CEO - Shane Richardson

GNR4LIFE said:
Right, so the alternative is to sign no one haha

Idk mate, for all your talk about Pascoe apologists, you are a bit of a Richo apologist.
Click to expand...
I am a Richo apologist. He’s got runs on the board.

He’s also made his strategy public, you make spots available and have cap room and strike when the timing is right. There’s not much on the market now, why repeat old errors?
 
Last edited:
TSP said:
Very interesting thesis, thanks for crafting it, but i cant subscribe to it entirely for a couple of reasons. Reasonable minds can come to different conclusions.

Benji is a bit of a dill. He joins up with Tim and then puts his hand up to coach a poor roster without any experience. He should have done a proper apprenticeship and bided his time. His track record is appalling. Easily the worst coach in the NRL. If he was that talented as a coach, he should have done better last year.

Its his job to instill character and get as many players as possible playing at their optimum no matter the opposition. Hes failing miserably on that kpi. Good teams fight hard all the time. They dont get plastered into oblivion.

And lets not forget, if it is the players fault, then he recruited them!

He spent most of last year making excuses that he was a rookie. Well he wasnt bashful before he took the job.

It was his job to train then out of fatigue. Lots of coaches do it fairly regularly.

Weve got a young side, they should be physically adept to counter surges.

As for the culture, he hasnt built a winning culture. Hes relectant to hold players to account and he nevers calls them out. They know that as far as the public is concerned, they get a free ride.

He hates sacking players from the side. Its very hard to get sacked. No or very little accountability. All bets are off.

And my favourite argument, he said after the storm game that he screwed their preparation or "i will need to look at what i did." It was a full and unfettered admission. A confession that hes not where he needs to be.

Im not saying hes a bad person, he works hard but all that hard work....nothing especially great is coming from it. Thats another issue. Hes banging his head up against a wall.

Hes had months to prepare the players for combat and at times, they wont even get out of their fox holes.

I just havent seen enough to suggest his tenure should be set in stone. My feeling is that the team could respond better with another in command.

He can take a few years off and come back with a few notches under his belt.

No one likes to see him failing, floundering away, mouth wide open, arms waving wildly in the air...destroying his legacy as a superb player, pretty much for most of his incredible career.

And one that left the game in a better place than whence he found it. Rare and a gift.

But that doesnt always translate to the coaching lark.

Over to you maestro....
Click to expand...
You take me for a Benji fan boy. I'm not a huge fan, but neither do I believe that he is hopeless. I have seen enough for me to think that he has the goods to be successful and I like the approach he has taken to try and build a culture in the place.

Some see him as never blaming the team, others think he supporting them for doing the same thing. It is all about an individual's perspective. I have no doubt that he could have done better in preparation (in hindsight it is easy to say); however, the game was lost on the paddock not before they went out there. It is not like the flogging started from the kickoff.

I used the Cows game of an example of where the spoon winners dished out a flogging as well - so it happens to well coached teams too.

The reality is not known to anyone outside of the walls of the club - to state otherwise is simply conjecture based on personal perception.

My personal belief is that Benji shouldn't have been given the coaching position; but he has. I have seen enough to know that he can prepare a team and that they can execute a passable game plan. He is on the right path and is developing. Should that have been done as a FG coach? No - but it is what we have.

It is clear that we are short quality in areas and I have faith that this will improve; probably not before 26 though. I'm prepared to give him another year with an improved roster. You have a different perspective. Time will tell.
 
GNR4LIFE said:
Lol what? We let go Stef, Ice, Bateman, Klemmer and soon to be Galvin with no replacements.
Click to expand...
And how are they going at their new clubs ? You’ve been death riding Richo since he got here. has cleared many cancers from this club and had just cleared the biggest of them all. He’s doing a great job. The club is turning around under his helm , even blind Freddie can see it .
 
tigerman80 said:
And how are they going at their new clubs ? You’ve been death riding Richo since he got year .he has cleared many cancers from this club and had just cleared the biggest of them all. He’s doing a great job. The club is turning around under his helm , even blind Freddie can see it .
Click to expand...
Didn’t Stef just get picked in the Origin squad? But the point isn’t about how they are going, it’s how little we have gotten in return.
 
Jolls said:
You take me for a Benji fan boy. I'm not a huge fan, but neither do I believe that he is hopeless. I have seen enough for me to think that he has the goods to be successful and I like the approach he has taken to try and build a culture in the place.

Some see him as never blaming the team, others think he supporting them for doing the same thing. It is all about an individual's perspective. I have no doubt that he could have done better in preparation (in hindsight it is easy to say); however, the game was lost on the paddock not before they went out there. It is not like the flogging started from the kickoff.

I used the Cows game of an example of where the spoon winners dished out a flogging as well - so it happens to well coached teams too.

The reality is not known to anyone outside of the walls of the club - to state otherwise is simply conjecture based on personal perception.

My personal belief is that Benji shouldn't have been given the coaching position; but he has. I have seen enough to know that he can prepare a team and that they can execute a passable game plan. He is on the right path and is developing. Should that have been done as a FG coach? No - but it is what we have.

It is clear that we are short quality in areas and I have faith that this will improve; probably not before 26 though. I'm prepared to give him another year with an improved roster. You have a different perspective. Time will tell.
Click to expand...

