Josh Addo Carr Contract Discussion

[Mossman]

You could make a pretty good first grade team with the players tigers have managed to let go over the last 7 years. Their recruitment and retention programs are severely flawed. Would be bottom 3 in the league

NSG do you know what CCTW is saying about 3 yrs 2.1 million is correct?
Is that done to Tigers?
Some random on The F book said JAC was spotted at concord recently?

 

[new smoking gun]

You could make a pretty good first grade team with the players tigers have managed to let go over the last 7 years. Their recruitment and retention programs are severely flawed. Would be bottom 3 in the league


NSG do you know what CCTW is saying about 3 yrs 2.1 million is correct?
Is that done to Tigers?
Some random on The F book said JAC was spotted at concord recently?

Nothing is official. But that’s the number per season. JAC didn’t seek a release with no where to go. Up to tigers to secure the release now. He’s done his bit

 

[avocadoontoast]

You could make a pretty good first grade team with the players tigers have managed to let go over the last 7 years. Their recruitment and retention programs are severely flawed. Would be bottom 3 in the league


NSG do you know what CCTW is saying about 3 yrs 2.1 million is correct?
Is that done to Tigers?
Some random on The F book said JAC was spotted at concord recently?


Nothing is official. But that’s the number per season. JAC didn’t seek a release with no where to go. Up to tigers to secure the release now. He’s done his bit

$2.1m per season? That seems a lot.

 

[Tigersmurf]

You could make a pretty good first grade team with the players tigers have managed to let go over the last 7 years. Their recruitment and retention programs are severely flawed. Would be bottom 3 in the league

Is this set up for a swap with Josh Reynolds?

 

[momo_amp_medo]

You could make a pretty good first grade team with the players tigers have managed to let go over the last 7 years. Their recruitment and retention programs are severely flawed. Would be bottom 3 in the league


NSG do you know what CCTW is saying about 3 yrs 2.1 million is correct?
Is that done to Tigers?
Some random on The F book said JAC was spotted at concord recently?


Nothing is official. But that’s the number per season. JAC didn’t seek a release with no where to go. Up to tigers to secure the release now. He’s done his bit

$2.1m per season? That seems a lot.

I think it’s just badly written and hopefully the offer is $2.1M over 3 years. Still a hefty sum for a flanker ..... but no doubt a good one.

 

[momo_amp_medo]

You could make a pretty good first grade team with the players tigers have managed to let go over the last 7 years. Their recruitment and retention programs are severely flawed. Would be bottom 3 in the league

Is this set up for a swap with Josh Reynolds?

Yes we all have our letters to Santa for that one.

 

[new smoking gun]

You could make a pretty good first grade team with the players tigers have managed to let go over the last 7 years. Their recruitment and retention programs are severely flawed. Would be bottom 3 in the league

Is this set up for a swap with Josh Reynolds?

Josh probably not allowed to leave the state tbh

 

[GNR4LIFE]

You could make a pretty good first grade team with the players tigers have managed to let go over the last 7 years. Their recruitment and retention programs are severely flawed. Would be bottom 3 in the league

Is this set up for a swap with Josh Reynolds?

Don’t see what use they’d have for Reynolds. If anyone is going to take him off our hands it would be the Dogs. He has a history there, and they are thin with Foran injured. Would have happened already though. No other club will touch him now with his hanging over his head.

 

[krayola]

I think the first priority for Pascoe and co is to secure Addo Carr's signature then worry about negotiating his release for 2020....

Mate I'm beginning to feel that Pascoe is pretty useless at this stuff. Couldn't secure a root in a brothel let alone a good player when one is on offer.

You guys slay me - Pascoe is on a hiding to nothing.

He says nothing, doesn't sign someone - the guy is useless.

He signs someone - the guy is useless.

Exactly what do you want him to do Spud?????

Sign someone to bolster our piss weak backline for a start. Stop promising things he can't deliver. Glad you're happy with our off season recruiting - easily pleased.

Who is on the market that you want... AJ???? Maybe JAC when available (not yet).

Just about everyone else are signed, do not want to come here or are not as good as we have.

On the other side of the coin - do you know who he has made offers for etc.

You and hsvjones are bigger whingers than the whole of the RNS Nursery department.

**You, it seems are a Pascoe hater** - he is doing his best and the best CEO we and Balmain have ever had, Don't know about Western Suburbs.

