Another Year Another disappointment

supercoach

Well-known member
It’s all over once again and our extended offseason begins as usual in early September. I guess we avoided the spoon so it was not a total disaster. The club got off to a disastrous start with our board room doing their best to destroy our season before a ball had been kicked off. With Richo’s sacking we lost probably the most important cog in the wheel.

Of course the first month or so we exceeded expectations and people were getting excited and talking top four come September. Personally I put very little importance on the first six weeks of the comp as it seldom gives you a gauge on how things will pan out. Anyway injuries,lack of depth, lack of quality, lack of speed and lack of mental toughness prevailed and we rolled over and never got back up.

Not sure what positives we can take out of the year, Iam really scratching my head to find one. Maybe the potential that Andrews showed in reserve grade. Iam also finding it hard to get any positive vibes about next year as I really think we are still way off top eight but with a good run with injuries we may climb the ladder a tad.

I really think the club will always struggle while the HBG hold the keys for the club. We are grossly under funded and lack the quality governance to compete with the best. Although the coaching staff and players need to have a long hard look at themselves. Anyway enjoy the off season and we will do it all again next year
 
Call to arms for Wests Tigers fans after another season slips by

Chris Barrett
September 7, 2026 — 6:00am





A
A
A
Fed up by years of dysfunction and disappointment, disgruntled Wests Tigers fans are set to push for the reinstatement of an independent board and a greater say in the direction of the under-performing club.

The Tigers have missed the finals for the past 15 seasons – by far the longest dry spell of any team in the competition – and have only qualified for the play-offs three times since Balmain and Western Suburbs merged in 1999.



Wests Tigers fans protest the removal of the club’s independent directors in December.Flavio Brancaleone
With another underwhelming campaign now over, Inner West Mayor Darcy Byrne has issued a call to arms for supporters to mobilise as part of a new independent group called Wests Tigers Unite to be formed in the off-season.

“At the start of this season, Wests Tigers supporters deliberately held off establishing a permanent supporters’ organisation,” Byrne said. “Like every Tigers fan, we hoped the club had finally turned a corner and wanted to get behind the team.

“Regrettably, this season has shown the underlying problems remain unresolved.

“After 15 years without finals football, Wests Tigers supporters have shown extraordinary loyalty. Yet they still have no meaningful say in the future of the club they love.”



Tigers fans had reason to hope for better times earlier this year but they slipped two places from 13th to 15th.Flavio Brancaleone
After a bright start to the year, the Tigers’ finals chances evaporated with eight losses in a row.

Benji Marshall’s team was also at the centre of two of the biggest soap operas of the season: the signing of Jarome Luai by the PNG Chiefs and Adam Doueihi’s refusal to play against Canberra in July.

Off the field, questions continue to be asked about Tigers majority owners, the Holman Barnes Group, whose decades-old governance model places power over the $100 million licensed club operation in the hands of 20 so-called debenture holders.

The only one of its kind remaining in the state, the debenture system has been the subject of an investigation by Liquor and Gaming NSW after multiple complaints were made about it.



The Adam Doueihi saga was just another chapter in Wests Tigers’ slide in 2026.Getty Images
HBG took over the Tigers board after it removed chairman Barry O’Farrell and three other independent directors in December in an intervention that prompted chief executive Shane Richardson to quit.

The sacked directors were reinstated amid supporter protests and pressure from the NRL, but the owners restructured the board to give them effective control, scrapping the independent-led board after less than 12 months.

“When it all blew up in December, the undertaking was that Barry O’Farrell would be reinstated as chair and our understanding was an independent board would be reinstated, and that’s yet to occur,” said Gary Barnier, one of the architects of a 2023 governance review that led O’Farrell and other independents to briefly have the balance of power on the Tigers board.

“The sooner it happens, the better we’ll all be.

“Professional sporting organisations that are successful have professional governance and professional structures. Wests Tigers will benefit from putting those things in place.”

After finishing 15th this season, down two spots from 2025, the new Tigers fan group aims to build on the movement that arose last year when the independent directors were unseated and seasoned operator Richardson left.

Byrne said the administration and ownership of the Tigers remained unaccountable to fans and members “who have stuck by the club through thick and thin”.

“It’s no coincidence that the only time that the performance of the organisation has improved was in the period that an independent board was in place,” Byrne said. “Re-establishing that is a necessity for turning the club around.

“Our goal is simple: to organise supporters, represent their views and advocate for governance arrangements that make the club more accountable to its members.

“This is not about division. It’s about giving one of rugby league’s biggest and most passionate supporter bases the seat at the table it deserves.”

