Farah/Taylor Thread...

@bobo125 said:
It's amazing that some people here are still talking about Farah like he's the problem.
The position the Tigers are in is because of one person and one person only.
It was that person that triggered all this bs and it's that's same person that the team are not performing under.
As a team, they cannot stand the coach.
They do not believe in anything he has to offer and never have.
And if anyone seriously doubts this….. Why can't he get them up for games.
What is it that he's saying or not saying or doing that's getting absolutely no reaction from them.
His remarks to the media after games are laughable.
And yes - everyone is laughing.
They ain't laughing at Farah... In fact it's all doing the opposite
People want to see oposition fans dislike him blah blah .. What a load of crap.
I'm more concerned that the talk amongst NRL players and managers is that whilst JT is at the Tigers look at ALL other options.
That's the real marker here ! !

I'd love to see you enlighten us all on this bobo. How do you know this situation is entirely Taylor's fault?
How do you know that the team cannot stand him?
How do you know they don't believe in anything he says or has to offer?
 
@innsaneink said:
Ex © and Origin & Broncos stalwart Sam Thaiday starting from the bench...

Manly favourite son Brett Stewart told he can look around for another club

Poor guys

Im sure Ink they will stand firm and start white anting their own club that they love.
 
@bobo125 said:
It's amazing that some people here are still talking about Farah like he's the problem.
The position the Tigers are in is because of one person and one person only.
It was that person that triggered all this bs and it's that's same person that the team are not performing under.
As a team, they cannot stand the coach.
They do not believe in anything he has to offer and never have.
And if anyone seriously doubts this….. Why can't he get them up for games.
What is it that he's saying or not saying or doing that's getting absolutely no reaction from them.
His remarks to the media after games are laughable.
And yes - everyone is laughing.
They ain't laughing at Farah... In fact it's all doing the opposite
People want to see oposition fans dislike him blah blah .. What a load of crap.
I'm more concerned that the talk amongst NRL players and managers is that whilst JT is at the Tigers look at ALL other options.
That's the real marker here ! !

Bobo, sseriously. Taylor might be a tool, but if you think WT are in this position because of one person and one person only, you are kidding yourself.
 
@Swordy said:
@innsaneink said:
Ex © and Origin & Broncos stalwart Sam Thaiday starting from the bench...

Manly favourite son Brett Stewart told he can look around for another club

Poor guys

Im sure Ink they will stand firm and start white anting their own club that they love.

Is amazing the difference when you work with adults
 
@bobo125 said:
It's amazing that some people here are still talking about Farah like he's the problem.
The position the Tigers are in is because of one person and one person only.
It was that person that triggered all this bs and it's that's same person that the team are not performing under.
As a team, they cannot stand the coach.
They do not believe in anything he has to offer and never have.
And if anyone seriously doubts this….. Why can't he get them up for games.
What is it that he's saying or not saying or doing that's getting absolutely no reaction from them.
His remarks to the media after games are laughable.
And yes - everyone is laughing.
They ain't laughing at Farah... In fact it's all doing the opposite
People want to see oposition fans dislike him blah blah .. What a load of crap.
I'm more concerned that the talk amongst NRL players and managers is that whilst JT is at the Tigers look at ALL other options.

Maybe they shouldn't have followed Robbie's lead and had the last Coach punted. They're not good enough to determine who does or doesn't Coach them.
 
@Pawsandclaws said:
It's amazing when you have a coach such as Bennett who can coach, has excellent communication skills and is respected.

Just talking to some ex knights players about this today. :wink:
 
@Pawsandclaws said:
It's amazing when you have a coach such as Bennett who can coach, has excellent communication skills and is respected.

It's amazing when you don't have a player that indermines the coach…...... Seriously, give it up.
 
@Blaze said:
@Pawsandclaws said:
It's amazing when you have a coach such as Bennett who can coach, has excellent communication skills and is respected.

