Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

Dylan Brown..eels...?
There's probably more errors on that list than accurate.
As things stand:
Brown: Eels not knights.
Metcalfe: Warriors not Dragons.
Trindal not Hynes: Sharks.
Campbell not Harrison: Titans.
Sharpe not Brown or even Smith: Knights.
Woods not Galvin: Bulldogs.
Walsh not Fogarty: Manly (may prove accurate by the time the season starts).
Flanagan not Metcalf: Dragons.
Fainu: doubtful he starts 7 but at this stage it is as good a guess as any.
 
Firstly, fact is we need an organising half who plays right side. We are literally bottom 4 without it. I get that the club has prioritised this over every other external recruitment priority. Fogarty is a organising half who plays right side. He doesn’t make us a top 8 team, but probably moves us out of the bottom 4 where we sit today. He’s also available. For a first grade half he is likely very cheap.
Thus, the starting point is we need to work out a new plan that builds off Fogarty (right side controlling half with some ball playing ability but very limited running threat). Let’s then try to logically build the backline from this new starting point.

Jake Averillo arrives as a right sided player, one would think as a centre. Even if the 5/8 chat was real, he would still be right side 5/8 and thus isn’t likely to be the first player you put into a backline that starts with Fogarty. That said, feels like a perfect centre partner for someone like Fogarty.
So, now I’m scratching my head, where could we possibly find a left sided running ball player? That player will be inside literally our best back Taylan May. Logically, the player then needs to have a tool kit that makes the most of the players on their outside. Somehow the club then start to focus in on Adam Doueihi. Typically a right sided player. Good ball runner but is weakest at setting up other players unless as support runner once Adam beats a player.

Now that we have found the player to stifle Taylan Mays game the next thing the club does is start talking about removing the fall back, Latu (that shouldn’t have been the fall back).

No need for me to add anything more.
 
Don't think our forward depth is good enough to get rid of Royce. We were well below par on forward depth this year and so far we have lost 2 (Afoa and Hunt) and signed two (Frizzle and Mann).

Amongst all signing talk, I just don't think we have addressed our biggest issue and thats forward depth. A winger such as JAC will have limited difference in my opinion, with how we play. It's not like we are creating a heap of opportunities for our wingers. Turuva went 13 games or so without scoring, and it was not as if I sat there and thought he should of scored any...there was literally very few opps that went his way.

We need to be better in the middle and edges first and I don't see that being improved (much).
I think Afoa is still with us.
 
Bula has no more excuses...should be fully fit hitting the ground running at trials time
I think what you see with Bula is what you get im afraid. We keep waiting for him to take the leap to Tedesco’s level, but he doesn’t have it in him. At least not at our club. Would be fascinating to see how he’d go at a club like the Roosters.
 
Last edited:
Don’t forget, it’s all just a rumour at this stage.
How do we know it’s not a ploy to show Mario and Latu that we are the only club currently willing to pay him 500k per season and show he is not a walk up start in the halves at any rival NRL club?
For all we know it could be all a ploy and we have no intention of loaning him out?
Based on historical evidence that seems too smart of a play for our management
 
The loan is a 100% about creating a roster spot and freeing up salary cap space. Nothing to do with Latu’s development , he has been offered as he is the player that is most likely to attract interest and plays in a position we can cover for a year.

Absolutely a stupid plan as it could go so terribly wrong and the thought of a Foggerty and AD as our 7 and 6 gives me nightmares
 
You don't live on luck - we'd all be millionaires. He 22 - probably soon to be 23 and still under an injury cloud every week. Hasn't manages more than 13 games a season. If he tears it up at another club so be it but $500k is well over his output
quick google puts him at 21, 22 in may next year. 500 for half of his obvious ability, not counting his clear willingness to play ball for the club and Benji plus his brothers, and be a team player, seems par
 
I’m trying to think this craziness through logically…

Firstly, fact is we need an organising half who plays right side. We are literally bottom 4 without it. I get that the club has prioritised this over every other external recruitment priority.

Fogarty is a organising half who plays right side. He doesn’t make us a top 8 team, but probably moves us out of the bottom 4 where we sit today. He’s also available. For a first grade half he is likely very cheap.

Thus, the starting point is we need to work out a new plan that builds off Fogarty (right side controlling half with some ball playing ability but very limited running threat).

Let’s then try to logically build the backline from this new starting point.

Jake Averillo arrives as a right sided player, one would think as a centre. Even if the 5/8 chat was real, he would still be right side 5/8 and thus isn’t likely to be the first player you put into a backline that starts with Fogarty. That said, feels like a perfect centre partner for someone like Fogarty.

So, now I’m scratching my head, where could we possibly find a left sided running ball player?

That player will be inside literally our best back Taylan May. Logically, the player then needs to have a tool kit that makes the most of the players on their outside.

Buellllleer buellllller…. (Sorry for the old man reference)

Somehow the club then start to focus in on Adam Doueihi. Typically a right sided player. Good ball runner but is weakest at setting up other players unless as support runner once Adam beats a player.

Now that we have found the player to stifle Taylan Mays game the next thing the club does is start talking about removing the fall back, Latu (that shouldn’t have been the fall back).

Okay… whilst I am going to vomit in my mouth writing this let me offer some remote and probably stupid explanations.

Option1
Benji wants Latu to develop as a right sided controlling half. He believes this will occur best at another club (RATHER THAN OUR OWN STATE CUP). Option 2
Benji wants Latu to develop as a left sided 5/8 but believes Javon is a higher priority.
Option 3
The club is bluffing to bring down his 2028 price.
Option 4
The club has another left side 5/8 incoming (eg Munster) on a 1 year deal who would be in addition to Fogarty. They need to offer a player other clubs will actually pay for (hence the Maka rumour and now the Latu rumour).

I’m going with option 4. Every other option is too consistent with the last 10 years. We have learnt from those lessons…. Or have we
How about we drop this tired left side/right side crap and have roaming halves who work the whole field over?
 
BREAKING NEWS: HBG have just released a new Strategic 10-year plan.

Following on from the recent leaks regarding the "loans" of Makasini & Latu Fainu, the HBG has announced that from January 2027, all Macarthur Pathways teams will officially be on loan to whoever wants them.

Dennis Burgess said, "We realised that the cost of running the Macarthur Pathways was becoming prohibitive, especially when players kept leaving our nursery having honed their exceptional skills at our cost".

The new Plan provides for players to be given a chance to develop their skills further with a legally binding player option clause to return to the Club in 10 years.

"As an incentive and sign of goodwill, I have promised each player who returns after 10 years of Development, will receive a personally signed edition of My Masters Apprentices Mix Tape".

🍷 🕺 🤣🐯🍻
On a serious note. Where can i purchase his Mixed Tape. I believe i would be the only person to own one.
 

Latest posts

Staff online

Back
Top