Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

But he knows he isn't actually behind any of them. He also isn't the one that was surplus. Both Brooks and Fogarty have been shopped as well as half their pack.
What does that actually mean? What ? If you’re told you’re behind them ….. you’re behind them . Like they would have to be shitting the bed so hard just for you to get a look in . Like Hastings at the end here , and at Newcastle. . You’re just creating a narrative to suit your agenda .
Also i can’t see it being AD - Fogarty . AD in halves equals 13th/12th. How do we know ? We have years of proof . I genuinely think the keys are in Latus hands . And it’s up to him now. Now or never .
 
Fogarty is the type of signing that fans will applaud now but will blow up at the club about mid July next year when he's not performing and one of our young halves requests to leave due to lack of opportunities.

Happens all the time with our fans and club.
This is the hard part that comes with signing older players who are temporarily blocking the paths of promising younger players.
In our current position, it’s damned if we do, damned if we don’t.
If we go into the 2027 season season with the halves currently on our books and they do not perform up to expectation, how many people will say I told you so?
Ideally we could sign Fogarty on a subsidised contract of hopefully around 500k to us, but realistically we will probably have to pay closer to 600k to secure him for 2 seasons at age 33 and 34.
If it happens, surely the deal is that he would have to be performing somewhere near his best on a regular basis and if he’s not, be prepared to play NSW Cup, or if his form dips dramatically during g the 2027 seasons, hopefully be prepared to head to the UK Super League for 2028 and beyond.
On the other hand, if he’s doing for us what he did in his final year at the Raiders, it’s a success.
 
Last edited:
It just makes no sense to let a 26 year old Madden go who is on no money to sign a 34 year old on good money that does the same job. Both are poor defenders, both have no running game, both organise well and both kick well. Madden steps up with the game on the line while Fogarty crumbles with the game on the line. When you take into account future improvement and salary cap management, you take Madden over Fogarty every time.

Im ok if Fogarty comes so we can have like for like at 6 and 7 in NRL and reserve grade, but to replace Madden with a player costing us 500k more who is on the decline and offers no more than what Madden does is crazy
Your kidding Fogarty is a 8 , madden on his best day is a 4
 
Brooks sticking point was his injury recovery and also the deal he wants for 2028 as he does not have one.

Fogarty on the other hand is signed for 26 27 and 28 so tigers know what they are getting for 2028 price wise
Yes Manlys issue in unloading Brooks is his injury, so obviously no-one would consider him for next season given he may miss a fair chunk of it. Yet alone to then offer an aging half that relies on speed coming back from injury another year. No club is going to take that risk, so Manly have had to offer up other players.
I understand Tigers interest in Fogarty...If you can get him for 2 years subsidized by Manly. I however don't understand why Fogarty would just agree to leave. As I said above he is still Manlys first choice 7 (arguably he won't be in 28, or his form might drop whilst Walsh improves during 27 but who knows). So there is no playing incentive for him to leave. Tigers traditionally a worse performing club, so no success incentive. Were not offering an extra year (I hope not at least) so no career incentive. The only thing we could potentially offer is money. Let's say he is on 700k. Manly will need to subsidize some but where does that become too much for them, at best maybe 200-250K. So we start at 450k plus whatever we need to add on top to get him here, maybe 100k.
Do we have 550 to offer Fogarty this year and next?
 
What does that actually mean? What ? If you’re told you’re behind them ….. you’re behind them . Like they would have to be shitting the bed so hard just for you to get a look in . Like Hastings at the end here , and at Newcastle. . You’re just creating a narrative to suit your agenda .
Also i can’t see it being AD - Fogarty . AD in halves equals 13th/12th. How do we know ? We have years of proof . I genuinely think the keys are in Latus hands . And it’s up to him now. Now or never .
He hasn't been told he is behind them. Manly has prioritised keeping them long term as they are young and they want them in the future. For next year Fogarty is still their 7.
 
Yes Manlys issue in unloading Brooks is his injury, so obviously no-one would consider him for next season given he may miss a fair chunk of it. Yet alone to then offer an aging half that relies on speed coming back from injury another year. No club is going to take that risk, so Manly have had to offer up other players.
I understand Tigers interest in Fogarty...If you can get him for 2 years subsidized by Manly. I however don't understand why Fogarty would just agree to leave. As I said above he is still Manlys first choice 7 (arguably he won't be in 28, or his form might drop whilst Walsh improves during 27 but who knows). So there is no playing incentive for him to leave. Tigers traditionally a worse performing club, so no success incentive. Were not offering an extra year (I hope not at least) so no career incentive. The only thing we could potentially offer is money. Let's say he is on 700k. Manly will need to subsidize some but where does that become too much for them, at best maybe 200-250K. So we start at 450k plus whatever we need to add on top to get him here, maybe 100k.
Do we have 550 to offer Fogarty this year and next?
good point he still has a contract so he has got to want to move in the first place. From fogarty point of view he would still likely be the 7 at manly for 2027 regardless of what happens either way.
 
Fogarty is the type of signing that fans will applaud now but will blow up at the club about mid July next year when he's not performing and one of our young halves requests to leave due to lack of opportunities.

Happens all the time with our fans and club.
On the flip side, fans will be upset we went into the season undermanned in the halves when Latu goes down and we are trotting Doueihi out at halfback by round 3.
 
Prime JAC was the best pure winger I've seen in the speedster sense. At 31, he is definitely past his silkiest best, but he is still super fast off the mark and an excellent finisher. We need a winger, so this is an easy Yes.

Fogarty is an interesting one. He is a proper in-game kicker, cool under pressure and could steer a team effectively, exerting leadership from the middle. If he were to rediscover +80% goal-kicking form that would be particularly valuable. He is clearly better than our current best halfback options, but he will be 33 next month, so there's that.

On that note, I am all for a healthy mix of experience and youthful exuberance, but I note (a) we didn't exactly have a team of rookies to begin with and (b) have already signed a bunch of 30-something's for bench spots and depth. They might help us grind out wins, but the direction with recruitment this off-season has become a bit confusing to me, not to mention slightly triggering of former days.
How old was DCE this year?
 
Top 8 lol…

Saints, parramatta, storm, Brisbane all have better rosters than us and didn’t make the finals …

Unfortunately for us to make the 8 next year even if those two guys come

We need bula and Latu to be like unbelievable

Rn bula is average and Latu is not consistent

If those two have break out years which I can’t see bula havjg bc I think he’s shown us his level already … than we could make the 8

But I doubt it

We need origin and rep players and marquee players in the spine and we don’t have them

Apart from API all other spine players are out of the top 8 - that’s just fact
Go away

The only time we have to be optimistic each year is pre season before a game is played

Let us live with some delusion
 
good point he still has a contract so he has got to want to move in the first place. From fogarty point of view he would still likely be the 7 at manly for 2027 regardless of what happens either way.
99% of players leave if told they are free to. Why stay at a club who doesn’t want you and views you as expendable.
 
We're all crossing our fingers that this is the case. I'm sure every Tigers supporter wants to make the eight next year. But it's not a long term solution, and it could potentially block our juniors and potentially force some to leave.
Which juniors are ready to step up now and play a full season, I'll tell you none.

Maybe Latu his age is approaching it, but would you put money on him getting through a full season playing 80 minutes in the halves with his injury history, yeah right.
 

Latest posts

Members online

Back
Top