It's amazing when you don't have a player that indermines the coach…...... Seriously, give it up.

Nice deflection but this is about coaching ability, not the players. Go re familiarise yourself with the pre match interview with Freddie last week. Just plain embarrassing and you get the sense of why JT could never inspire a team.
 
@Pawsandclaws said:
@Blaze said:
@Pawsandclaws said:
It's amazing when you have a coach such as Bennett who can coach, has excellent communication skills and is respected.

It's amazing when you don't have a player that indermines the coach…...... Seriously, give it up.

Nice deflection but this is about coaching ability, not the players. Go re familiarise yourself with the pre match interview with Freddie last week. Just plain embarrassing and you get the sense of why JT could never inspire a team.

Good to see you branching out and discussing a range of topics involving the Wests Tigers…
 
@Boonboon2 said:
@Milky said:
I'll take Snake

Stewart has been in horrible form this year - have a look at his stats v other years - may as well not be playing

Haven't seen him play this year tbh, was just thinking outside the box.

1\. Stewart
6\. Tedesco
7\. Moses/Brooks

Then in about two years Papahyuzen comes in for Brett
 
Taylors biggest failure for me is his inability to coach what's in front of him.
Coming to the club he mentions that an attacking style only worked once but while he wanted a defensive style with low errors he failed to procure that style of player including a good goal kicker.
He stuck with 2 young halves that are the real problem released Tapau so he have a side which lack forward strength and toughness without a good kicker and goal kicker and he wastes club money getting Ballin acting like the real problem is Farah.
Personally I was real disappointed in Farahs role in Potters axing however he is still a 1 club man who worked hard to keep players there and is still the best hooker at the club and one of the best in the game.

On top of this he is making the club uninteresting for sponsors and fans alike and dosent seem to much of a game plan.

The release of Tapau to me reflects that Taylor wants to rid the club of all personality so he can dictate.

But with what?
 
@Milky said:
@Boonboon2 said:
@Milky said:
I'll take Snake

Stewart has been in horrible form this year - have a look at his stats v other years - may as well not be playing

Haven't seen him play this year tbh, was just thinking outside the box.

1\. Stewart
6\. Tedesco
7\. Moses/Brooks

Then in about two years Papahyuzen comes in for Brett

I think it would be unwise to go near any Manly players until that investigation has run its course.
 
@Pawsandclaws said:
@Blaze said:
@Pawsandclaws said:
It's amazing when you have a coach such as Bennett who can coach, has excellent communication skills and is respected.

It's amazing when you don't have a player that indermines the coach…...... Seriously, give it up.

Nice deflection but this is about coaching ability, not the players. Go re familiarise yourself with the pre match interview with Freddie last week. Just plain embarrassing and you get the sense of why JT could never inspire a team.

I'm familiar with the interview, there was nothing embarrassing about it. Your hatred and ability to deflect anything and everything onto Taylor without actual facts to support it apart from your point of view is beyond ridiculous, you don't like the guy, good for you. But don't try and tell us the inner workings of the team and its personalities and relationships. Simple fact is you don't know, nor does anyone else on here, and that's fine. But give it a rest mate, I struggle to find any post of yours that doesn't have a go at Taylor. That's fine, your point is made. Thanks for that. Same as I THINK Farah is the one upsetting the team harmony, difference is I don't write 20 odd posts about it on every thread everyday… Enjoy your night.
 
@goldcoast tiger said:
@Pawsandclaws said:
It's amazing when you have a coach such as Bennett who can coach, has excellent communication skills and is respected.

Those brown paper bags sure buy you a lot of respect!!

Tevita Pangai rang Bennett because he wanted to play under him!

Is he any relation to David Pangai who played for Balmain and WTs under 20s and went to NQ?
 
@Blaze said:
@Pawsandclaws said:
@Blaze said:
@Pawsandclaws said:
It's amazing when you have a coach such as Bennett who can coach, has excellent communication skills and is respected.

