Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

The Cheifs/PVL NRL are stuffing up.the whole notion of a salary cap. Now Turbo has knocked back a contract extension worth reportedly 1,650, 000 for 2 years when he has hardly played 50% of the last couple of seasons and is aging. Clubs can not seriously keep a squad together and remain under the cap with players having an inflated view of what they are worth when they find out what players are getting for 2 years at PNG.
It is becoming a joke, and I would be pissed if I was Bears.

Has PNG even signed a local player or just keep buying top players.
The way this is going they will be a top 4 team 1st year

NRL need to think of the existing teams as well.
 
It is becoming a joke, and I would be pissed if I was Bears.

Has PNG even signed a local player or just keep buying top players.
The way this is going they will be a top 4 team 1st year

NRL need to think of the existing teams as well.
Respectfully mate. Of course they are. The NRL is Scripted . That team is going to get the rub of green like Broncos being reffed by harrigan.
Its probably part of the deal with the two governments "make them successful". They will be on ever add ever banner every poster. The talking heads are going to crow about them incessantly. Any one that has spent time in PNG knows there is an underlying promise of danger there. If that team struggles it wont be emails and news reports it will be riots and tribal wars.
 
It is becoming a joke, and I would be pissed if I was Bears.

Has PNG even signed a local player or just keep buying top players.
The way this is going they will be a top 4 team 1st year

NRL need to think of the existing teams as well.
Think Chiefs will fade fast..spent a truckload on aging marquees..mostly backs..and will run out of $$..
Dunno who is gonna fill the empty slots for $300.k .inconvenience of lifestyle not worth the tax benefits
..then mid season that aging roster will havecalve/hamstring/shoulder issues so they will struggle
 

2027 NRL Halfback Rankings​

RankHalfbackClub
1Nathan ClearyPenrith Panthers
2Jahrome HughesMelbourne Storm
3Tom DeardenNorth Queensland Cowboys
4Sam WalkerSydney Roosters
5Isaiya KatoaDolphins
6Dylan BrownParramatta Eels
7Luke MetcalfNew Zealand Warriors
8Jonah PezetBrisbane Broncos
9Braydon TrindallCronulla Sharks
10Jayden CampbellGold Coast Titans
11Fletcher SharpeNewcastle Knights
12Ethan SandersCanberra Raiders
13Mitchell WoodsCanterbury Bulldogs
14Joey WalshManly Sea Eagles
15Kyle FlanaganSt George Illawarra Dragons
16Latu FainuWests Tigers
17Ashton WardSouth Sydney Rabbitohs
What a laugh. It’s not a serious list
 
It is becoming a joke, and I would be pissed if I was Bears.

Has PNG even signed a local player or just keep buying top players.
The way this is going they will be a top 4 team 1st year

NRL need to think of the existing teams as well.
I'm in Perth and was keen to go see games but the side is legit bottom 4. This is all on the NRL. Pushing head first. Even with the tax incentives how can they still get these top players? Luai is on over a million himself. Not to mention the rest of the al stars. They will have no depth because they won't have any money left. They can say to players who are currently on 500k for example we will offer you 500k tax free. If they offer 400k then players still see that as a reduction. Not the brightest of bulbs.

If PNG hypothetically won a premiership I would sue the NRL.
 
I'm in Perth and was keen to go see games but the side is legit bottom 4. This is all on the NRL. Pushing head first. Even with the tax incentives how can they still get these top players? Luai is on over a million himself. Not to mention the rest of the al stars. They will have no depth because they won't have any money left. They can say to players who are currently on 500k for example we will offer you 500k tax free. If they offer 400k then players still see that as a reduction. Not the brightest of bulbs.

If PNG hypothetically won a premiership I would sue the NRL.
PNG will not be successful.
Their big name players are mostly Paper Tigers who are old, out of form or haven’t played NRL for years.
They are also hogging most of the cap with nothing left over for depth.
They’ll be bottom 4 and their finishing positions may get worse over time.
 
