

Buellllleer buellllller…. (Sorry for the old man reference)

Somehow the club then start to focus in on Adam Doueihi. Typically a right sided player. Good ball runner but is weakest at setting up other players unless as support runner once Adam beats a player.

Now that we have found the player to stifle Taylan Mays game the next thing the club does is start talking about removing the fall back, Latu (that shouldn’t have been the fall back).

Okay… whilst I am going to vomit in my mouth writing this let me offer some remote and probably stupid explanations.

Option1
Benji wants Latu to develop as a right sided controlling half. He believes this will occur best at another club (RATHER THAN OUR OWN STATE CUP). Option 2
Benji wants Latu to develop as a left sided 5/8 but believes Javon is a higher priority.
Option 3
The club is bluffing to bring down his 2028 price.
Option 4
The club has another left side 5/8 incoming (eg Munster) on a 1 year deal who would be in addition to Fogarty. They need to offer a player other clubs will actually pay for (hence the Maka rumour and now the Latu rumour).

I’m going with option 4. Every other option is too consistent with the last 10 years. We have learnt from those lessons…. Or have we
 
Back
Top