It's amazing when you don't have a player that indermines the coach…...... Seriously, give it up.

Nice deflection but this is about coaching ability, not the players. Go re familiarise yourself with the pre match interview with Freddie last week. Just plain embarrassing and you get the sense of why JT could never inspire a team.

I'm familiar with the interview, there was nothing embarrassing about it. Your hatred and ability to deflect anything and everything onto Taylor without actual facts to support it apart from your point of view is beyond ridiculous, you don't like the guy, good for you. But don't try and tell us the inner workings of the team and its personalities and relationships. Simple fact is you don't know, nor does anyone else on here, and that's fine. But give it a rest mate, I struggle to find any post of yours that doesn't have a go at Taylor. That's fine, your point is made. Thanks for that. Same as I THINK Farah is the one upsetting the team harmony, difference is I don't write 20 odd posts about it on every thread everyday… Enjoy your night.[/quote
\
\
\
\
Sorry Blaze I'm not sure how your post above ended under my name.
\
\
you just wrote another one :smiley: and it didn't have a single fact to back that up

Most people's problems with Taylor are there in front of you on the field , and in Pressos on almost any game day, and in a lot of his interviews. And selections before the ( mythical or not) Bucketts is alleged to have joined him in selections.

Whereas most of the comments about Farah are to do with things that no one would really know for sure about unless they were there. This last eruption seems to have come from a comment Robbie made in answer to a question that he was asked.
When asked how did he feel about the threat to be dropped, He answered that it hurt, and he'd never forget it.
To me, that's a perfectly normal answer for any one to give .
To my knowledge ( correct me if I'm wrong). he never said anything about JT, and I and a lot of people took it as meaning that he was talking about The feelings itself. He didn't bag JT for doing it, ( no matter what he thought) .
Reports , supposedly from someone who seems to have more info than you or me , say that Farah had no problem with Taylor, and was training hard and there was no problems

His ducks and Drakes with the hooker position this week have set the media off again.
I was a supporter of Taylor coming here at the start, , not just because of Potter, but because I genuinely thought that he would do a good job here . but instead I've seem no evidence that he's improved any thing here except maybe our injuries situation, it seemed that that was the case early , but I don't have any figures to really back that up . Our Halves have gone backwards, and seems to not know how to help them.
And it seems that he is prepared to disrupt the club at any cost to try again to force
Farah out.
 
@goldcoast tiger said:
you just wrote another one :smiley: and it didn't have a single fact to back that up

Most people's problems with Taylor are there in front of you on the field , and in Pressos on almost any game day, and in a lot of his interviews. And selections before the ( mythical or not) Bucketts is alleged to have joined him in selections.

Whereas most of the comments about Farah are to do with things that no one would really know for sure about unless they were there. This last eruption seems to have come from a comment Robbie made in answer to a question that he was asked.
When asked how did he feel about the threat to be dropped, He answered that it hurt, and he'd never forget it.
To me, that's a perfectly normal answer for any one to give .
To my knowledge ( correct me if I'm wrong). he never said anything about JT, and I and a lot of people took it as meaning that he was talking about The feelings itself. He didn't bag JT for doing it, ( no matter what he thought) .
Reports , supposedly from someone who seems to have more info than you or me , say that Farah had no problem with Taylor, and was training hard and there was no problems

His ducks and Drakes with the hooker position this week have set the media off again.
I was a supporter of Taylor coming here at the start, , not just because of Potter, but because I genuinely thought that he would do a good job here . but instead I've seem no evidence that he's improved any thing here except maybe our injuries situation, it seemed that that was the case early , but I don't have any figures to really back that up . Our Halves have gone backwards, and seems to not know how to help them.
And it seems that he is prepared to disrupt the club at any cost to try again to force
Farah out.

Did you write out that 20 line whinge fest all over again or did you just copy and paste it from somewhere else you'd moaned it?
 
Back
Top