Batmans Parents
Well-known member
Agreed but find one post on this thread or in the game thread where any poster on this forum said Seyfart was solely to blame.
Alex Seyfarth #232
- Thread starter TheDaBoss
- Start date
Agreed but find one post on this thread or in the game thread where any poster on this forum said Seyfart was solely to blame.
WestsEffTheRest
Well-known member
The way you seem to be particularly targeting Seyfarth seems to indicate so
Terry T.Nuts
Well-known member
Seyfart is shit, just face it. He would not make any other NRL side period. Jack Bird or Sukkar would make more metres than this clown. Him trying to add a passing game to his skill set is comedy gold if you are on the opposing side.
Jedi_Tiger
Well-known member
seems to me the only 2 players anyone wants to blame are seyfarth and galvin
Terrell May (golden child) didnt play well yesterday either....
Batmans Parents
Well-known member
Well then you clearly don’t have a clue what you’re talking about considering I was also calling out Galvin and Naden frequently in the game thread but I understand why you’d ignore that since it doesn’t go along with the BS narrative you’re putting out there.
When your starting second rower had run the ball once in the first 70 minutes, had a try assist for the Storm and was leaking breaks and tries all afternoon with Galvin on his edge, damn right I’m going to target him. Especially when his delusional little cult following continue to make excuses for him every week.
Batmans Parents
Well-known member
Sums it up perfectly. Because he shows “effort”, he must be a good player. That’s the thought process of the Seytard clan and shows we have some of, if not the dumbest fans in the NRL.
Batmans Parents
Well-known member
Seyfart fans really aren’t deep thinkers and love the deflection game.
May had a bad game but considering he’s been our best player over the first 9 rounds playing huge minutes, he gets a little leeway when he has his first bad performance.
WestsEffTheRest
Well-known member
I'm all for upgrading Seyfarth the point I've made is you need players like him at every club. What I find funny is for all the bashing you do you haven't named anyone that's currently at the club who could do a better job.
Terry T.Nuts
Well-known member
Bird, Sukkar and a toilet roll would do a better job than that clown.
Batmans Parents
Well-known member
We already have a a player like him in Twal except Twal doesn’t get driven back and put on his arse with every hit up.
I literally said in another thread that id give Sukkar or Bird (even though his discipline has been pretty bad) a go. Hell, I even said I’d give Sione a go there even though he’s more of a middle. They all have their flaws but they offer more impact than Seyfart.
You can’t carry a 80 minute second rower who is running for 60m a game and gives away dumb penalties. He is literally one of the worst second rowers in the game on a per minute basis.
WestsEffTheRest
Well-known member
So your solution is to plug crap with crap? Till a better solution comes a long there's no benefit in dropping Seyfarth.
Batmans Parents
Well-known member
No, my solution is try something different because the current solution is hurting the team. And you have no idea whether they would be crap if given the opportunity Seyfart has been given so you’re talking out of your rear end yet again. Not to mention their minute by minute production dwarfs Seytards so you’re going to have to find another excuse to keep him in the team.
There’s no benefit to dropping a guy who has literally cost us a game this season and nearly two others through his poor discipline? You Seyfart fans are Manson-follower level of delusion lol
WestsEffTheRest
Well-known member
How is the current solution hurting the team when the team has had it's best start to a season since 2019?
Batmans Parents
Well-known member
Holy goal post shifting Batman.
Do you think our start is because of Seyfarth contributions (noting he’s been part of all three wooden spoons), or the recruitment and effort of Luai, Turuva, May and Skelton?
WestsEffTheRest
Well-known member
It's not shifting goalposts Lol he's started every game in our best season since 2019. He's not the reason we are winning but to say he's hindering the team is nonsense & just shows how subjective your opinion is especially when your solution is to play props on the edge instead or play a rookie who only has 3 games to his name.
Batmans Parents
Well-known member
It aboslutely is shifting the goalposts but it's also a large dose of appeal to ignorance:
a) you're now directly associating our team success with him whilst conveniently ignoring that he played 23 games for us last season, including multiple starts, when we won a wooden spoon and
b) you're ignoring or at the very least minimising the recruitment of premiership winning players like Luai and Turuva as well as a top3-5 prop in the game in May.
So him literally costing us the Warriors game and nearly the Sharks and Dragons game doesn't qualify as hindering? How about having the worst production of any starting second rower in the comp?
Take a look at that and try gaslighting your way out of it because there's only one fool with a subjective opinion here and it ain't me. I know that as a Magpies fan, you're accustomed to rooting for mediocrity like Seyfart but the club is actually trying to get somewhere.
WestsEffTheRest
Well-known member
And yet with all that you still can't name anyone better to start over him
Batmans Parents
Well-known member
I literally did with reasoning like minute by minute production but you’re a bad faith clown who can’t or simply won’t argue the facts so there no point trying to explain it further to a moron.
WestsEffTheRest
Well-known member
You named middle forwards to start on an edge & then suggested a 3 game NRL rookie who's struggled in the lower grades could do a better job. Just because you try & act intimidating & hurl personal insults at people doesn't make you correct.
