OFFICIAL Jock Madden #244

Batmans Parents said:
If you could actually read or were capable of doing your own research, that was regarding when Cooper Cronk left and they didn't have a replacement half. So you confirmed that there was interest nearly 5 years ago? Not what we were talking about and just another example of you being deliberately dishonest.

I know reading comprehension clearly isn't your strength but go back to my previous post and you'll have your answer.
Click to expand...
You still have not answered my question. What NRL clubs would be interested in Maguire? Fess up.
 
pawsandclaws1 said:
Name the NRL clubs interested in Maguire? No deflection just name them
Click to expand...

I already answered your question but since I'm debating a simpleton, I'll repeat. If an NRL gig became available and Madge was sacked, there'd be interest from that club. Of the 16 current clubs, Tigers are pretty much the only ones with a coach on the hot seat.

Now name me a club outside Newcastle and the Bulldogs that have any interest in Brooks?
 
Demps said:
I don't understand the appeal either.

Maybe it's loyalty towards some one who showed loyalty to us during the dark era when all our favourites were talking out of the club.

Either way, everything you said is correct and I believe this will be his final year at the club.
Click to expand...
I thinks that loyalty plays a part for sure, for me its the level of crap directed at him, even if he has an OK game many on here blame him for the loss. Against Newcastle he did enough, though those around him failed to take advantage, (he put the ball on a platter for Laurie). I don't think Brooks is one of the elite halfbacks in the game, but unless we can find a better replacement then he is what we have. I prefer to support him that blame him for all our woes.

The way some talk, they expect everything Brooks does should lead to a try, sometime its only one or two things that win a game. Sometime even the greats sides only just win, because they convert the limited opportunities created by their haves, we don't seem to.
 
Batmans Parents said:
I already answered your question but since I'm debating a simpleton, I'll repeat. If an NRL gig became available and Madge was sacked, there'd be interest from that club. Of the 16 current clubs, Tigers are pretty much the only ones with a coach on the hot seat.

Now name me a club outside Newcastle and the Bulldogs that have any interest in Brooks?
Click to expand...
I see you're not going to answer my question. Well there you go. As Keating said "all tip no iceberg".
 
pawsandclaws1 said:
I see you're not going to answer my question. Well there you go. As Keating said "all tip no iceberg".
Click to expand...
I answered it. You just don't like the answer and like a toddler, you put your fingers in your ear. I can't help you and am not going to try to. As the saying goes; "Arguing with an idiot is like playing chess with a pidgeon. It'll just knock over all the pieces, poo on the board, and strut about like it's won anyway."
 
Jock is certainly a bright spot from the night.
He's been handling first grade well and I'd love to see him stick around. He seems more assertive than brooks.

Watching the game I was thinking, perhaps, considering our hooking problems, we could try:
9. Brooks
7. Madden
6. Douhei/Hastings?
 
Kul said:
Jock is certainly a bright spot from the night.
He's been handling first grade well and I'd love to see him stick around. He seems more assertive than brooks.

Watching the game I was thinking, perhaps, considering our hooking problems, we could try:
9. Brooks
7. Madden
6. Douhei/Hastings?
Click to expand...
Don't see why not. In his limited time there yesterday, Brooks service was better than both Liddle and Simpkins. AD at 6 and Hastings at lock could be very intersting
 
Kul said:
Jock is certainly a bright spot from the night.
He's been handling first grade well and I'd love to see him stick around. He seems more assertive than brooks.

Watching the game I was thinking, perhaps, considering our hooking problems, we could try:
9. Brooks
7. Madden
6. Douhei/Hastings?
Click to expand...
Worth a shot
 
Kul said:
Jock is certainly a bright spot from the night.
He's been handling first grade well and I'd love to see him stick around. He seems more assertive than brooks.

Watching the game I was thinking, perhaps, considering our hooking problems, we could try:
9. Brooks
7. Madden
6. Douhei/Hastings?
Click to expand...
if only they would try this
 
A member said recently some players are like a diamond in the rough.
This ones cheap at the moment but as history has it, after we put the the effort in raising these kids into first graders we lose them to go to Melbourne to become stars.
Resign this guy whilst still cheap.
He will be valuable next year and beyond.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 2,474 (members: 29, guests: 2,445)
Back
Top