Joel Reddy
- Thread starter shano
- Start date
Balmain_Bug
New member
Joel Reddy in his career, has scored only a few more first grade tries than Dean Collis !! And Collis doesn't even play first grade !!
Gothetigers
New member
Do you think Collis is a better player?
\
\
Posted using RoarFEED
\
\
Posted using RoarFEED
Balmain_Bug
New member
@Gothetigers said:
No I dont think that, Collis is not a better player.
But why buy an Average first grader ?? Why ?? There are blokes playing for BRET, Maggies and the NYC who deserve a start.
But Guns or buy nothing anduse what you have bred.
Gothetigers
New member
@Balmain Bug said:
Fair enough, I live in Brisbane and don't get to see the Reggies or NYC play.
I have always had a high opinion of Reddy and would prefer him over Brown and Ryan. I think playing outside Benji will help his game, certainly an improvement on Robson and Mortimer! Assuming he is not being paid a Kings Ransom he would add depth and potentially a good signing
I can't say I've ever feared Reddy when playing against the Eels. He is good in the air. In saying that he appears to be a solid player who could cover fullback, wing and centre. I don't think he is the 1st choice fullback we are after but I do rate him better than Brown and Beau Ryan on the wing.
@Balmain Bug said:
To be fair Collis had the benefits of playing outside people like Marshall and Prince. Reddy has to deal with people like Robson and Daniel Mortimer…
happy_tiger
Well-known member
Still amazed what others see in Reddy . If you were ranking him against the other 32 top centres in the NRL he would be in the bottom half dozen .
Balmain_Bug
New member
@happy tiger said:
That is probably true.
851
Well-known member
I rate Reddy,he is like Cooper,nothing gets past,I think he will improve our club.
happy_tiger
Well-known member
What position do you think Reddy will play , I'm sure he came to Parra as a fullback and obviously was pushed out by a certain J Hayne
hybrid_tiger
Well-known member
If anyone should move to FB, I think it should be Lote.
happy_tiger
Well-known member
@Drewby said:
Go through the centres in the NRL(starters ) and tell me who he is better than and see if you still think it is ridiculous . City and Country is a joke honestly . Really is used as a selection criteria trial isn't it Drewby . Once you have done the comparison Drewby and you can't tell me the 6 centres Reddy is better you can apologize to me and Bug for your comment .
Jack Reed, Clinton Toopi, Bodene Thompson, Joel Moon, Shaun Berrigan, Jamal Idris, Kane Linnett, Brent Tate, Brad Tighe, Ryan Morgan, Jarrod Croker, Junior Sa’u, Keith Lulia, Ben Pomeroy, Colin Best
all starting this weekend, and i'd say all apart from the dogs would swap their current centre(s) out
all starting this weekend, and i'd say all apart from the dogs would swap their current centre(s) out
EggButterRoll99
New member
According to the smh (sydney morning herald) the tigers are also expected to sign joel reddy this week.
