-3, -2, -1

[Born_tiger]

-3 Mitchell Moses
-2 Kevin Naiqama
-1 Chris Lawrence

Thought Moses' attack was awful, sliding defence similar.
Naiqama's compressed was horrid.

 

[Love_the_WestsTigers]

No one today is worthy of any points

The team collectively should get -3

Thats my summary of their performance or lack of it

 

[Tacky]

-3 Kev(it's been 2 years he still can't make defensive reads)
-2 Moses (I forgot he was playing)
-1 Grant (He's rushing out and creating holes in the defensive line around the ruck)

 

[Guest]

Worst on field was a hard one…Nofo got caught out all day in defence but then was the only bloke to really trouble Saints defensively and made a ton of metres...

Moses was terrible but Littlejohn probably takes the cake today. Defensively shocking and offered nothing with the ball.

 

[ILTIGRE]

I couldnt watch the whole game but from what i saw i thought big ava and aloiai dug in and had a go

 

[Byron_Bay_Fan]

3\. Tedesco - he was in the play so many times, never stopped trying.
2\. Idris - a lot more active this week
1\. Moses - only one kick came off but was always having a go

 

[tigers05]

3 points to all that turned up to watch that rubbish
2 points to all those at home who watched the whole match
1 point to the cameramen who didn't nod off filming the garbage

 

[everett8]

I also though Ava and Aloiai tried hard today

Only half the team is NRL standard

Teddy should move to a stronger club.

 

[sideline_eye]

Tedesco made a lot of metres but he will never make a clean break while he applies the brakes before the line. What has happened to him? He can't just wait until his team mates create a hole because they aren't capable of doing so. If he wants line breaks he has to hit the line at speed; I just wonder whether the injuries he suffered as a result of Ryan James' high tackle have made him a bit gun shy.

Anyway, 3,2,1.

3\. Woods
2\. Aloiai.
1.Taylor.

 

[jadtiger]

3 Josh
2 Aaron
1 Ava
Nofo was good in attack Suli is developing nicely.
Lots of deadwood out there again

 

[Born_tiger]

Minus fellas.

Would be interested to hear what everyone thought was our downfall

 

[Pawsandclaws]

I thought Woods ran the ball harder today and was looking to unload at every opportunity. 3 points
Josa A looked likely to break the line every time he ran the ball. A player on the rise. 2 points
Suli ran the ball hard today and always seems to make the tackles. Needs to move to centre 1 point

 

[sheer64]

3\. Aloiai
2\. Ava
1\. Teddy

 

[Geo]

3\. Seumanufagai
2\. Aloiai
1\. McIlwrick

Honourable Mentions Chee Kam Woods Nofoaluma Taylor Suli ..

Naughty Cnr ..the pies were cold..

 

[sideline_eye]

Minus fellas.

Would be interested to hear what everyone thought was our downfall

Oh, OK.
Apart from Woods, Aloiai, Taylor and McIlwrick, they all sucked.

 

[happy_tiger]

Taylor
Suli
Too hard

 

[goldcoast_tiger]

-3\. Moses
-2 Idris a waste of a jumper
- 1LittleJohn
And special non award to Nofa terrible in defence, but saving a little bit in attack
Just missed out on a negative 2

 

[Sabre]

3\. Teddy
2\. Idris
1\. Ava

-3\. Naiqama
-2\. Moses
-1\. Littlejohn

 

[WestsBenTigers]

3\. ET
2\. Aloiai
1\. Teddy

-3\. Kev
-2\. Ballin
-1\. Moses

 

[Mighty_Tiger]

Worst on field was a hard one…Nofo got caught out all day in defence but then was the only bloke to really trouble Saints defensively and made a ton of metres...

Moses was terrible but Littlejohn probably takes the cake today. Defensively shocking and offered nothing with the ball.

Nofo wasn't the problem Willow.

Kev on 3 of the tried was standing within 5-10mtrs of the goal posts leaving Nofo marking 4 players over 40mtrs to himself.

Kev was terrible today yet again he either compresses, starts from the side or rushes. He has no defensive capability to sturcture at all.

Cleary needs to make his role #1 priority to resolve or replace.
\
\
-3 Kev
-2 Teddy just a selfish player atm
-1 Moses hardly seen at all considering we had over 50 tackles in our opposition 20….