It is yet to be determined what that looks like in practice, but there are myriad examples of supporters being able to exercise their will in Australian and world sport.

In the NRL, members don’t have a say on club boards at most clubs any more, although they can still nominate and vote for directors of select teams, such as Canterbury and Penrith.

Related Article

ExclusiveNRL 2026
V’landys v Gallop: The big-money brawl over Origin and finals
In European soccer, supporters also have greater agency at member-owned clubs, such as Barcelona and Real Madrid, and in Germany’s Bundesliga, which mandates that members of a club hold at least 50 per cent of voting rights plus one vote.

HBG has branched out into soccer recently, buying a stake in National Premier Leagues NSW team APIA Leichhardt and taking over the Central Coast Mariners in the A-League Women competition.

Supporters will be able to register their interest in Wests Tigers Unite at the One Last Roar concert at Leichhardt Oval on September 19, which is being held before the venue is renovated.

The iconic inner-west ground will be unavailable for games in 2027 while a $40 million upgrade takes place. The Tigers announced last week that they would play six home games at Campbelltown Stadium, as well as four at CommBank Stadium.
 
Another disappointing year and another season where I care less and less. Hard to see anything changing with this club after Richo left, he was the shining light for our club moving forward and now that has disappeared. I admire the call to arms, but it's hard be optimistic with how the NRL is run and how little the NRLs executive management care about clubs. Bottom $ is all that matters and although we generate headlines, we don't really matter.
 
Positives:
Jahream Bula’s last few games of the season, while nothing flash, he at least showed an increased willingness to get his hands on the ball, he was at least challenging the defensive line at speed and it was a noticeable increase in his overall energy and effort.
I am one of his biggest critics and I still have doubt we will get value for money on his new upgraded contract value, but based on his last few games I think there is a chance we will.

Fonua Pole still only 23 years old had a great season which really displayed the power, athleticism and footwork he possesses.
He has cut down his handling errors, improved his defence and is fast becoming one of the better props in the NRL.
We need to extend his contract and keep him with us long term.

Samuela Fainu - Had an injury riddled season which prevented him from showing his best on a regular basis, but he still showed glimpses of the size, power and athleticism he possesses.
Extending his contract with us is a high priority along with Latu and Fonua Pole.

Heamasi Makasini - Yes I know he was disappointing after the early promise he showed in our pre season games, but not forgetting he was still only 18y.o for a large portion of the season.
He is a big, tall and strong youngster who by all reports has a great work ethic and a great attitude.
I am optimistic he can be much better for the experience and start to live up to his potential in 2027.

Solomone Saukuru- He was always a promising standout junior who seemed to struggle with his weight and fitness levels, but he looks to now be in much better shape, a lot fitter than he has been for a few years and was rewarded with multiple standout performances in NSW Cup that led to his NRL debut and a few more NRL games to end the season.
It’s well known he for some reason struggles defensively, in particular his defensive reads, but you would think if we do re-sign him, continued improvement on his fitness levels and a major focus on his defence, could see him improve enough to become a serious NRL contender even when we are at full strength.

Junior Tupou - I thought he showed a lot of promise before he left us a few years back, he was seemingly underperforming at both the Dolphins and Roosters, but showed good gradual improvement and looked every bit an NRL player back with us for the back end of the season. He is still young and has scope for further improvement which could see him become a very good, valuable player in 2027.

Jack Attard - Showed promise early in the season, but his form stagnated somewhat mid season when switching between NSW Cup and Jersey Flegg. I thought his late season form for our Jersey Flegg team showed glimpses of the sheer speed, anticipation and class he possesses.
If he can add a little bit of muscle and size to his frame, he has enough ability to genuinely push Bula for our NRL fullback spot in 2027.

Javon Andrews - He signed for us with big wraps coming off a standout game for Qld u/19’s and a couple of senior Qld Cup games late in the 2024 season.
So I thought he was a player with potential, but I had no idea just how good and classy he is.
He had an outstanding season dominating and leading our NSW Cup team to many a good win and forcing his way to an NRL debut.
Like many young players he needs plenty of improvement with his defence, but it doesn’t concern me greatly as I watched a few NSW Cup games where he defended very well under plenty of pressure, so he well and truly has good defence in him.
Extremely classy young halve who combined extremely well with Latu in their one NSW Cup game together and he has enough talent to become a genuine NRL star.

Latu Fainu - I think nearly every Wests Tigers fan likes what they see from Latu when he plays in the halves and most of us are a bit perplexed why he has been held back for so long.
Obviously the Luai signing did not help his situation regarding NRL game time, but hopefully Luai’s work ethic and professionalism has rubbed off as he has been known to be a bit lazy in these areas.
Overall I think Latu being held back from regular NRL game time is a blessing in disguise or maybe a master plan from Benji as his last round 40min cameo just reinforced how much talent he has and he now looks ready to take the NRL world by storm in 2027.
Hopefully we can get his contract extended real soon.