PNG will not be successful.
Their big name players are mostly Paper Tigers who are old, out of form or haven’t played NRL for years.
They are also hogging most of the cap with nothing left over for depth.
They’ll be bottom 4 and their finishing positions may get worse over time.
Do they have any forwards ? Just Young ?

And Luai playing 7 maybe Munster playing 6 Brimson at 1 and some fringe player at 9 it's not alot with all that Cash
 
Meanwhile
Caleb Navale to PNG 3 yrs
Is a there a hat bigger than a sombrero ?
I said this weeks ago , it will blow up in the NRL , yes the clubs signed off on it , but know they are getting , what is really going to happen for the next 10 years , this could destroy football as we know it
 
How about we drop this tired left side/right side crap and have roaming halves who work the whole field over?
Tucker, you know your footy well enough to know it will take years to make that change in pathways before it takes effect in NRL.

I would also suggest that NRL head coaches are probably more astute than we are at figuring out what will work to break down defensive lines.
 
The loan is a 100% about creating a roster spot and freeing up salary cap space. Nothing to do with Latu’s development , he has been offered as he is the player that is most likely to attract interest and plays in a position we can cover for a year.

Absolutely a stupid plan as it could go so terribly wrong and the thought of a Foggerty and AD as our 7 and 6 gives me nightmares

It pisses me off when wide awake, let alone worrying about nightmares.
 
Tucker, you know your footy well enough to know it will take years to make that change in pathways before it takes effect in NRL.

I would also suggest that NRL head coaches are probably more astute than we are at figuring out what will work to break down defensive lines.
We clearly can not do it using current tactics. Clearly not.
Benji’s superpower as a player was effortlessly ripping holes in defensive lines. It followed no structure, it was attacking outside of the box and other teams often weren’t prepared for it as it wasn’t what the rest were doing. If he wants to survive this season, he MUST get the team scoring multiple tries every week. Not following the herd will help.
 
We clearly can not do it using current tactics. Clearly not.
Benji’s superpower as a player was effortlessly ripping holes in defensive lines. It followed no structure, it was attacking outside of the box and other teams often weren’t prepared for it as it wasn’t what the rest were doing. If he wants to survive this season, he MUST get the team scoring multiple tries every week. Not following the herd will help.
Can't see that happening if Doueihi is in the halves, trying to do it himself running into dead ends.
 
We clearly can not do it using current tactics. Clearly not.
Benji’s superpower as a player was effortlessly ripping holes in defensive lines. It followed no structure, it was attacking outside of the box and other teams often weren’t prepared for it as it wasn’t what the rest were doing. If he wants to survive this season, he MUST get the team scoring multiple tries every week. Not following the herd will help.
Yep, the 2005 GF winning team were basically a bunch of enthusiastic young kids playing unstructured attacking footy. That combined with the way the game was reffed were the two principle reasons for the 2005 success.

The defence of some sides at the time were just not up to it. Can you imagine the scores our 2005 boys would have been running up against opposition teams if the 6 again rule was in place back then?
We have it now (6 agains) we just need the boys to be a bit more adventurous and unorthodox in attack, and a LOT more brutal in defence.
 
Respectfully mate. Of course they are. The NRL is Scripted . That team is going to get the rub of green like Broncos being reffed by harrigan.
Its probably part of the deal with the two governments "make them successful". They will be on ever add ever banner every poster. The talking heads are going to crow about them incessantly. Any one that has spent time in PNG knows there is an underlying promise of danger there. If that team struggles it wont be emails and news reports it will be riots and tribal wars.
It was the same in 1968 in Port Moresby. In the one year I spent there I was shot at twice and had a house brick thrown at me while on a motorbike. When I got my driver's licence I was told to just keep on driving if I happened to have an accident.
 

Latest posts

Members online

Back
Top