Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature currently requires accessing the site using the built-in Safari browser.
@king sirro said:Heaps happy for Robbie and cant wait to watch him go.
\
\
But, if i have to be honest, i dont understand the selection. Gidley, while overrated, covers so many postions if there's any injuries, and they replace him with a specialist hooker? What makes it even more odd is that Cameron Smith is an 80 minute player, its sort of like having 2 halfbacks in the squad, u just wouldnt do it. What happens if an outside back gets injured?
**While i believe Robbie is the best 9 in the world,** i see this as a very biased selection by Sheens. But here's hoping he gets some good game time and gets an early jump on Ennis for the Blues job next year.
I'd really love to see Slater go down injured in the first 5 minutes and Robbie come at 6 pushing Lockyer to fullback and Farah get MOM.
@stryker said:@king sirro said:Heaps happy for Robbie and cant wait to watch him go.
\
\
But, if i have to be honest, i dont understand the selection. Gidley, while overrated, covers so many postions if there's any injuries, and they replace him with a specialist hooker? What makes it even more odd is that Cameron Smith is an 80 minute player, its sort of like having 2 halfbacks in the squad, u just wouldnt do it. What happens if an outside back gets injured?
**While i believe Robbie is the best 9 in the world,** i see this as a very biased selection by Sheens. But here's hoping he gets some good game time and gets an early jump on Ennis for the Blues job next year.
I'd really love to see Slater go down injured in the first 5 minutes and Robbie come at 6 pushing Lockyer to fullback and Farah get MOM.
This quote appears on this forum regularly and it gives me the poo's a bit as it is total nonsense. Not singling you out here Sirro a lot on here think this way, including the Australian coach, but it is just plain not true and was again emphasised today.
I can not explain why but Robbie just isn't up to rep football at this stage in his career
@Balmain Tiger said:i think its stupid how people say farah being selected is favoritism..
if this was the case im sure we would see lawrence and galloway also
@king sirro said:@stryker said:@king sirro said:Heaps happy for Robbie and cant wait to watch him go.
\
\
But, if i have to be honest, i dont understand the selection. Gidley, while overrated, covers so many postions if there's any injuries, and they replace him with a specialist hooker? What makes it even more odd is that Cameron Smith is an 80 minute player, its sort of like having 2 halfbacks in the squad, u just wouldnt do it. What happens if an outside back gets injured?
**While i believe Robbie is the best 9 in the world,** i see this as a very biased selection by Sheens. But here's hoping he gets some good game time and gets an early jump on Ennis for the Blues job next year.
I'd really love to see Slater go down injured in the first 5 minutes and Robbie come at 6 pushing Lockyer to fullback and Farah get MOM.
This quote appears on this forum regularly and it gives me the poo's a bit as it is total nonsense. Not singling you out here Sirro a lot on here think this way, including the Australian coach, but it is just plain not true and was again emphasised today.
I can not explain why but Robbie just isn't up to rep football at this stage in his career
Your probably right. I should have said i believe he's the best club hooker in he world. Because at club level, i wouldnt swap him for anyone, but i agree he hasnt proved himself at rep level so it a bit hard to say he's the best in the world.
@stryker said:@Balmain Tiger said:i think its stupid how people say farah being selected is favoritism..
if this was the case im sure we would see lawrence and galloway also
Probably would have if they weren't injured…...
Point is though that Sheens has two guys in his squad that are far better suited to being the bench utility i.e. Cronk and Lewis.
You cant blame other supporters for claiming bias for chucking a specialist hooker in as the utility, the fact that he had very little impact is only fueling the fire
@Moh said:@stryker said:@Balmain Tiger said:i think its stupid how people say farah being selected is favoritism..
if this was the case im sure we would see lawrence and galloway also
Probably would have if they weren't injured…...
Point is though that Sheens has two guys in his squad that are far better suited to being the bench utility i.e. Cronk and Lewis.
You cant blame other supporters for claiming bias for chucking a specialist hooker in as the utility, the fact that he had very little impact is only fueling the fire
How is Cronk a better utility?
@G. Strombolli said:Looks like Robbie is going to get another chance:
http://www.smh.com.au/news/lhqnews/half-empty-lockyer-jt-to-lift/2009/11/03/1257010197212.html?page=fullpage" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;
Cameron Smith will be rested and Robbie will be starting hooker. I hope, for his sake, he goes into the game with the nerves under control and he has a blinder. There will be plenty of points on offer, Robbie has to take advantage.