N
newtiger
Guest
@851 said in [Garner suspended](/post/1047568) said:
Because he didn't have any carry over points and was free to play this round either way.
Garner suspended
- Thread starter innsaneink
- Start date
Because he didn't have any carry over points and was free to play this round either way.
N
newtiger
Guest
As much as I don't like Gus Gould, he said the other day that all these decisions ( MRC, Judiciary, Referees) are controlled by the knobs of the NRL.
I looks like he is right, just another way to try and squeeze us out of the NRL.
I looks like he is right, just another way to try and squeeze us out of the NRL.
The reason Garner was suspended is he had carry over points so taking an early plea still cost him a game..
The joke is the carry over point weren't for the same offence it was a high tackle from last season not dangerous contact..
The whole system needs an overhaul..he wasn't suspended because he wears a Wests Tigers jersey ..he was suspended because the system is flawed..
The joke is the carry over point weren't for the same offence it was a high tackle from last season not dangerous contact..
The whole system needs an overhaul..he wasn't suspended because he wears a Wests Tigers jersey ..he was suspended because the system is flawed..
Tiger_Steve
New member
@Geo said in [Garner suspended](/post/1047607) said:
At an exponential rate I’m struggling to agree with this. There was a segment on fox tonight showing the favouritism towards the storm in how long a defender lies on the tackled player. Blatant favouritism. It’s just becoming ridiculous.
Tigerlily
Well-known member
Well! The idiots at Nrl Hq have set an unrealistic standard/precedence of how the human body is supposed to stop mid-action within a matter of seconds, which is anatomically impossible to do unless your playing freeze frame..
Tim Sheens
Well-known member
@Tiger_Steve said in [Garner suspended](/post/1047611) said:
What show please @Tiger_Steve?
hobbo1
Well-known member
@bathursttiger said in [Garner suspended](/post/1047606) said:
Same with me in regards to Gus “bull frog” Gould ..
But I’d love to see him oust Greenberg and his cronies from the NRL Penthouse
Gus does love Leichhardt on a Sunday afternoon!
@Tiger_Steve said in [Garner suspended](/post/1047611) said:
Oh I agree there ...but that has nothing to do with the flawed judicial system..Any player who has carry over points faces suspension for a grade 1 charge taking the plea wont save them so you fight the charge
tiger05premier
Well-known member
The NRL are the most disgraceful and unfair sporting organization on the planet
Garner plays for rorters or donkeys there wouldn't even of been a sinbinning or suspension
Todd Greenburg is a dud and should walk away from the job
Garner plays for rorters or donkeys there wouldn't even of been a sinbinning or suspension
Todd Greenburg is a dud and should walk away from the job
Tigerlily
Well-known member
@Geo said in [Garner suspended](/post/1047607) said:
In that case why wasn’t he advised to plead guilty instead of not guilty if he had carryovers?...He probably would have got off...👎
hobbo1
Well-known member
@Geo said in [Garner suspended](/post/1047617) said:
Was Lional Hutz Garners lawyer ?
Burgess seems to get off despite having a rap sheet longer than Adolf Hitler !
@Tigerlily said in [Garner suspended](/post/1047619) said:
No if he pleads guilty the reduction plus his carry over points he still misses a game..thar's the point..
If he pleads not guilty and wins he's free to play..no carry over points from the current charge
Tiger_Steve
New member
@formerguest said in [Garner suspended](/post/1047615) said:
I didn’t mention because I wasn’t sure. I was watching repeat of controversy corner. Then watched NRL tonight and then 360. I’m pretty sure it was highlighted on controversy corner
Tim Sheens
Well-known member
@Tiger_Steve said in [Garner suspended](/post/1047626) said:
Thanks. Don't want to watch through all the repeats, so thought I would ask.
@Needaname said in [Garner suspended](/post/1047624) said:
He still has carry over point
Dangerous contact Grade 1 is 120 points..or 1 game..you take the plea that is reduced to 75 points so you are free to play but carry that 75 points
In Garners case he had 35 point from a previous charge so 75 + 35 = 110 so he misses a game even if he takes the early plea
By fighting and losing it's 120 + 35 = 155 ..1 game suspension - 100 points so he now carries 55 points...If he had won he still would have carried the 35 points..as carry over points take 2 seasons to expire..
Well, that was a surprise - who would have thought that Garner would get suspended?
However the bigger question is - who would have thought he would have been penalised and sin binned?
How is it possible for a player to pull out of a tackle in a milli second, assuming that you knew the opposition player had got rid of the ball (in my opinion Garner could not see that the player had released the ball).
The judiciary is made up of former players Mal Cochrane, Michael Buettner, Bradley Clyde, Sean Garlick, Don McKinnon and Bob Lindner - players who should realise that you cannot pull out of a tackle with such limited time - I would suggest that maybe the game has gone past these guys and a new committee should be appointed - players with their fingers on the pulse.
As for the NRL and Greenturd - they keep on wanting to prove that the officials of the game are incompetent and that it is a level playing field.
The supporters of at least 10 NRL teams know this is not true and the whole thing is a sham and becoming more than a joke.
However the bigger question is - who would have thought he would have been penalised and sin binned?
How is it possible for a player to pull out of a tackle in a milli second, assuming that you knew the opposition player had got rid of the ball (in my opinion Garner could not see that the player had released the ball).
The judiciary is made up of former players Mal Cochrane, Michael Buettner, Bradley Clyde, Sean Garlick, Don McKinnon and Bob Lindner - players who should realise that you cannot pull out of a tackle with such limited time - I would suggest that maybe the game has gone past these guys and a new committee should be appointed - players with their fingers on the pulse.
As for the NRL and Greenturd - they keep on wanting to prove that the officials of the game are incompetent and that it is a level playing field.
The supporters of at least 10 NRL teams know this is not true and the whole thing is a sham and becoming more than a joke.
gallagher
Well-known member
@formerguest said in [Garner suspended](/post/1047629) said:
NRL 360