crazycat
Well-known member
@Demps said in [321 Panthers Trial](/post/1120613) said:@crazycat said in [321 Panthers Trial](/post/1120584) said:@SeanT said in [321 Panthers Trial](/post/1120463) said:@voice_of_reason said in [321 Panthers Trial](/post/1120391) said:@mike said in [321 Panthers Trial](/post/1120340) said:3-Johns
2-Walters
1-Musgrove
I agree, plus hon. mention to 'dewey'. I'm satisfied enough that the players I wanted to go well did in fact go well.
Naughty corner for JR for not working on his passing game - will likely cost him a first grade spot.
In his defence JR hasn't passed left to right his whole career. Yet Ivan still overpaid him 200%. My god incompetence all around.
I even like Josh Reynolds and... That is 100% true.
His passing game is pretty average at best. He often can line up with the person outside him, but he isn't a person who would ever move the ball left to right. Which is why I pegged him in at Center, clearly we are overloaded there.
Yet Mbye passes everything. As a halves partnership, Reynolds + Mbye was one of the worst in the league. Yet some people here wanted us to recruit Michael Lichaa into this mix!? Yes I totally bagged out Mbye often, in fairness he as performed better then I expected. Yet playing Mbye as center and Reynolds at 5/8 doesn't make sense except each one has played together often.
Brooks too is a running halfback who plays a very Mitchell Pearce style game.
All of the above leaves us a little headless.
Yeah what a ludicrous idea...
Recruit a hooker... when we need a hooker.
What a bunch of imbeciles......
Michael Lichaa? Really?
Particularly with Reynolds and Mbye in the team. Cmon.
Maybe Michael under another coach/situation can get his game back. Maybe Des Haslier ruined him, but Des leaves the Bulldogs and Manly are playing way better with him then Barrett.
We should Never Ever replicate another teams failing combination. Reynolds + Mbye is bad. Don't add Lichaa to that mix.