Ex tigers v tigers

[Really]

Is this team of current ex tigers players better than our current team??
1\. Austin
2\. Ado carr
3\. Simona
4\. Ashford
5\. Koribete
6\. Te Martin
7\. Marshall
8\. Blair
9\. Farah
10\. Fifita
11\. Sironen
12\. Hoffman
13\. Tupou
14\. Lodge
15\. Nathan brown
16\. Heiginton
17\. Sitaleki akaula
Spelling might be a bit off but I reckon they would beat us now comfortably and fit under the salary cap. Someone is making interesting decisions
Did I miss anyone??

 

[WestsBenTigers]

Is this team of current ex tigers players better than our current team??
1\. Austin
2\. Ado carr
3\. Simona
4\. Ashford
5\. Koribete
6\. Te Martin
7\. Marshall
8\. Blair
9\. Farah
10\. Fifita
11\. Sironen
12\. Hoffman
13\. Tupou
14\. Lodge
15\. Nathan brown
16\. Heiginton
17\. Sitaleki akaula
Spelling might be a bit off but I reckon they would beat us now comfortably and fit under the salary cap. Someone is making interesting decisions
Did I miss anyone??

Ok Let's see

Austin v Tedesco - Tedesco
JAC v Nofo - Nofo
TimSim v Kev - TimSim
Ayshford v Idris - Idris
Koro v Suli - Koro (but Suli has shown some potential and he is a centre NOT a winger)
TMM v Moses - That is a good matchup
Benji v Brooks - Young Benji would beat Brooks but Benji isn't young anymore
Blair v Woods - Woods
Farah v Liddle - I would rather have Liddle but Robbie at this stage is a better player
Fifita v Ava - Fifita
Siro v Aloiai - This is another good matchup, probably Aloiai
Hoffman v Lawrence - Hoffman
Tupou v ET - ET

Ex Tigers have a much stronger bench

 

[Cosimo_Zaretti]

Simona's betting against his own team, so I reckon we've got this.

 

[nrlcountrytiger]

Simona's betting against his own team, so I reckon we've got this.

:laughing: "run the ball at Tim"

 

[gallagher]

Looks like we've let just as much crap go as we've kept.

 

[Harvey]

Think that the current team would win. 17 on 15 is a fair advantage, as there is no way Simona or Lodge will be getting near an NRL game any time soon.

Can someone confirm when Hoffman ever played in a wests tigers jersey? Might as well throw Hayne, Kahu, Folau and anyone that ever attended Keebra Park into the side.

 

[Yossarian]

That 3/4 line has a lot of defensive issues! As the forward pack is more leaner than lifter. Plus a few people in that team might be unavailable due to legal issues.

 

[happy_tiger]

Think that the current team would win. 17 on 15 is a fair advantage, as there is no way Simona or Lodge will be getting near an NRL game any time soon.

Can someone confirm when Hoffman ever played in a wests tigers jersey? Might as well throw Hayne, Kahu, Folau and anyone that ever attended Keebra Park into the side.

Replace them Rangi Chase ,BMM ,Sam Moa ,Rob Lui etc

 

[Tigertigertiger]

Hoffman was a St Gregs boy

 

[Harvey]

Yes and Folau and Hayne were Campbelltown juniors. None of them ever played for the wests tigers

 

[larrycorowa]

Both very ordinary teams, I think Farah inclusion in the ex players would tip the balance in favour if the current team.

 

[Milky]

1\. Blake Austin
2\. Joshua Addo Carr
3\. Tim Simona
4\. Rangi Chase
5\. Marika Koroibete

6\. Te Mair Martin
7\. Robert Lui

8\. Andrew Fifita
9\. Robbie Farah
10\. Nathan Brown
11\. Ben Teo
12\. Bodene Thomson
13\. Martin Taupau

14\. Sam Moa
15\. Agnatius Passi
16\. Ben Murdoch Masila
17\. Sitakeli Akoula

Would tear our current side to shreds.

 

[innsaneink]

Passi?
Everyone's forgetting poor ol Manaia

 

[GNR4LIFE]

Passi?
Everyone's forgetting poor ol Manaia

Paws was talking Manaia up something fierce a few weeks ago :laughing: Now he's at best third string hooker at the Sharks now they have Seggy

 

[sheer64]

We would be competitive for 30 odd minutes then the wheels would fall off!

 

[Tacky]

Is this team of current ex tigers players better than our current team??
1\. Austin
2\. Ado carr
3\. Simona
4\. Ashford
5\. Koribete
6\. Te Martin
7\. Marshall
8\. Blair
9\. Farah
10\. Fifita
11\. Sironen
12\. Hoffman
13\. Tupou
14\. Lodge
15\. Nathan brown
16\. Heiginton
17\. Sitaleki akaula
Spelling might be a bit off but I reckon they would beat us now comfortably and fit under the salary cap. Someone is making interesting decisions
Did I miss anyone??

Marshall, Ayshford, Blair and Sironen were well below their best when they were released. Lodge and Simona are criminals. Hoffman never played for us. Koroibete doesn't play League anymore. Tupou? Heighington and Farah are at the end of their careers. Austin doesn't make any impact in games more often than not. If you take that into account, the only players we really lost are Fifita, Brown, Akouala, Martin, and Addo-Carr.

 

[Blackpearl]

What about mr T on a wing. Scored an awesome try today for waratahs
No mention of him at all, far more imposing than ado carr