Josh Addo Carr Contract Discussion

[OzLuke]

Who cares if he doesn't come to WT? In all seriousness, if the so-called marquee signing turned out to be JAC, then we are totally and utterly a basket case.

having a current blues and kangaroo winger coming to us would be a marquee signing. And he appears to have a personality that would ignite a dressing room I personally would rate that move highly.

But what I think a lot of people are more concerned about, and me personally being a Dad, is the welfare of his kids. That personally takes the emphasis off where the guy plays

 

[hsvjones]

(Speaking as a Dad myself) if push comes to shove I’m choosing the welfare of my child/family over a football contract. This could backfire badly on Storm if they don’t release him due to exceptional circumstances.

Agreed mate, in this circumstance I think it is a pretty crappy decision on Storm's part.

Yet when we try and hold a player to his contract we are the bad guys... :man-gesturing-no:

 

[OzLuke]

(Speaking as a Dad myself) if push comes to shove I’m choosing the welfare of my child/family over a football contract. This could backfire badly on Storm if they don’t release him due to exceptional circumstances.

Agreed mate, in this circumstance I think it is a pretty crappy decision on Storm's part.

Yet when we try and hold a player to his contract we are the bad guys... :man-gesturing-no:

I think the difference is that Matterson wanted more money and was vocal about that, JAC is vocal about his kids' wellbeing. No argument really.....

 

[The_Patriot]

Sometimes its better not to drink the kool ade

 

[Milky]

We aren’t even close to getting him...

But the chances of him returning to Storm are 0.

He won’t be there, thats a guarantee.

 

[OzLuke]

We aren’t even close to getting him...

But the chances of him returning to Storm are 0.

He won’t be there, thats a guarantee.

this pessimism or insider knowledge talking?

 

[tiger05premier]

We aren’t even close to getting him...

But the chances of him returning to Storm are 0.

He won’t be there, thats a guarantee.

You seem to know a lot about JAC

 

[Milky]

We aren’t even close to getting him...

But the chances of him returning to Storm are 0.

He won’t be there, thats a guarantee.

this pessimism or insider knowledge talking?

We aren’t even close to getting him...

But the chances of him returning to Storm are 0.

He won’t be there, thats a guarantee.

this pessimism or insider knowledge talking?

Inside

 

[Milky]

We aren’t even close to getting him...

But the chances of him returning to Storm are 0.

He won’t be there, thats a guarantee.

You seem to know a lot about JAC

I know a fair bit about a few players but i refrain from posting if I don’t know its guaranteed..

 

[hsvjones]

We aren’t even close to getting him...

But the chances of him returning to Storm are 0.

He won’t be there, thats a guarantee.

You seem to know a lot about JAC

I know a fair bit about a few players but i refrain from posting if I don’t know its guaranteed..

Fingers crossed he goes to Souths and we get LM long term.. We can only dream

 

[851]

We aren’t even close to getting him...

But the chances of him returning to Storm are 0.

He won’t be there, thats a guarantee.

You seem to know a lot about JAC

I know a fair bit about a few players but i refrain from posting if I don’t know its guaranteed..

Fingers crossed he goes to Souths and we get LM long term.. We can only dream

We could get both with some smart negotiating, but souths will get both, we will get left overs again,

 

[hsvjones]

We aren’t even close to getting him...

But the chances of him returning to Storm are 0.

He won’t be there, thats a guarantee.

You seem to know a lot about JAC

I know a fair bit about a few players but i refrain from posting if I don’t know its guaranteed..

Fingers crossed he goes to Souths and we get LM long term.. We can only dream

We could get both with some smart negotiating, but souths will get both, we will get left overs again,

Unfortunately you would be correct on this .... :face_with_rolling_eyes:

 

[OzLuke]

We aren’t even close to getting him...

But the chances of him returning to Storm are 0.

He won’t be there, thats a guarantee.

You seem to know a lot about JAC

I know a fair bit about a few players but i refrain from posting if I don’t know its guaranteed..

Fingers crossed he goes to Souths and we get LM long term.. We can only dream

I'm going the other way, I would prefer JAC over LM

 

[tiger05premier]

We aren’t even close to getting him...

But the chances of him returning to Storm are 0.

He won’t be there, thats a guarantee.

You seem to know a lot about JAC

I know a fair bit about a few players but i refrain from posting if I don’t know its guaranteed..

So where is he going?

Why not us?

 

[Moh]

@Milky I'd also like to know why you don't reckon we are a chance? Given his apparent passion for our club.

 

[GNR4LIFE]

This forum needs a holiday. A deserted beach with a few cocktails would do some of you wonders.

 

[Roar_Power]

We aren’t even close to getting him...

But the chances of him returning to Storm are 0.

He won’t be there, thats a guarantee.

You seem to know a lot about JAC

I know a fair bit about a few players but i refrain from posting if I don’t know its guaranteed..

Can you say why we are so far from signing him?

 

[Tiger5150]

Milky is an insider now? Wow things change quickly in this forum.

 

[tigerbalm]

We’ve got one insider saying west’s are his preferred club and another insider saying west’s are no chance.

I think it’s safe to say our insiders are more like outhouses.

 

[NT_Tiger]

Its easy to see how information gets twisted on this forum. Milky says "We aren't even close to getting him', and ten posts later that becomes "why you reckon we don't have a chance". Not close to getting him does not necessarily equate to we don't have a chance.