Grant Mayer Opinion Article

the_third

Well-known member
http://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/sport/nrl/wests-tigers-ceo-grant-mayer-deserves-some-tough-questions-from-the-new-board/story-fni3fh9n-1227053175414

**Wests Tigers CEO Grant Mayer deserves some tough questions from the new board
PAUL CRAWLEY**

Let's hope the new Wests Tigers board ask Grant Mayer some tough questions on Wednesday.

This is the man new Tigers Chairwoman Marina Go admits will be charged with the authority to kick the chair from under Mick Potter’s legs after having the coach’s head tied to a noose for the past two seasons.

As Chief Executive, Mayer ruled over this rabble during the most explosive and divided period in the joint venture’s history.

Now, apparently, he will on Wednesday make a recommendation on why Potter should be sacked.

Throughout his period as coach Potter has had little, if any, input into player retention.

He never even got to choose his coaching assistants.

This might not seem like a big deal from outside but any NRL head coach will tell you that loyalty just might be the most important asset you can have.

Mick Potter never had this.

Throughout his tenure his assistant’s Todd Payten and David Kidwell made no secret of their desire to have Potter’s job.

As a result, this undermined the coach’s authority within the playing group.

From almost the get-go there were rumours, coming out of the club, that Potter’s position was under threat.

Potter finally admitted as much following last weekend’s final game, that he had been coaching with his hands tied behind his back. But what if he had full support?
\
\
When Wayne Bennett was in his early years at Brisbane, he had a chairman called Paul Morgan.

In those early years Bennett too was a dead man walking, given he didn’t have the backing of the club’s most powerful player Wally Lewis.

But he had Porky’s support, and that proved crucial. The chairman made a tough decision, to

let Lewis go and keep Bennett. The rest, as they say, is history.

This year Mayer brought in Brian Smith to do a mid-season review of the club’s coaching structures, which could only have one conclusion.

Yet despite this Potter defied the undermining to have the Tigers in contention for the finals until that fateful board meeting in July that was publicly leaked before the crucial game against St George Illawarra.

The Tigers went on to lose six straight after that before their final round win over Cronulla.

Mick Potter is not to blame for how the Tigers’ season finished — but someone is.

Let’s hope the new board works out who before they make a final decision on who will coach the Tigers in 2015.
 
"Let's hope the new Wests Tigers board ask Grant Mayer some tough questions on Wednesday.
Mick Potter is not to blame for how the Tigers’ season finished — but someone is.
Let’s hope the new board works out who before they make a final decision on who will coach the Tigers in 2015."
 
time for both to go, me thinks. mayer is a snake in the grass. Potter not sold on his player selection or his game plans, comes across as a mouse rather than a lion, which is what we need.
 
If Mick Potter has the blowtorch put on him this week,Mayer should have it turned up full bore on him ,he could have stopped a lot of the rubbish that went on this season by being a strong CEO,instead of running and hiding he could have answered the tough questions people asked.."..

Weak as p..s him having the last say on Potters future…..
 
Whilst I'm all for looking into what has happened in the past few weeks and months, I think we could get easily trapped staring into our belly button too long…

Lets look to the future. Work out what we need to move forward...
 
The article in regards to Lewis ,Bennett and Porky isn't quite correct

Porky knew what decision the club had to make , but to find out whether they had the right man (Bennett) he left him to make the right call

Ask anyone who knows Bennett , he hires them and he fires them

Back to the main issue , the minute we knew that Mayer was making the call we knew the fate of Potter

But that means Mayer has had no one of significance make any judgements on him

Smith didn't if you believe what Mayer said on radio a month ago

So who is passing judgement on Mayer's 2014 season

Jack Frost ,Easter Bunny and Santa Claus ,that's who
 
I'd go with Santa…jolly fellow gets the joy done once a Year
 
@foreveratiger said:
Sounds like Mayer should be the one sacked , the guy sounds like a Salesman ? and you know what they say about Salesman?

My exact words from 12 months ago … But not many agreed.
The only thing that will keep Mayer here is if he is under contract. He couldn't possibly be retained on performance.
 
Who in the right mind instigate a football operations review right in the middle of the season, unless trying to find justifications to do something drastic like sacking the coach. Obviously leading on from this, there bounds to be ramifications on the rest of the club including the players. The rest is history. The whole thing is completely unprofessional, lack of leadership, not just on the part of the CEO, who should take the lion share of the blame, but the Board who kept silent throughout the whole sorry saga. It is good that a new look Board had now taken over. Hopefully they will review the entire season's performance, including the CEO's, learn from it and prepare for the better in 2015.

@Knuckles said:
@foreveratiger said:
Sounds like Mayer should be the one sacked , the guy sounds like a Salesman ? and you know what they say about Salesman?

My exact words from 12 months ago … But not many agreed.
The only thing that will keep Mayer here is if he is under contract. He couldn't possibly be retained on performance.

\

@the third said:
http://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/sport/nrl/wests-tigers-ceo-grant-mayer-deserves-some-tough-questions-from-the-new-board/story-fni3fh9n-1227053175414

**Wests Tigers CEO Grant Mayer deserves some tough questions from the new board
PAUL CRAWLEY**

Let's hope the new Wests Tigers board ask Grant Mayer some tough questions on Wednesday.