Thanks.

No i dont dare presuppose to know your actual thinking, only the argument posited. I take note of your contributions.

I would rather dispense with him in the manner that ive discussed previously affording him significant dignity and grace. And ive opened my heart to him for a future "incursion"

Realistically, i think he will almost certainly get another season yet maybe he will want two.

I think @Tucker was speculating as to the consequences for him if we cant improve and regain our competiveness this year.

Whilst support for him is dwindling, it may not be at the rate required to actually pull the trigger.

A handful of heavy defeats may be required to dislodge the onus favouring his continuation.

As against Galvin, Benji has always had my fullhearted and undying support.

And as a club at least we threw a few punches until we succumbed to $175k.

But of course, we only get a small slice of the background. Usually unpalatable!
 
GNR4LIFE said:
Didn’t Stef just get picked in the Origin squad? But the point isn’t about how they are going, it’s how little we have gotten in return.
Click to expand...
Those guys didn’t come here and live up to their lofty reputations either, which means you can’t just move on and sign equally established talent. There’s a cost.
 
BAGNF05 said:
Galvin left 24 hours ago mate, the guys wearing those jerseys are doing much better on the ladder than the gone guys.
Click to expand...
Theyve known about this since April 10 and we still havent replaced the forwards we lost.
Stef, Klem, Bateman and Papa for May, Big lazy Royce and a somewhat interested Bird....
Our pack has gone ok to start the season. The back half is where theyll be tested. They require reinforcements pronto.
 
Tucker said:
Theyve known about this since April 10 and we still havent replaced the forwards we lost.
Stef, Klem, Bateman and Papa for May, Big lazy Royce and a somewhat interested Bird....
Our pack has gone ok to start the season. The back half is where theyll be tested. They require reinforcements pronto.
Click to expand...
Mid season transfers are a gift that only wests tigers provide!
 
Tucker said:
Theyve known about this since April 10 and we still havent replaced the forwards we lost.
Stef, Klem, Bateman and Papa for May, Big lazy Royce and a somewhat interested Bird....
Our pack has gone ok to start the season. The back half is where theyll be tested. They require reinforcements pronto.
Click to expand...
Galvin leaving solves a potential headache IF the Latu signing wasn’t a stuff-up in the first place. Big IF.

I’m with you and GNR, we still have holes to fill in the forwards and believe me I’m checking back here daily to see if we’ve filled those gaps BUT I also remember how poorly we’ve done in the past using the “signing what’s available on overs” strategy.

Richo has frustrated fans with his patient approach but we need to remember his track record is building winning clubs, while ours is watching a losing one.
 
TIGERS said:
If it turns out the Club/Richo decided to let Galvin go to the Bulldogs to avoid him going to the Eels, that could be an act of genius.

Bulldogs are already on top and flying. Galvin has to make them better. If they don't win a comp and fall off, it will be the decision to sign Galvin that gets blamed. Also if they continue to play great, Galvin is not the catalyst behind their rise. He joined an already winning team. The pressure going to be on Galvin now and I don't think he's ready for it. He's left to develop as a half by playing maybe at Lock. lol.

If its the Eels he joins up with another poached Tigers player. They go scurrying up the ladder and its the Galvin signing that did it. And its basically more of "what might have been" if Isaac Moses had never been born. From a optics standpoint it's much much worse for us. He;s also an eels fan of course.

If that is actually the case, and the Doggies don't take to him.... smooth move.
Click to expand...
I wouldn't be surprised if Galvin did end up at Parra, even this stage
 
Tucker said:
Theyve known about this since April 10 and we still havent replaced the forwards we lost.
Stef, Klem, Bateman and Papa for May, Big lazy Royce and a somewhat interested Bird....
Our pack has gone ok to start the season. The back half is where theyll be tested. They require reinforcements pronto.
Click to expand...
Stef, Klem, Bateman and Papa...the tears are veritably running my cheeks by their permanent omission from our roster.

Weve more than replaced these holiday making pussies.

I thought you were on the wagon? Have a night off!

Bateman, ffs i had to blink to make sure i wasnt seeing things.

How many spoons did this sordid lot deliver?
 
Last edited:
TIGERS said:
If it turns out the Club/Richo decided to let Galvin go to the Bulldogs to avoid him going to the Eels, that could be an act of genius.

Bulldogs are already on top and flying. Galvin has to make them better. If they don't win a comp and fall off, it will be the decision to sign Galvin that gets blamed. Also if they continue to play great, Galvin is not the catalyst behind their rise. He joined an already winning team. The pressure going to be on Galvin now and I don't think he's ready for it. He's left to develop as a half by playing maybe at Lock. lol.

If its the Eels he joins up with another poached Tigers player. They go scurrying up the ladder and its the Galvin signing that did it. And its basically more of "what might have been" if Isaac Moses had never been born. From a optics standpoint it's much much worse for us. He;s also an eels fan of course.

If that is actually the case, and the Doggies don't take to him.... smooth move.
Click to expand...
There will be questions asked and fingers pointed no doubt whether justly or unjustly.

And no its not some coping mechanism, Im sleeping well
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 341 (members: 5, guests: 336)
Back
Top