A hypothetical ...

[stryker]

Seriously, why bother having a poll when you're a closed book on the matter?? Even with the no option you can't resist having a crack.

Agreed. There is no use having a poll if the data your trying to collect will be as biased as this.

End result?…this survey means diddly squat!

 

[Montague_Street]

Suppporters deathriding their own club. Class.
No doubt one of the few who had a hissy fit when Sheens called them 'so-called' supporters.

Why is he listening, reading what fans supporters say?
Ive followed this team in its forms since '70, granted the net has changed a lot of things in the last 10 years or so….but in that time Ive never heard ANY coach bag those that follow his boys.....that was absolutely pathetic and shows he is not as professional as some think

Start listening to the fans and next thing you'll be sitting with them.

On topic, a spoon wont force Sheens to leave….he has too much control here, he is an elder statesman in the game and as such is afforded some leeway rightly or wrongly, he goes on his terms - which is precisely the problem here

Context please!
Sheens blew up at "so-called supporters" bagging Fitzhenry. He didn't have to read that on this or that Forum. So-called Wests Tigers fans loudly booed Fitzhenry when his appearance was announced at the beginning of games at Leichhardt Oval. Sheens would have heard that disgusting boo on game day from the coach's box.
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_

 

[innsaneink]

Sorry Monty, he wasnt defending Fitzy, he conveniently, thanks to his ego, ignored the fact that people were criticising him…..not Fitzy, that was the main theme here, cant speak though for those at that game.

So those that were critical of the coach over fitzy, morris etc etc could hardly be blamed for thinking its them he's referring to.

 

[Montague_Street]

Would you cop a spoon if it meant the removal of the coach/dictator/despot/supercoach/man who won 3 comps with half a NSW side, half a Qld side and a few NZ reps whilst over the cap ?

Put me in the yes camp

I cannot wait for him to pack his clipboard up and get back to Magnetic Island. The only one probably not in the same boat is Mrs supercoach who probably lives in peace up there.

so Pistol Pete joins the Forum on April Fools Day 2012 and launches a sack the coach campaign.
Excuse me whilst I get my crayon to connect the dots …

 

[Swordy]

What happened to sensible chat and discussion on this forum. Somewhere you could come to share an opinion and to listen to other opinions with respect?
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_

 

[GoldXR50Leroy]

We have had the anonymous alleged NRL player have his say here in Player XXX but is Pistol_Pete another aggrieved NRL player or one and the same, they are only newcomers to the forum, a conspiracy perhaps?.
I do recall our much revered Leader, the Great Mr Sheens suggest that when the side stops making the Semi Finals then it's time for him to give the game away but really Robbie & Benji et al couldn't do that to their Foster Father.

 

[Knuckles]

After following the Maggie's for so many years, I think I have had my share of wooden spoons !

 

[Cultured_Bogan]

Interesting to note the handle of the OP… I find it ironic that Pistol Pete is shooting from the hip.

I've a hypothetical for you, what if we go on to win the comp... Would you sack a coach who brought a club, that was the laughing stock of the NRL when he came to us mind you, two premierships in seven years?

 

[Montague_Street]

Sorry Monty, he wasnt defending Fitzy, he conveniently, thanks to his ego, ignored the fact that people were criticising him…..not Fitzy, that was the main theme here, cant speak though for those at that game.

So those that were critical of the coach over fitzy, morris etc etc could hardly be blamed for thinking its them he's referring to.

Perhaps, but equally Sheens can hardly be fairly accused of criticizing those that made critical Forum posts of Fitzy et. al. There is NO evidence that Sheens read Forum posts but he must have been deaf not to hear the so-called supporters bagging Fitzy before he had even run on to the field.
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_

 

[innsaneink]

Yeh fair enough….poor form imo to boo your own players, no matter how inept we think they are.

 

[tiger4ever]

Another stupid poll that ends up giving results the topic starter didn't want to prove their point.

How about doing what they said last year …judge us at the end of the year.

Some people are never happy...it use to be cause we didn't make the semis and now we are so everyone should be happy...this years start isn't much good but we really only played 2 bad games against dragons and raiders.

 

[monkey]

I guarantee that if we win the comp all the haters will wanna kiss his arse cause he is a great coach for turning us around . U can't blame the coach he doesn't play the game and we have heaps of injuries and he only uses what's left in the cupboard sure he makes some selection mistakes but u dont coach as many games as he has by not knowin what he is doin
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_