This is the man new Tigers Chairwoman Marina Go admits will be charged with the authority to kick the chair from under Mick Potter’s legs after having the coach’s head tied to a noose for the past two seasons.

As Chief Executive, Mayer ruled over this rabble during the most explosive and divided period in the joint venture’s history.

Now, apparently, he will on Wednesday make a recommendation on why Potter should be sacked.

Throughout his period as coach Potter has had little, if any, input into player retention.

He never even got to choose his coaching assistants.

This might not seem like a big deal from outside but any NRL head coach will tell you that loyalty just might be the most important asset you can have.

Mick Potter never had this.

Throughout his tenure his assistant’s Todd Payten and David Kidwell made no secret of their desire to have Potter’s job.

As a result, this undermined the coach’s authority within the playing group.

From almost the get-go there were rumours, coming out of the club, that Potter’s position was under threat.

Potter finally admitted as much following last weekend’s final game, that he had been coaching with his hands tied behind his back. But what if he had full support?
\
\
When Wayne Bennett was in his early years at Brisbane, he had a chairman called Paul Morgan.

In those early years Bennett too was a dead man walking, given he didn’t have the backing of the club’s most powerful player Wally Lewis.

But he had Porky’s support, and that proved crucial. The chairman made a tough decision, to

let Lewis go and keep Bennett. The rest, as they say, is history.

This year Mayer brought in Brian Smith to do a mid-season review of the club’s coaching structures, which could only have one conclusion.

Yet despite this Potter defied the undermining to have the Tigers in contention for the finals until that fateful board meeting in July that was publicly leaked before the crucial game against St George Illawarra.

The Tigers went on to lose six straight after that before their final round win over Cronulla.

Mick Potter is not to blame for how the Tigers’ season finished — but someone is.

Let’s hope the new board works out who before they make a final decision on who will coach the Tigers in 2015.
 
@Menacing Tiger said:
Who in the right mind instigate a football operations review right in the middle of the season, unless trying to find justifications to do something drastic like sacking the coach.

Well, I don't particularly like GM, but instigating this report is extremely good business practice. A new board is coming in and a basic requirement of this is to get an independent review of this type of thing to ensure the new board has full and frank independent advice.

Whether or not it was done the right way is another story…
 
If I'm not mistaken, it has been said many times that the structural review was mandated by the NRL, it was not something Mayer just dreamed up to rock the boat?

Certainly Mayer deserves the same board scrutiny that Potter will receive. But Paul Crawley has really written quite an opinion piece. It can be argued that it is Mick Potter's responsibility to get results from his team and coaching staff, even if not cherry-picked. Sometimes you gotta work with the tools you have.

I don't have an opinion one way or the other, I am too far removed from actual legitimate knowledge of how the club runs, and all the media does it stoke the fire, stir the pot. This Tigers saga, just like the Sharks and ASADA, sells papers and the media are glad for it to rumble on.

I'm with ink - let's make a decision and move on. It's amazing how all the "disjointed board" gear died the minute the new board came in.
 
Let's hope Mayer says something about why potter should keep his job not only why he shouldn't, and let's also hope the new board asks Mayer why he should keep his job as well

_Posted using RoarFEED V.4_
 
One good thing about the new board,all the hidden agendas from either side hopefully stop now,complete business acumen is now needed and is in place.no more secrets.no more jobs for the boys,and absolutely no more BACKSTABBING…...
 
@marzie said:
Grant Mayer makes me nervous and I don't like him. Get the feeling he shouldn't be trusted and really hoping we can find a new CEO. There's just something about that guy it gives me a bad feeling.

Anyone else?

Mayer got sacked from manly when the club was in trouble, and he caused most of it.
 
@bathursttiger said:
Mayer got sacked from manly when the club was in trouble, and he caused most of it.

Stop making stuff up, Mayer was the casualty of a very public spat between the owners, Max Delmege and Scott Penn, Mayer had a good relationship with Penn, Max Delmege won the battle and Mayer paid the price of his relationship with Penn in mid 2009.

_“Mayer was a pawn in Delmege’s bitter political dispute with co-owner and chairman Scott Penn, who is a strong Mayer supporter. Another Mayer supporter to suffer was coach Des Hasler. Despite the club’s outstanding success under his reign, Hasler’s contract extension wasn’t as cut and dried as it ought to have been, and he was forced to accept the insertion of KPIs as part of his new deal.”_
**By Matthew ONeill, 25 Jun 2009**

_Manly chairman Scott Penn paid tribute to Mayer, who took over at the Sea Eagles in 2006 and was contracted to the club until October this year.\
\
"Grant came to Manly at a time when the Sea Eagles were struggling off the field and formed a wonderful partnership with (coach) Des Hasler to take the team to successive grand finals, including the 2008 premiership and 2009 World Club Challenge," Penn said in the statement.\
\
**"Grant leaves the club in good shape, having increased revenue more than 30 per cent, more than doubling membership and tripling merchandise sales as well as signing our new major sponsor.**\
\
"We are a much stronger organisation as a result of Grant's leadership."_
**NRL.com News - Wed, Jun 17, 2009 - 10:14PM**
 
Back
Top