Tiger-ferret
Well-known member
I’ve always liked how he goes but seems to always follow 10-15mins of great play with something dumb lol
3, 2, 1 Vs Warriors
- Thread starter Demps
- Start date
BAGNF05
Well-known member
I find his default is plod mode but he sometimes has a bit more of a dig. I don’t think he’s been the origin forward we were buying.
And he's not that - no one is denying that.
But that, like everything else, ain't his fault.
Brooks can't be any first grade teams main guy.
And neither can forum favourite Madden.
Goldust
Well-known member
3. To’a
2. Seyfarth
1. Garner
Hm.Joffa,Gildart
2. Seyfarth
1. Garner
Hm.Joffa,Gildart
BrissieTiger67
Well-known member
Yep I like your 321 but HM for gildart?
He held on to the ball half a dozen times when there was a good pass on during a break and then in the last play instead of taking the 2nd tackle , he flicks he forward?
He's way to slow for a winger/centre.
He held on to the ball half a dozen times when there was a good pass on during a break and then in the last play instead of taking the 2nd tackle , he flicks he forward?
He's way to slow for a winger/centre.
cqtiger
Well-known member
My goodness, if you don’t pick Brooks in your top 3 you are a Brooks hater?
Tiger_Fanatic3
Well-known member
3. Madden
2. Seyferth
1. To'a
Garner defended solid at centre, To'a was good under the high balls
2. Seyferth
1. To'a
Garner defended solid at centre, To'a was good under the high balls
Chicken_Faced_Killa
Well-known member
It’s going both ways, you were saying during the week that everyone will turn on Madden by half time when they realise he is rubbish.
Madden has played 4 games in first grade including at least 1 from the bench. Let’s not destroy him with expectations because we want Brooks gone or Brooks to stay and we need him to fit our agenda.
Both sides of this discussion need to tone it down a bit.
Tim Sheens
Well-known member
Might have been.
BAGNF05
Well-known member
It was a silly pass that Gildart wasn’t ready for. That’s where you need big outside backs getting yardage to set up for a last ditch shift later in the set. But alas we have our maligned seven taking hit ups. No wonder he wants out.
Mighty_Tiger
Well-known member
Watched the game a 2nd time, ratings below:
3 - Joe best player on the park playing with 1 arm. After his injury he just got on and hit harder and ran harder. If all our forwards played like him we would be a different pack.
2 - Tamou he cops it here but he actually was a leader on and off the park barking orders and running hard and hitting hard. The difference in Stefano play was noticeable as well. When Tamou was on we were easily the better team, he came off and Warriors made meters easily.
3 - Gildart/Toa. Pairing them as couldn’t split them.
Brooks I would have put in top 3 if he actually took control of the team in the last 10mins we didn’t and it was very costly. At the time was like now show everyone what you’re made of and his ball handling dried up. We needed someone to direct and control the team with inexperienced 1/6/9 + backs and forwards with 10mins on the goal line and a man advantage with a clearly tired Warriors team and he failed badly.
Laurie and Nofa have to be close to reserve grade if we actually had depth. They both are making very costly errors.
3 - Joe best player on the park playing with 1 arm. After his injury he just got on and hit harder and ran harder. If all our forwards played like him we would be a different pack.
2 - Tamou he cops it here but he actually was a leader on and off the park barking orders and running hard and hitting hard. The difference in Stefano play was noticeable as well. When Tamou was on we were easily the better team, he came off and Warriors made meters easily.
3 - Gildart/Toa. Pairing them as couldn’t split them.
Brooks I would have put in top 3 if he actually took control of the team in the last 10mins we didn’t and it was very costly. At the time was like now show everyone what you’re made of and his ball handling dried up. We needed someone to direct and control the team with inexperienced 1/6/9 + backs and forwards with 10mins on the goal line and a man advantage with a clearly tired Warriors team and he failed badly.
Laurie and Nofa have to be close to reserve grade if we actually had depth. They both are making very costly errors.
TieDye
Well-known member
And had a dropsy deep on attack in second half. Maybe from marker but he lacks judgement, and hopefully will adjust quicker now for those simple mistakes. Needed one of Laurie or Simpkin to back him up with breaks as Brooks always does!
Goldust
Well-known member
Yeah good point.
He was definitely chasing that first NRL try haha.
That last flick pass was beyond stupid.
tig_prmz
Well-known member
I was impressed with Madden, I think he's more switched on than Brooks when running at the line.
But those saying Madden played better than Brooks are delusional.
Madden may be a better player than Brooks when he plays 150 games but right now he isn't.
But those saying Madden played better than Brooks are delusional.
Madden may be a better player than Brooks when he plays 150 games but right now he isn't.
isaaktigers
Well-known member
Ass
Boobs
Face
Boobs
Face
earl
Well-known member
There was plenty to like about Madden. It was a really good effort.
Your girlfriend's best feature her ass? Good to know
twentyforty
Well-known member
3. JO
2. Brooks
1. Luci
2. Brooks
1. Luci
TieDye
Well-known member
She got them small boobies.
C
Cobarcats
Guest
After watching it again and taking the emotion away from my 3-2-1,
I thought Gildart produced some brilliant running and elusiveness, made at least 3 tackle busts and would have got my vote but a couple of ill timed passes and brain explosions pushed him back but if he keeps up his competitive style he'll be a good fit with more NRL experience.
I thought right from the outset James Tamou led like a real captain, hit hard in D and got a meat pie and Musgrove is also finding some form, a bad handling error came at a crucial time.
Seyfarth is showing some mongrel, the 'Big Red' might be a surprise packet as he gets even bigger and stronger.
Madden showed some class considering lack if game time.
3. Capt JT
2. Seyfarth
1. Gildart
NM. Got to say my man To'a has got to stay and at several stages we had 4 ball players on the park and no indians, thats where we lost the game.
1. Bad Handling and
2. No big boppers to finish them off.
I'm unhappy with the loss but happy we starting to put in an effort.
I thought Gildart produced some brilliant running and elusiveness, made at least 3 tackle busts and would have got my vote but a couple of ill timed passes and brain explosions pushed him back but if he keeps up his competitive style he'll be a good fit with more NRL experience.
I thought right from the outset James Tamou led like a real captain, hit hard in D and got a meat pie and Musgrove is also finding some form, a bad handling error came at a crucial time.
Seyfarth is showing some mongrel, the 'Big Red' might be a surprise packet as he gets even bigger and stronger.
Madden showed some class considering lack if game time.
3. Capt JT
2. Seyfarth
1. Gildart
NM. Got to say my man To'a has got to stay and at several stages we had 4 ball players on the park and no indians, thats where we lost the game.
1. Bad Handling and
2. No big boppers to finish them off.
I'm unhappy with the loss but happy we starting to put in an effort.
Staff online
-
DempsModerator