Inglis try or no try?

[fulleightyminutes]

I don' enjoy losing as a Blues Fan, but to lose from that try made it feel more than usually bitter. He dropped the ball fair and square.

 

[Goose]

It hit Inglis lower forearm after it was dislodged, so even with that ridiculous played at decision, it is still a knock on, disgraceful decision.
The penalty for the bird tackle was a disgrace as well.
Very frustrated, I can cop a loss and hate blaming refs, but feel they had undue influence on this game
\
\
Posted using RoarFEED

 

[ball_main]

A knock on every day of the year
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_

 

[bradills]

Any way you look at it the decision was wrong ! The ball was knocked on . So if and I Mean IF Robbie actually played at the ball with his feet the correct decision should have been a penalty try not a try as was awarded. I don't think any of tonight's referees can hold there positions after tonight's performance ! On the plus Robbie was fantastic hope that cements his spot now !
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_

 

[Flippedy]

I don' enjoy losing as a Blues Fan, but to lose from that try made it feel more than usually bitter. He dropped the ball fair and square.

The only consolation, fulleighty, is that we didn't actually lose because of that try. QLD were already in front when they 'scored' it and I don't know if NSW would've scored again anyway - they certainly didn't look likely. Still, we'll never know.

 

[clokan]

I feel sorry for Inglis, knowing his record try wasn't a try, he dropped it. In years to come he look back on it and know that he broke the record on a lie 😢

 

[twenty20]

…...and they will say it had no bearing on the final result, as it was 12-10 at the time. It does my head in that, no one thinks a scrum feed to the opposing team in the last 10 minutes doesn't change the course of play for precisely - THE NEXT 10 MINUTES!

 

[ball_main]

It hit Inglis lower forearm after it was dislodged, so even with that ridiculous played at decision, it is still a knock on, disgraceful decision.
The penalty for the bird tackle was a disgrace as well.
Very frustrated, I can cop a loss and hate blaming refs, but feel they had undue influence on this game

Exactly. It hit his arm after it was knocked out. Its a No try since 1908
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_

 

[Yossarian]

Ricky Stuart on Fox News now not only refusing to comment on the referees but not letting Paul Gallen comment on the referees.

 

[stryker]

Its a No try since 1908
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_

Well said Gus….

 

[Tigerdave]

knock on, I'm not sure whether the Blues would have won the game anyway if it wasn't given though, but with 10 minutes to go…... at any rate it'll be the big thing they'll be talking about in the morning.

 

[stryker]

…...and they will say it had no bearing on the final result, as it was 12-10 at the time. It does my head in that, no one thinks a scrum feed to the opposing team in the last 10 minutes doesn't change the course of play for precisely - THE NEXT 10 MINUTES!

Mate if it wasnt a try it was a QLD penalty…rest easy in the knowledge that they would have scored from that next set.

 

[Yossarian]

…...and they will say it had no bearing on the final result, as it was 12-10 at the time. It does my head in that, no one thinks a scrum feed to the opposing team in the last 10 minutes doesn't change the course of play for precisely - THE NEXT 10 MINUTES!

Mate if it wasnt a try it was a QLD penalty…rest easy in the knowledge that they would have scored from that next set.

Should have been a penalty when Slater slid in with his knees when Farah tried to score.

 

[tiger_sean]

…...and they will say it had no bearing on the final result, as it was 12-10 at the time. It does my head in that, no one thinks a scrum feed to the opposing team in the last 10 minutes doesn't change the course of play for precisely - THE NEXT 10 MINUTES!

Mate if it wasnt a try it was a QLD penalty…rest easy in the knowledge that they would have scored from that next set.

:laughing: If you don't think Inglis knocked it on you are delusional. Knock on every day of the week.

 

[Tiger_Watto]

I feel sorry for Inglis, knowing his record try wasn't a try, he dropped it. In years to come he look back on it and know that he broke the record on a lie 😢

I don't think Inglis will give a rats considering he is gona smash the record by at least another 13 Tries…

No Try, Scrum to Qld would've been my ruling.

The Referees cost Qld plenty also by there poor decisions to not penalties NSW in the play the balls... But I doubt all you sooky la la NSW supporters have factored that into your rants about being robbed. (oh, and on being robbed, wasn't Qld still ahead by 2 points before the Inglis Try?)

 

[cnx_tigers]

Robbie didn't play at it….......and EVEN IF HE DID, Inglis knocked it forward after it hit Robbie's boot.

A knock on. EVERY. SINGLE. DAY. OF. THE. WEEK.

Ruined a great game.

 

[tig_prmz]

if robbie stuck his foot out on purpose… it's an 8 point try.

if it was an accident, then a knock on, as simple as that.

what the ref did was totally wrong.

also, there is no way robbie did it on purpose, u can clearly see it in motion that inglis tried to do it quickly, and simply got hindered by robbie's foot.

 

[Hit_or_Miss]

If that happens on the 2nd tackle on the half way it's a knock on…. What's the difference????
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_

 

[Mistadobalina]

If that try wasn't awarded we would have had an extra 3 minutes of game time AND possession. If we could've taken that last set to the 5th tackle, we were every chance of scoring.

 

[shane2801]

NSW whingers just be pleased you were at least competetive. Hopefully the idiot NSW selectors make wholesome changes for the next game and QLD put 50 them.

LOVE THE MAROONS!