Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

Shoes · 2026-10-09T08:31:00+1100

mtd#2 said:
- Auckland Blues (Rugby) and NSW Blues (NRL)

- Richmond Tigers (AFL) and Wests Tigers (NRL)

These compete.
Why arent they relevant?

Mainly, because when they ( the above 2 examples) were established they were not in competing markets. The media revolution has made the market smaller hence now they are in competition for share!

Shoes · 2026-10-09T08:36:34+1100

mtd#2 said:
A quick google tells me that Trademark laws have been around since 1905. Balmain Tigers were founded in 1908.

If we look at something more recent, the Auckland Blues were founded in 1996 to launch the super rugby competition. They are competing in the same market as the NSW Blues.

They are throwing their toys out of the cot because their game is dying. They should be scared, not of the PNG Chiefs, but the NZ Warriors. If anything, their panic draws more people's attention to the NRL.

The problem there is that the ‘Canterbury Rugby Union ‘ commenced in the 1880s and has been known as the Blues for decades The Auckland Blues are a Franchise of the same organisation

hank37w · 2026-10-09T08:41:37+1100

pawsandclaws1 said:
Don't forget Paul Harragon, his nickname was the chief. When asked why other players call him that, he said that's what I want them to call me.

Unlike the "Chief" in Superman. 🤣

mtd#2 · 2026-10-09T08:57:56+1100

Shoes said:
Mainly, because when they ( the above 2 examples) were established they were not in competing markets. The media revolution has made the market smaller hence now they are in competition for share!

I personally dont think the Waikato Chiefs compete with the PNG chiefs at all. There is no super rugby competition in PNG. Chiefs fans in NZ arent going to just start following the PNG chiefs because of the name. And how many members do the Waikato chiefs have in Australia?

Sport is global. If they had a decent brand they wouldn't be having a sook.

pawsandclaws1 · 2026-10-09T09:10:47+1100

We build our team around families for the reason it is smart recruitment and being a less powerful club, we need to take every advantage offered. In addition a family culture within a club has had great success in the past with the Bulldogs.

cktiger · 2026-10-09T09:11:15+1100

Leck said:
No, you put forward your opinion and then told me that the Mortimers and the Hughes family are somehow comparable. That proves you have no idea what you’re talking about.

Oh, really?
Let's re-wind.
Here's your original post....

Leck said:
I don't understand why any club would want to build a team around two families. It makes absolutely no sense.

We have three Fainus (possibly four if Manase gets signed) and maybe three Mays in the squad.

If they don't get their way, they'll hold the club to ransom. If they leave, we'll be absolutely screwed.

This is the stupidest recruitment strategy and logic I've ever seen from this club.

Here's my original answer.....
"Never heard of the Mortimer and Hughes brothers at Canterbury?
Seemed to work pretty good."
Where did I make a comparison on skill sets?
You specifically asked why any club would bother to base their team on a pair of brothers and I gave you Canterbury, and the Mortimer and Hughes brothers, as a factual (not opinion based) answer as a team that did.
So ... looks like you're the one here who has no idea what they're talking about. 🙄🤣
PS You seem to have a habit of putting people down or making derogatory statements regarding their knowledge when answering posts of late.
I'm unsure if this is based on a fragile ego, insecurity or low self-esteem... but it is unnecessary.

JB9918 · 2026-10-09T09:20:21+1100

Just signed another junior. Ashton Whyte. Redcliffe Dolphins junior.

Unsure what position

Demps · 2026-10-09T09:22:55+1100

JB9918 said:
Just signed another junior. Ashton Whyte. Redcliffe Dolphins junior.

Unsure what position

#13

Leck · 2026-10-09T09:41:55+1100

cktiger said:
Oh, really?
Let's re-wind.
Here's your original post....

Here's my original answer.....
"Never heard of the Mortimer and Hughes brothers at Canterbury?
Seemed to work pretty good."
Where did I make a comparison on skill sets?
You specifically asked why any club would bother to base their team on a pair of brothers and I gave you Canterbury, and the Mortimer and Hughes brothers, as a factual (not opinion based) answer as a team that did.
So ... looks like you're the one here who has no idea what they're talking about. 🙄🤣
PS You seem to have a habit of putting people down or making derogatory statements regarding their knowledge when answering posts of late.
I'm unsure if this is based on a fragile ego, insecurity or low self-esteem... but it is unnecessary.

I replied that they don't.

derekderekson · 2026-10-09T09:48:40+1100

JB9918 said:
Just signed another junior. Ashton Whyte. Redcliffe Dolphins junior.

Unsure what position

Demps said:
#13

Courier Mail article -Walters Cup schoolboy Team of the Season

UNSUNG HERO AWARD

Ashton Whyte (Redcliffe SHS)

Whyte made the Sunshine Coast representative side but was injured at the state titles which robbed him of some matches.