Pascoe is not a miracle worker. If they don't want to be here, do you want him to physically drag them over to Concord?


You know what? I have never said a bad word about the guy until that recent post, NEVER! So I don't know whose posts you have confused mine with because I have always supported the the guy. I am only just now starting to question his ability to get the job done and I have my reasons for doing so. Whether you agree with them or not, I don't really care.

Feelings mutual Spud.

Just don't like to see a guy made a scapegoat who is trying his best for the club and all of us.

AND NSG - I don't give a stuff what he looks like.

Just see it now ... LM, JAC, Arrow.... they all rejected Tigers in 2019 because Pascoe didn't look like he was going to a dinner party. Lol.


Presentation play a big part. He’s a reflection of the club from the ground up.

He looks like a pretty typical footy fan if you ask me so I'd say that, by your theory, he's got the look just right.

 

[Tiger_Steve]

What are the odds Gagai will finish up at the Gold Coast?


Mal wants him. But gagai ain’t so keen.

Are you Todd Greenberg incognito? Really you’ve got the low down on every deal in the NRL. I’ve never communicated with such a well connected forum member. You’re amazing.

 

[earl]

You could make a pretty good first grade team with the players tigers have managed to let go over the last 7 years. Their recruitment and retention programs are severely flawed. Would be bottom 3 in the league


NSG do you know what CCTW is saying about 3 yrs 2.1 million is correct?
Is that done to Tigers?
Some random on The F book said JAC was spotted at concord recently?


Nothing is official. But that’s the number per season. JAC didn’t seek a release with no where to go. Up to tigers to secure the release now. He’s done his bit

$2.1m per season? That seems a lot.

I love the guy but a winger on that much money who wants to come home. It sounds inflated.

 

[Guest]

You could make a pretty good first grade team with the players tigers have managed to let go over the last 7 years. Their recruitment and retention programs are severely flawed. Would be bottom 3 in the league


NSG do you know what CCTW is saying about 3 yrs 2.1 million is correct?
Is that done to Tigers?
Some random on The F book said JAC was spotted at concord recently?


Nothing is official. But that’s the number per season. JAC didn’t seek a release with no where to go. Up to tigers to secure the release now. He’s done his bit

$2.1m per season? That seems a lot.


I love the guy but a winger on that much money who wants to come home. It sounds inflated.

It's not 2.1 per season...good lord:face_with_rolling_eyes:

 

[Madge]

@willow do you think he will end up coming here for 2020?

 

[Ponyo]

2.1m / 3y = 700,000k p/y
I'd pay the fox bless him

 

[Guest]

@willow do you think he will end up coming here for 2020?

Not sure, Josh has made his intent clear and I know WE are his preferred club. It's going to be up to the WT/Storm/NRL - it's a family welfare situation which is delicate. I totally understand the Storm's position but they have a duty of care to JAC and if being in Sydney is best for his welfare due to personal reasons...well you can start to see the logical argument here...

 

[Spud_Murphy]

2.1m / 3y = 700,000k p/y
I'd pay the fox bless him

Agree he is one winger who is definitely worth it, especially to our team like ours that is lacking genuine pace and try scoring ability.

 

[Ponyo]

2.1m / 3y = 700,000k p/y
I'd pay the fox bless him

Agree he is one winger who is definitely worth it, especially to our team like ours that is lacking genuine pace and try scoring ability.

Add to that - pride in the jersey

 

[Tim Sheens]

2.1m / 3y = 700,000k p/y
I'd pay the fox bless him

Agree he is one winger who is definitely worth it, especially to our team like ours that is lacking genuine pace and try scoring ability.

Add to that - pride in the jersey

He better brush up on his singing skills though and have 26 January as his favourite day to be welcomed by many.

 

[Tiger_Steve]

Could you argue that the Storm are neglecting their duty of care towards JAC by allowing him to sign with us? Just sayin...

 

[Spud_Murphy]

2.1m / 3y = 700,000k p/y
I'd pay the fox bless him

Agree he is one winger who is definitely worth it, especially to our team like ours that is lacking genuine pace and try scoring ability.

Add to that - pride in the jersey

Honestly, it would be the biggest highlight for me since 2005 if JAC were to return to us. I have always struggled with losing him more than any other player we've lost (Tedesco included), especially watching him blossom into the player I always knew he could be at another club, so it would be just brilliant to have him return, bloody brilliant! Praying hard on this one ??