HBG, Independent Directors Sacked

Status
Not open for further replies.
Look other then Batboy and some others.

Do we really still 'fight' about this in forum land?

I really feel Denis and about 8 old men are fighting. .. That's about it.


Sure a few people are bating here. I think most members are really passed this so called Balmain vs Magpies thing.
I don’t support clowns, there’s plenty of both at Wests and Balmain.

I’ve been a stanch supporter of the betterment of Wests Tigers longer than you’ve been here.

Unfortunately, that means neither foundation club having anything to do with running the football club - as its performance over 26 seasons suggests..

And that’s certainly not my fault.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
After Cleary left, we went hard for Bennett, but he’d never come to a basket case like us, for that very reason.
Bennett agreed to terms - pretty sure even he said that. But we couldn’t wait the extra year for him.

That said, even if we did wait - we’d have found a way to make him change his mind
 
The NRL needs a better implementation authority in the SW. A WTs with new ownership under BOF and independent directors, plus our new CEO. With 54,000 new households and the new airport metropolis WTs has a strong case for funding assistance from State and Federal authorities as well as from the private sector. Goals -

Winning

Increased participation of girls and boys in SW

Maintain and improve traditional areas

Continue on the good work of WTs being profitable.

Increase pay and free to air viewing audience

New stadium for WTs (one ground) with facilities for other sports and entertainment in growth area. New stadium at Camden, Narellan, Oran Park or near airport with links to planned rail.

Seek additional funding for a more extensive junior development officer network, programmes and recruitment staff
Work to make the new stadium the heart of RL in Australia with GF played in SW.
 
The NRL needs a better implementation authority in the SW. A WTs with new ownership under BOF and independent directors, plus our new CEO. With 54,000 new households and the new airport metropolis WTs has a strong case for funding assistance from State and Federal authorities as well as from the private sector. Goals -

Winning

Increased participation of girls and boys in SW

Maintain and improve traditional areas

Continue on the good work of WTs being profitable.

Increase pay and free to air viewing audience

New stadium for WTs (one ground) with facilities for other sports and entertainment in growth area. New stadium at Camden, Narellan, Oran Park or near airport with links to planned rail.

Seek additional funding for a more extensive junior development officer network, programmes and recruitment staff
Work to make the new stadium the heart of RL in Australia with GF played in SW.
What’s wrong with my idea of a shared stadium ( with Dogs) in Liverpool ?
Just replicate CommBank there.
Perfect location. Cost efficient.
 
I'm trying to make the point that my criticism is directed at individuals, not Wests. I criticise the decisions, nothing else.

Cleary...great appointment? For a little while yes. He extracted 120% out of what he had, but we lost Moses and Tedesco under him. He left us with a huge amount of overpaid has-beens and dumped us in the middle of the contract citing board disunity. It took us a long time to clean up that cap mess...the board approved all those contracts.

Prior to that it was Jason Taylor.

Not saying Cleary can't coach, but it's undeniable that he destroyed our cap for many years.
Yep... Look I wont blame Cleary for the big 4. Heck his "big 17" put that Ego trip to rest.

But yes, 100% ruined the cap. I actually think Cleary has a poor skill in picking players. He can just coach really really well.
 
What’s wrong with my idea of a shared stadium ( with Dogs) in Liverpool ?
Just replicate CommBank there.
Perfect location. Cost efficient.
Liverpool is now the inner south west of Sydney and a stadium at Liverpool imo does nothing for our regions further south west. Our territory is extends to Camden, Narellan, Oran Park and the new airport metropolis. Many of our juniors come from those areas and we need to mark our territory. This will never happen if the boardroom is divided by loyalties to clubs which are long gone. The NRL needs to establish a new WTs free from the tiring HBG, Wests and Balmain dramas. $18m says it has the final decision and imo we are best served by encouraging PVL to act.
 
Look other then Batboy and some others.

Do we really still 'fight' about this in forum land?

I really feel Denis and about 8 old men are fighting. .. That's about it.


Sure a few people are bating here. I think most members are really passed this so called Balmain vs Magpies thing.
I agree with this but it only takes a few individuals to reignite the acrimony and dissension. As long as that level of dissension exists, the Wests Tigers will continue to flounder. It appears that some board members know this and are happy to encourage it for their own sad reasons.
There are a couple of posters on this forum that agree with that aim. It would not surprise me if they are very closely aligned with the board.
I agree with others that Vlandys, or someone capable of taking this further, needs to have an in depth look at Wests Tigers governance and intervene. The evidence is pretty clear, WT have gone from making gains with an independent board, to taking two steps back as a result of an ownership action that is yet to be explained.
To me it is clear, the current ownership either does not have the best interests of Wests Tigers as their guiding principle or are incompetent. It is as simple as that, and is what the NRL or other body needs to look at and change. Otherwise we will remain as also-rans and a feeder club for organisations that have competent and committed leadership.
 