Ethan Roberts - Another youngster who arrived to us with a big reputation, but was unfortunately hampered by early season injuries. He is a big human with good footwork, athleticism and skill to go with it. Made his NRL debut and generally impressed with his attacking ability, but showed he needs to improve his defence.
I’ve long known of his talent, so was happy when we signed him and to be honest his progression has far outweighed my expectations.
With a big offseason I think he can be a genuine strike weapon for us off the bench in 2027 and I really think the sky is the limit for him if he knuckles down and realises how good of an NRL player he can be.

Jared Haywood - A bit of a surprise he spent most of the season playing Jersey Flegg as he is so highly regarded, but I think it was a smart plan from Benji or whoever made the decision as it allowed him to continue tj grow in confidence in the age restricted competition and he was very dominant in most games he played. He made his NRL debut and was very impressive from at attacking point of view before ending the season with his last few games back in Jersey Flegg.
Another young player who needs to work hard to add a little bit of size and muscle to help tighten up his defence and he had a day to forget in our Jersey Flegg elimination last week, but he has a stack of ability and I think he will get much more NRL game time in 2027.
Apart from these more obvious players mentioned about, we have a few more good prospects emerging who could improve enough to become genuine NRL contenders in 2027.

Tony Sukkar - Another who I have long known the size, power and ability he possesses. I thought he had a really good season where his improvement was significant and is now showing he is a very capable NRL player who could have plenty of improvement left to come.
It would be a shame if we have developed him thus far and then let him go, let’s hope we re-sign him.

Vaka Aho / Had a very good improved season culminating with his last round NRL debut where he showed plenty of promise. He will take plenty of confidence from that and should show plenty more improvement again in 2027.

Heath Mason should we keep him, is still only 21y.o and showed some real good signs in hs cameos off the bench for our NRL team at 13 and 9 late in the season. He will be a much improved player for the experience and it will be a shame if we do not hang onto him.

Tino Tavana - Come out of nowhere to play a handful of NRL games this season. A have question marks on his defence and long distance speed for a winger who is not overly big, but his effort and his attacking aerial ability cannot be questioned. A sprinkling of NRL experience could see him be one a much improved player in 2027.

Peter Taateo - A few years older than all the others I have mentioned, but he come ba onto us after spending the early rounds at the Sharks and instantly resume his powerful, high speed, aggressive ball running. Another that needs work and focus on his defence, but he is showing good potential as an impact player who can come into the field and make a real positive difference.

Christian Taupau-Moors, Archie Duncombe, Phoenix Godinet and Blake Van Drie all made good strides in their progression and it’s hard to gauge how much they will be improved by the time the 2027 season commences.
It’s not out of the question that any of them could make a rapid rise and become genuine NRL contenders in 2027.
 
Last edited:
I find it hard to blame the players and coaches when the culture of failure and giving up comes from above them. This place has a loser stench we can't get rid of.

Even in hindsight I think Justin Pascoe was not even that bad. I remember reading an article about his time here, he spoke about a few things he wanted to do which I believe would've been beneficial to us, and the board/HBG/whoever just wouldn't get behind him.
 
I find it hard to blame the players and coaches when the culture of failure and giving up comes from above them. This place has a loser stench we can't get rid of.

Even in hindsight I think Justin Pascoe was not even that bad. I remember reading an article about his time here, he spoke about a few things he wanted to do which I believe would've been beneficial to us, and the board/HBG/whoever just wouldn't get behind him.
Hands must just be completely tied in their role
 
Circle of life

Brilliant motivational articles and streaming footage released. Followed by a season mixed with moments of hope only to have a trap of thumpings in the middle to end the season whilst we flap in the remaining games watching with nothing to gain. Mixed in with mid season player selfishness and well it’s really hard to wake up for the next season being passionate.

We make the exact same mistakes coaching, game plan and roster wise year after year.
 
Tigers are just consistent in turmoil
Tim Sheens sacked August 2023

Lachlan Galvin released May 2025

HBG sack board Dec 2025

CEO walks 2026

Luai signs with PNG May 2026

Xxxxxxxxxx May 2027
Next year the only thing that could happen that would be something new is a fight breaks out on field between a few Tiger players and the Ref has to send them off for punching and knowing the club it could happen

AD and Twal punching on with the May boys after a missed tackle it really could happen
 

Latest posts

Back
Top