Hit on Groat

@innsaneink said:
No need to get all defensive, We're here to discuss things 'champ', you can make a statement and leave it at that, however some may like to respond to that statement.
You did prove my point, you finally see the signing(s) are a result of a dire situation yet on the other hand say teams have enough players to have an extra two waiting for a shoulder charge that may never happen..
Its clear right now we dont have enough. We will struggle to field a first grade squad next week.

Let's agree to disagree, but my stance is that despite the injury situation we are in we could still find 1 or 2 players each week from 20's, NSW Cup etc.

Plus, I have offered another thought regarding penalising the offending team through reduced interchange, but I didn't get much stick for that suggestion so you may have missed it :wink:
 
For what it's worth Teo will get 3 weeks….4 if he contests and loses. No good to us though :unamused:

Source.....Foxsports.
 
@Montague Street said:
@innsaneink said:
@Montague Street said:
Keep It Simple **<big>Stupid</big>** (KISS)
Any tackle above the chest is illegal.
The chest is defined as the nipple
The consequence is a send off to offending player and a penalty to the offended team.
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_

You got one part correct.
Ridiculous idea

Most pea brained thing Ive ever read tbh

The suggestion that all tackles above the nipple line should be banned has been promoted by Dr Nathan Gibbs. And I agree.
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_

Thought it was 'armpit' he was suggesting? In any case probs the same horizontal point! Its of some interest that none of these accidental or careless shots never take out a players larynx, moreover tend to make contact between the chin and the forehead. Just co-incidence I suppose?
 
Brisbane's Te'o to miss two matches:

Brisbane's Ben Te'o will be sidelined for the next two NRL matches after being found guilty of a grade three dangerous contact charge, before successfully getting the offence downgraded to a grade two offence at an eventful judiciary hearing on Wednesday.

The Kiwi back-rower was initially hit with a four-game ban following a marathon hearing lasting almost two hours in the wake of his shoulder charge on Wests Tigers prop Matt Groat that forced him off the field with concussion last Friday.

However, immediately after the verdict was delivered by the three-man panel of Michael Buettner, Don McKinnon and Chris McKenna, the Broncos' counsel Peter Shields applied for a second hearing to fight the grading.

That lasted almost 45 minutes, and saw video footage presented of incidents involving St George Illawarra's Leeson Ah Mau and Canberra's Joel Thompson which Shield claimed were similar to Te'o's but were deemed to be grade one offences.

The panel took just over five minutes to make their second decision and the 25-year-old will now be free to return in round nine against the Warriors.

Broncos' chief executive Paul White said the verdict vindicated the club's decision to make the trip to Sydney.

"The decision has made it a worthwhile effort in what has been a long night for all concerned," White said.

"Our focus is now on facing Canberra this weekend."

The decision to find Te'o guilty places the future of the shoulder charge very much in doubt, in light of the one-match imposed on Canterbury's Frank Pritchard earlier in the season for a challenge to the head of Penrith's David Simmonds.

Shield earlier presented nine still shots of the incident and asked Te'o to explain in great detail what he was doing in each one in a bid to prove his innocence.

Footage of Groat leaving the field at Allianz Stadium was also presented, with Shield arguing that there were no lacerations to his face and little evidence to suggest Te'o had caught him on the head, and not the upper body.

Te'o and NRL counsel Peter Kite then had a verbal sparring match, with the player fighting his corner under questioning, claiming his the challenge was fair, with Kite arguing that there was no evidence to suggest he had not hit Groat in the head.

"I could see he had no footwork as he is a front-rower, and I had watched video of him all week," Te'o said.

"I knew he would take off straight up so I shortened my step to get my timing right and hit him above the ball and into the shoulder. I was hard and fast and he was hard and fast."

However, Kite's argument proved to be successful and a decision was made by the panel in less than 10 minutes to find Te'o guilty.

Below is the Ben Te'o tackle in question and some similar shoulder charges from season's gone by.

Source: http://www.nrl.com/broncos-teo-to-miss-two-games/tabid/10874/newsid/66831/default.aspx
 
Back
Top