2019 Coaching saga -Thread

@ said:
@ said:
@ said:
@ said:
Me neither! The hate word gets bandied around a lot by bitter souls. I’d be happy if Ivan saw out his contract with us then moved onto Penrith in 2021\. I’m sure he’s professional enough to do the job that’s in front of him. Equally as happy to have Bennett as a replacement coach if Cleary wants to move on now.

There’s way worse things going on in the world to be pissed off about than coaches or players wanting to change NRL teams.

Let it go Flip. You’ve chased me around for 12 months chastising me for my opinion on this. I didn’t bring them up to have another rant about them, I was using them as an example as to why I can understand the bitterness towards Cleary. I don’t feel the same, but I know sometimes supporters are irrational. That’s what passion drives you to sometimes.

Firstly it’s you that needs to let it go! You’re the one who keeps bringing them up every chance you get - much like that fellow that somehow used to bring Robbie Farah into just about every comment he made.

Secondly what the hell is Flip? Are you swearing at me nicely? Using the alternative word for the swear word beginning with F?

Thirdly yes passion does make people irrational at times. Like I said there are far more important things in life to get mad over.

Ha - i get the feeling that some on here think you have changed your user name Spud. It came up.a while ago and I assumed they knew something I didnt
Flippedy" clocked off a while ago - hence the Flip reference.
Click to expand...
Click to expand...
Click to expand...
Click to expand...

Oh really? No, this is my first foray into the forum.
 
@ said:
@ said:
@ said:
@ said:
Let it go Flip. You’ve chased me around for 12 months chastising me for my opinion on this. I didn’t bring them up to have another rant about them, I was using them as an example as to why I can understand the bitterness towards Cleary. I don’t feel the same, but I know sometimes supporters are irrational. That’s what passion drives you to sometimes.

Firstly it’s you that needs to let it go! You’re the one who keeps bringing them up every chance you get - much like that fellow that somehow used to bring Robbie Farah into just about every comment he made.

**Secondly what the hell is Flip? Are you swearing at me nicely? Using the alternative word for the swear word beginning with F?**

Thirdly yes passion does make people irrational at times. Like I said there are far more important things in life to get mad over.

No, I’m calling you by your old username. Anyway, I’m sorry that my opinions get under your skin. As you said, there’s a lot more important things in life than to get worked up over silly old me.

You both need to give it a rest.
Click to expand...
Click to expand...
Click to expand...
Click to expand...

Okey doke ?
 
@ said:
@ said:
@ said:
@ said:
Shame…

Yes I think Bennett would have been a better choice.
Hope Maguire does the job required. Not an upgrade ….. only in my opinion.
Very happy about Brooks however.
At least it will be settled now.

Yep with you on all counts there. Gotta give Madge a chance I suppose, but it sucks to miss out on a coach like Bennett- so close, yet so far.

Not an upgrade? Maguire has won two premierships and has around a 58-60% winning record. Way better than Clearly. Definite upgrade. Prob get him for 600k compared to Bennett's 1 mill a season. Yes Bennett would be better but not by much.
Click to expand...
Click to expand...
Click to expand...
Click to expand...

Oh he’s probably an upgrade from Cleary, but nowhere near Bennett imo. Just would’ve preferred a big name coach if the cards fell our way.
 
@ said:
@ said:
@ said:
@ said:
Yes I think Bennett would have been a better choice.
Hope Maguire does the job required. Not an upgrade ….. only in my opinion.
Very happy about Brooks however.
At least it will be settled now.

Yep with you on all counts there. Gotta give Madge a chance I suppose, but it sucks to miss out on a coach like Bennett- so close, yet so far.

Not an upgrade? Maguire has won two premierships and has around a 58-60% winning record. Way better than Clearly. Definite upgrade. Prob get him for 600k compared to Bennett's 1 mill a season. Yes Bennett would be better but not by much.

Oh he’s probably an upgrade from Cleary, but nowhere near Bennett imo. Just would’ve preferred a big name coach if the cards fell our way.
Click to expand...
Click to expand...
Click to expand...
Click to expand...

Downgrade from Cleary and not in the same league as Bennett.
 
Did Madge coach the Kiwis to do the Scorpion ?

https://www.foxsports.com.au/video/league/tests/yes-this-ended-in-a-try!702817?fbclid=IwAR3BjmuR6oAj5hkPp1SzdLzi5I-WJ-Ya33JJBJUrlJ8xiJoVI42pZ2htuNA

If so. I want him.
P.S I don’t think you can determine Madge’s catch cry until we hear a statement from him on the Tigers. Then again, the bus broke down pretty quickly..maybe don’t go there.
 
@ said:
@ said:
@ said:
@ said:
Yep with you on all counts there. Gotta give Madge a chance I suppose, but it sucks to miss out on a coach like Bennett- so close, yet so far.

Not an upgrade? Maguire has won two premierships and has around a 58-60% winning record. Way better than Clearly. Definite upgrade. Prob get him for 600k compared to Bennett's 1 mill a season. Yes Bennett would be better but not by much.

Oh he’s probably an upgrade from Cleary, but nowhere near Bennett imo. Just would’ve preferred a big name coach if the cards fell our way.

Downgrade from Cleary and not in the same league as Bennett.
Click to expand...
Click to expand...
Click to expand...
Click to expand...

Totally agree Paws.

Someone said Madge's Flyers - no more than a glider imo.
 
@ said:
@ said:
@ said:
@ said:
Yep with you on all counts there. Gotta give Madge a chance I suppose, but it sucks to miss out on a coach like Bennett- so close, yet so far.

Not an upgrade? Maguire has won two premierships and has around a 58-60% winning record. Way better than Clearly. Definite upgrade. Prob get him for 600k compared to Bennett's 1 mill a season. Yes Bennett would be better but not by much.

Oh he’s probably an upgrade from Cleary, but nowhere near Bennett imo. Just would’ve preferred a big name coach if the cards fell our way.

Downgrade from Cleary and not in the same league as Bennett.
Click to expand...
Click to expand...
Click to expand...
Click to expand...

Agree on one thing, Bennett would have been my first choice. But I'm interested why you think he's a downgrade on Cleary? Maguire has a much better win record and a premiership.
 
@ said:
@ said:
@ said:
@ said:
Not an upgrade? Maguire has won two premierships and has around a 58-60% winning record. Way better than Clearly. Definite upgrade. Prob get him for 600k compared to Bennett's 1 mill a season. Yes Bennett would be better but not by much.

Oh he’s probably an upgrade from Cleary, but nowhere near Bennett imo. Just would’ve preferred a big name coach if the cards fell our way.

Downgrade from Cleary and not in the same league as Bennett.

Totally agree Paws.

Someone said Madge's Flyers - no more than a glider imo.
Click to expand...
Click to expand...
Click to expand...
Click to expand...

Agree with seantice Maguire won a premiership peeps not too long ago. Get a grip
 
Magic Madge
He can come over with Big Marty and the number 9 from Kiwi Side as well as the rooster young guy who played well for Kiwi team
 
Cleary winning record

Won - 140\. Loss 150

Madge
\
\
Win - 139\. Loss 83.

Yeah I can see how Madge isn't an upgrade on Cleary…. :unamused:
 
Someone mentioned it earlier, Seibold and Bennett switching roles. I think that’s pretty close to the money if we sign Maguire. Bennett will not end up jobless if he doesn’t want to be. Based off Pom’s mail, I’d say in 2019

Cleary - Penrith
Bennett - Souths
Seibold - Broncos
Hasler - Manly

Something has to give very soon.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Staff online

Members online

Total: 394 (members: 27, guests: 367)
Back
Top