But when he played for Redcliffe, it was time to make up for lost time. He was able to cover lock and hooker where he was as tough as an old boot.

Whtye had a high ethic.

pawsandclaws1 · 2026-10-09T09:56:16+1100

derekderekson said:
Courier Mail article -Walters Cup schoolboy Team of the Season
UNSUNG HERO AWARD
Ashton Whyte (Redcliffe SHS)
Whyte made the Sunshine Coast representative side but was injured at the state titles which robbed him of some matches.

But when he played for Redcliffe, it was time to make up for lost time. He was able to cover lock and hooker where he was as tough as an old boot.

Whtye had a high ethic.

Good pick up for WTs.

king_sirro · 2026-10-09T10:30:18+1100

Leck said:
They will upgrade the facility, just like Leichhardt is being upgraded now, and then Campbelltown after that.

Direct your question to Brookswest not me. He / she brought this up.

Chill man. Saw your post saying they "have to play at Lidcombe" and just wanted to know why, you said it.
Your answer doesnt tell me why they have to. Either one of Campbelltown or Leichhardt will be available at any given time. They could also work with the NRL to get them playing before the NRL team as much as possible, and they could also try and tie in with Wests Harbour and play out of the Centre of Excellence. I dont see how the have to play out of Lidcombe other than some old fossils hanging on to past glory.

Leck · 2026-10-09T10:45:19+1100

king_sirro said:
Chill man. Saw your post saying they "have to play at Lidcombe" and just wanted to know why, you said it.
Your answer doesnt tell me why they have to. Either one of Campbelltown or Leichhardt will be available at any given time. They could also work with the NRL to get them playing before the NRL team as much as possible, and they could also try and tie in with Wests Harbour and play out of the Centre of Excellence. I dont see how the have to play out of Lidcombe other than some old fossils hanging on to past glory.

What's your point?

TigerBurnsy · 2026-10-09T10:54:17+1100

pawsandclaws1 said:
He sounds like he possesses the qualities we need at WTs, especially his never defeated attitude and toughness. Congratulations to him and his family. Let's hope it is the first of many junior QLD signings for WTs.

View this content on Instagram

View this content on Instagram

Great to see the club stockpiling good talent to go along side the juniors we have

cktiger · 2026-10-09T10:56:03+1100

Leck said:
I replied that they don't.

Selective memory… or memory loss?

JB9918 · 2026-10-09T10:59:56+1100

pawsandclaws1 said:
He sounds like he possesses the qualities we need at WTs, especially his never defeated attitude and toughness. Congratulations to him and his family. Let's hope it is the first of many junior QLD signings for WTs.

View this content on Instagram

View this content on Instagram

Better watch out they are coming to get you for breaching copyright 🧐🤪

king_sirro · 2026-10-09T11:50:45+1100

Leck said:
What's your point?

Does anyone know what this guys problem is with everyone?

orange&black · 2026-10-09T11:53:49+1100

A few of us recently tossing around Schiller as an option for outside back depth - seems like recruitment had the same idea!
Interesting to see $ and term for him if the scuttlebut is true.

pawsandclaws1 · 2026-10-09T11:55:53+1100

king_sirro said:
Does anyone know what this guys problem is with everyone?

I don't think it is personal and I wouldn't let it impact how you feel about him or yourself. You are a good poster on the forum. I certainly enjoy reading your posts and respect your knowledge. I hope this provides some clarity.

king_sirro · 2026-10-09T12:05:20+1100

pawsandclaws1 said:
I don't think it is personal and I wouldn't let it impact how you feel about him or yourself. You are a good poster on the forum. I certainly enjoy reading your posts and respect your knowledge. I hope this provides some clarity.

Mate I appreciate those kind words and right back at ya. Im not personally bothered by him all that much. Ive just noticed recently he is overreacting to a number of posters on the forum. We all have a moments, but his seems widespread at the moment.

Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

Active member

Active member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Moderator

Well-known member

Well-known member

Courier Mail article -Walters Cup schoolboy Team of the Season​

UNSUNG HERO AWARD​

Ashton Whyte (Redcliffe SHS)​

Well-known member

Courier Mail article -Walters Cup schoolboy Team of the Season​

UNSUNG HERO AWARD​

Ashton Whyte (Redcliffe SHS)​

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Well-known member

Courier Mail article -Walters Cup schoolboy Team of the Season

UNSUNG HERO AWARD

Ashton Whyte (Redcliffe SHS)

Courier Mail article -Walters Cup schoolboy Team of the Season

UNSUNG HERO AWARD

Ashton Whyte (Redcliffe SHS)