Fan's Tigers side to take on Cowboys
- Thread starter Milky
- Start date
H
Hitup
Guest
Modest haha prop n hooker was my go when playing for Newtown jets haha so bench for me lol
Wandering Tiger
Active member
1\. Tedesco
2\. Reddy
4\. Simona
4\. Koroibete
5\. Nofoaluama
6\. Marshall
7\. Anasta
8\. Woods
9\. Farah
10\. Buchanan
11\. Sironen
12\. BMM
13\. Fulton
14\. Pettybourne
15\. Sue
16\. Ava
17\. Thompson
I honestly believe
A) Koroibete would have more room to be destructive plus would get more ball
B) Sironen is a backrower
C) Marshall should play in starting side
D) Keep the same front rower pairings Buchanan and Woods for some continuitiy
E) give guys like Sue and ava time to get used to nrl. bench is best. we dont need to stress these good newbies.
2\. Reddy
4\. Simona
4\. Koroibete
5\. Nofoaluama
6\. Marshall
7\. Anasta
8\. Woods
9\. Farah
10\. Buchanan
11\. Sironen
12\. BMM
13\. Fulton
14\. Pettybourne
15\. Sue
16\. Ava
17\. Thompson
I honestly believe
A) Koroibete would have more room to be destructive plus would get more ball
B) Sironen is a backrower
C) Marshall should play in starting side
D) Keep the same front rower pairings Buchanan and Woods for some continuitiy
E) give guys like Sue and ava time to get used to nrl. bench is best. we dont need to stress these good newbies.
@fixxhalo said:
lost all credibility when you put koro at centre. His defensive reads are already subpar and only his speed and power keeps him in the side which are obviously best used on the wing. That's why wings are the fastest people in teams usually. And nofo can already play centre a million times better than koro.
Brainless decision, rest i agree with. Although, buchanan is a newbie so 'we don't need to stress these good newbies' kinda contradicts that.
Paris_Cobbs
New member
The only thing that REALLY matters is that the spine must be:
Tedesco Marshall Anasta and Farah. Injuries aside, this gives us stability, experience, genuine talent and creativity in the spine.
The rest are foot soldiers. The only requirement is that they have to be able to tackle and they have to have a go. The return, if ever, of Galloway and Bell would make a big difference.
So, Koro goes as on balance he is a big liability that we can't afford. Reddy and Utai don't have his talent but they are a safer bet for a while. I'm prepared to give Simona another go, but he must work on his defense. I think we should play Sironen in the centres as he deserves a place in the top side and he can tackle. Novo earns another chance.
My great fear this week is that Adolf Potler will bench Liam Fulton to put him in his place and draw a line in the sand as he received far too much praise on the forum for his performance v the Rabbits!
Tedesco Marshall Anasta and Farah. Injuries aside, this gives us stability, experience, genuine talent and creativity in the spine.
The rest are foot soldiers. The only requirement is that they have to be able to tackle and they have to have a go. The return, if ever, of Galloway and Bell would make a big difference.
So, Koro goes as on balance he is a big liability that we can't afford. Reddy and Utai don't have his talent but they are a safer bet for a while. I'm prepared to give Simona another go, but he must work on his defense. I think we should play Sironen in the centres as he deserves a place in the top side and he can tackle. Novo earns another chance.
My great fear this week is that Adolf Potler will bench Liam Fulton to put him in his place and draw a line in the sand as he received far too much praise on the forum for his performance v the Rabbits!
Wandering Tiger
Active member
@pHyR3 said:
buchanan has played prop all season and has a few more games under his belt then sue and ava. also he has handled it well plus works with woods. theres no contradiction. the 2 young forwards have been throw in at a low point where with buchanan came earlier on before this mess.
With koro, well thats your opinion i think his defence will get better with more game time and will be more destructive runner whilst playing there.
mikey
Well-known member
I can't believe so many people are calling for Anasta to be back in the side. Does everyone forget how badly he went missing ala Humphrey B Blair earlier in the year and how many of you were calling for his head?
tigerbenji
Well-known member
A
tigerbenji
Well-known member
Anasta @ Half would be o.k, better then him playing @ 2nd Row or Lock.
Gladesville_Tiger
New member
Anyone else, just do not have Blair in the 17, make him 18th man.
1\. Tedesco - Long term fullback
2\. Nofoaluama - Superb last week
3\. Simona - Talented and we develop into an excellent 1st grader, need to persist
4\. Sironen - Killed it last year when played there after an injury in the game. Big, strong, skillful and can run good lines
5\. Koroibete - X-Factor
6\. Marshall - Needs forward to aim up to play his game, unfairly being targeted for poor form, no halves can operate effectively behind the pussycat forward packs we have fielded (Woods/Farah excluded…)
7\. Anasta - For now.....Brooks eventually
8\. Woods - 100% every week. A star
9\. Farah - Ditto
10\. Buchanan - Only young, done nothing wrong, will improve each game
11\. Fulton - Tackling machine. Works his butt off
12\. Ava - The future. Has a go unlike Blair/Pettybourne etc
13\. Sue - Ditto
14\. Thompson
15\. Groat
16\. BMM
17\. Spence
2\. Nofoaluama - Superb last week
3\. Simona - Talented and we develop into an excellent 1st grader, need to persist
4\. Sironen - Killed it last year when played there after an injury in the game. Big, strong, skillful and can run good lines
5\. Koroibete - X-Factor
6\. Marshall - Needs forward to aim up to play his game, unfairly being targeted for poor form, no halves can operate effectively behind the pussycat forward packs we have fielded (Woods/Farah excluded…)
7\. Anasta - For now.....Brooks eventually
8\. Woods - 100% every week. A star
9\. Farah - Ditto
10\. Buchanan - Only young, done nothing wrong, will improve each game
11\. Fulton - Tackling machine. Works his butt off
12\. Ava - The future. Has a go unlike Blair/Pettybourne etc
13\. Sue - Ditto
14\. Thompson
15\. Groat
16\. BMM
17\. Spence
sober_siddhi
New member
Anasta will be lock. Benji back in the halves.
Staff online
-
DempsModerator