HBG, as ultimate owners, are 100% entitled to replace the Board of Directors at any time that they want, for what ever reason that they want. Point of fact, they don't have to give a reason. They can just call an Extraordinary General Meeting and, viola, it is done.

That being said, in the real world of business, such events are usually only reserved for malfeasance by the Board being sacked. Sacking a Board on a whim just doesn't happen in the world of business.
So the question to be asked is: what malfeasance was conducted by the sacked Board?

By any reasonable measure, the sacked Board was doing a good job. On field results improved, membership up, profitability returned. All in twelve months.

In the real world of business, such Boards are not sacked, they are rewarded.

Compare that to the results of the previous HBG dominated Board over the last decade.

I just want a single logical reason as too why HBG have acted in the way that they have. Just one.

In the absence of such a logical reason, I can only question the motives of HBG in essentially throwing a hand grenade into season 2026.

It is said that the definition of madness is doing the same thing over and over, yet expecting a different outcome.

I had thought that HBG proved to us fans that they weren't mad when they appointed an independent review of our corporate governance, found it was wanting, and changed course by appointing an independent Board. Clearly that would appear to be an error of judgement on my part.

I think I might drop a lazy $100 at $8 on the Tigers to get the 2026 spoon. I expect the odds will shorten shortly.
Well, we are back to where we were, sans Richardson.

I hope the brand reputational damage was worth it HBG.
 
Well, we are back to where we were, sans Richardson.

I hope the brand reputational damage was worth it HBG.
It’s not even just the reputational damage either. We’re in a such worse position than we were prior to this whole saga.

HBG can now branch stack the Wests Tigers board and they’ve proven themselves completely incompetent at running an NRL club.

We’ve lost Viola and Richo, HBG made a knee jerk decision to extend Benji so we’re locked into a long term deal. The leak about Brad Arthur obviously upset some of the playing group and now fans are turning their back on memberships, maybe boycotting games and merch sales.

It’s a worse of position to be in financially and in terms of reputation than two weeks ago.
 
The NRL needs a better implementation authority in the SW. A WTs with new ownership under BOF and independent directors, plus our new CEO. With 54,000 new households and the new airport metropolis WTs has a strong case for funding assistance from State and Federal authorities as well as from the private sector. Goals -

Winning

Increased participation of girls and boys in SW

Maintain and improve traditional areas

Continue on the good work of WTs being profitable.

Increase pay and free to air viewing audience

New stadium for WTs (one ground) with facilities for other sports and entertainment in growth area. New stadium at Camden, Narellan, Oran Park or near airport with links to planned rail.

Seek additional funding for a more extensive junior development officer network, programmes and recruitment staff
Work to make the new stadium the heart of RL in Australia with GF played in SW.
Didn't even think of the new airport area - good call out. If they are planning significant residental, I'd say the panthers and dogs would both be sniffing around there too.
 
Didn't even think of the new airport area - good call out. If they are planning significant residental, I'd say the panthers and dogs would both be sniffing around there too.
The NRL has to take charge by recalling the license and establishing a WTs' club which best delivers RL, TV, Sponsorship and new stadium to that area. BOF with his connection to Govt, business and the community plus and a board of independents (free of any past allegiances) would be ideal. Let's hope PVL agrees.
 
The NRL needs a better implementation authority in the SW. A WTs with new ownership under BOF and independent directors, plus our new CEO. With 54,000 new households and the new airport metropolis WTs has a strong case for funding assistance from State and Federal authorities as well as from the private sector. Goals -

Winning

Increased participation of girls and boys in SW

Maintain and improve traditional areas

Continue on the good work of WTs being profitable.

Increase pay and free to air viewing audience

New stadium for WTs (one ground) with facilities for other sports and entertainment in growth area. New stadium at Camden, Narellan, Oran Park or near airport with links to planned rail.

Seek additional funding for a more extensive junior development officer network, programmes and recruitment staff
Work to make the new stadium the heart of RL in Australia with GF played in SW.
Respectfully mate that ain’t gonna happen, but I see where you’re coming from. PVL isn’t gonna take away the license anytime soon if he was he would’ve done it by now. With HBG locking in as majority on the board again the south west is probably gonna get ignored again. It was Richo pushing for the south west and a lot of the people on the HBG board from what I’ve heard hated the fact that they moved to Campbelltown to try and stay alive. The south west plan will be nowhere near as it was now that Richo is gone.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest posts

Back
Top