OFFICIAL Elijah Taylor [Discussion]

I cant explain how stoked I am with this signing. Really think he's going to do wonders for our forward pack. Big motor, great defender and can hit. FINALLY!!! a signing that I don't think anyone could say a bad word about.
 
@WestsSupporter said:
Yep like above posters are saying you don't play 100 first grade games and 10 tests by being a chump. Hope to see him in the team.

Dene Halatau has played over 230 NRL games and 15 Tests and he isn't far from being chump material

Lets hope he is a massive upgrade on Dene 😛ray:
 
@happy tiger said:
@WestsSupporter said:
Yep like above posters are saying you don't play 100 first grade games and 10 tests by being a chump. Hope to see him in the team.

Dene Halatau has played over 230 NRL games and 15 Tests and he isn't far from being chump material

Lets hope he is a massive upgrade on Dene 😛ray:

Perhaps because Dene is 33 and Taylor is 26 and in his prime
 
If happy doesn't like u you're dirt..unlike Nathan 'Renouf' Milone…

If Taylor can match the value Grant has bought to the Wests Tigers we'll be doing OK...Elijah Taylor was very impressive in the residents game on the weekend his work rate in defence is far and away that of most of our current Pack...His lines in attack and ball work wasn't to shabby either...

If he can take some of the workload off Farah all the better for us
 
@Boonboon2 said:
@happy tiger said:
@WestsSupporter said:
Yep like above posters are saying you don't play 100 first grade games and 10 tests by being a chump. Hope to see him in the team.

Dene Halatau has played over 230 NRL games and 15 Tests and he isn't far from being chump material

Lets hope he is a massive upgrade on Dene 😛ray:

Perhaps because Dene is 33 and Taylor is 26 and in his prime

Dene's prime was a 12 week period in 2005 :laughing:
 
@Geo. said:
If happy doesn't like u you're dirt..unlike Nathan 'Renouf' Milone…

If Taylor can match the value Grant has bought to the Wests Tigers we'll be doing OK...Elijah Taylor was very impressive in the residents game on the weekend his work rate in defence is far and away that of most of our current Pack...His lines in attack and ball work wasn't to shabby either...

If he can take some of the workload off Farah all the better for us

I haven't knocked Taylor at all Geo

Someone brought something up and I responded

Dene's been massive for the club since we brought him back , hey ??

3 decent (and I mean decent , not good ) games at best
 
It's going to get harder and harder to get into our NRL side and we'll have some good players running around in State Cup. The extra competition for spots can only be a good thing and I'm hoping that, as time goes on and as I've said before, there won't be any shame attached to playing in our State Cup side.
 
One of the best signings we've had for a long time. Great defender and plenty of class. So glad we were patient and didn't blow our money in desperation months ago.
 
I hope Taylor comes to our club with the same plan as Grant , fresh Start and wants to play first grade , if he gets back to his best it will only be all positive for the club , he defends well and if you stop teams putting on points then half the battle is won , we have players that can produce points , I don't think he will play this next game but the one after I can see him on the bench
Grant and Taylor could be our best buys for a while
 
Playing Taylor this week is a priority this is a big game for the team .. Win this one then Newcastle at Cambo ,roll into the Origin period and things could be very different within the month .Bums on seats alone on Sunday with a positive addition to the team is a positive as well,interesting to see how JT approaches this.
 
@Snake said:
Playing Taylor this week is a priority this is a big game for the team .. Win this one then Newcastle at Cambo ,roll into the Origin period and things could be very different within the month .Bums on seats alone on Sunday with a positive addition to the team is a positive as well,interesting to see how JT approaches this.

I agree this is a chance for JT to show he has some smarts about him when it comes to team selection. What he does with Elijah and how he fills in the fullback position are 2 things I'm waiting to see come 5pm today.
 
@happy tiger said:
@WestsSupporter said:
Yep like above posters are saying you don't play 100 first grade games and 10 tests by being a chump. Hope to see him in the team.

Dene Halatau has played over 230 NRL games and 15 Tests and he isn't far from being chump material

Lets hope he is a massive upgrade on Dene 😛ray:

Well FTWIT, I agree Happy. I would straight out swap Taylor for Dene. I doubt that will happen, but ignoring the age/energy difference they are similar size and playing style by the looks?

Dropping Dene out of the team would allow us to put a bigger player on the bench.
 
@stevetiger said:
I have high expectations for this guy. I'm hopeful he can be defensively really strong and minimise our mid game slumps.

GNR - I can't see him making the starting side but I'd play him at 13\. It's not a big deal though. Let him prove himself off the bench.

Pointless to play him off the bench IMO. He's not an impact player, certainly not post-injuries. But he can play 80 and get through a lot of defensive work, letting other forwards run shorter spells.
 
@tigermac88 said:
@Snake said:
Playing Taylor this week is a priority this is a big game for the team .. Win this one then Newcastle at Cambo ,roll into the Origin period and things could be very different within the month .Bums on seats alone on Sunday with a positive addition to the team is a positive as well,interesting to see how JT approaches this.

I agree this is a chance for JT to show he has some smarts about him when it comes to team selection. What he does with Elijah and how he fills in the fullback position are 2 things I'm waiting to see come 5pm today.

Rankin will be named at fullback. Put a monkey on it.
 
The signing of Grant and ET is the sort of recruitment this club should have been doing for years instead of trying to find a diamond in the garbage bin policy we have had for years. This team is one class centre and maybe a winger away from a very good roster
 
@barra said:
Well FTWIT, I agree Happy. I would straight out swap Taylor for Dene. I doubt that will happen, but ignoring the age/energy difference they are similar size and playing style by the looks?

Dropping Dene out of the team would allow us to put a bigger player on the bench.

Nah Taylor is 10+kg heavier and 4-5 inches taller than Dene, they're very different physically and so have very different games. Dene is a tough little nugget whereas Taylor is more in the athletic mould.
 

Members online

Back
Top