Congratulations Nathan Milone

[Guest]

I've never rated him and tonight did nothing to change my mind.

That's the first negative thing I can recall willow saying. And tend to have to agree.

_Posted using RoarFEED 4.2.0_

What ??

Willow has had his cranky pants on all night

Just being realistic, we sucked and Milone is not an NRL quality centre.

 

[happy_tiger]

I've never rated him and tonight did nothing to change my mind.

That's the first negative thing I can recall willow saying. And tend to have to agree.

_Posted using RoarFEED 4.2.0_

What ??

Willow has had his cranky pants on all night

Just being realistic, we sucked and Milone is not an NRL quality centre.

Ok so you had your reality pants on , but you can't base your judgement on one performance

He got little quality ball and the one time he did he scored , imo JT should of dragged Lovett for that , that was brain dead footy , he didn't have any reason to run to Sezers outside shoulder :brick:

 

[Goose]

He went ok.
He is IMO of limited talent, but did his bet and didn't let us down.
Hoeter on the other hand, was very poor .

 

[stevetiger]

Hoeter and Milone don't appear to be first grade standard.

 

[diedpretty]

How was the obstruction his fault - that was Lovett who didn't have the nouse to run on the inside shoulder. Milone still had to work hard to get over the line.

 

[Russell]

He was awful. Well maybe not awful but extremely average. I've seen him play something like 20-30 times now and not once has he looked anything even above average. He's slow, small and not overly gifted in any aspect of the game.

It would have been better to play Lovett, Liolevave or Funaki in the centres. Heck even Seve without much experience is at least an attacking threat. It doesn't matter how nice he is or how hard he trains. He didn't deserve a first grade spot yet and his deficiencies were obvious.

A year or two in state cup and who knows.

**Hoeter has been a winger or fullback all his career, suddenly out of necessity we make him a centre, which he's not**.

Then being the good people we are - we crucify him for it. He was not good in defense last night but he did not choose to be a centre.

 

[Russell]

Both centres were terrible. Neither stuck to. Tackle all night.

Hoeter can be a good first grade winger IMO. He is great under the high ball and has solid dummy half runs. A center he will never be.

Milone was bog average, not really his fault as Simona, nofo, fine, Lulia and moltzen are all injured and probably ahead of him in the pecking order. Also he has played left center his entire career, don't know why they didn't just play hoeter there.

Neither will make it. George Rose is quicker than Hoeter. We don't need any more slow outside backs. Putting up with Richards the slug is about enough.

Looking forward to a positive comment one day Pacman. Hope I live long enough to read it.

 

[stevetiger]

How was the obstruction his fault - that was Lovett who didn't have the nouse to run on the inside shoulder. Milone still had to work hard to get over the line.

Completely agree.

 

[Fumbles]

This surprises me greatly.

He has proved me wrong. Good on him.

The report has always been he is a terrific kid who does all the little things right. He is good to see them succeed.

Im glad Irvine is banned, he would be giving it to me with both barrel for saying he wouldn't make it.

I think Malone proved you right. He doesn't look anything like an NRL centre, very very average.

Goose why aren't you doing our recruiting ?

 

[Juro]

I really don't understand the obstruction ruling. Our player runs through the line, and the Titans player steps to his side and tackles him without the ball. The Titans player made an error, but gets rewarded with a penalty?